Arguments 1.2-1.3 Flashcards
memorize the direction of support and the q-types and the q stem language that helps us id the q types
How does the AC relate to the argument?
Answer choices will prove the assumption to be true thereby proving the conclusion to be true
Assumption Sufficient
ASSUMPTION BASED QUESTIONS
How does the AC relate to the argument?
ACs will provide information that is “needed” for the assumption to be true.
Assumption necessary
ASSUMPTION BASED QUESTIONS
How does the AC relate to the argument?
ACs will make the assumption less likely to be true
Weaken
ASSUMPTION BASED QUESTIONS
How does the AC relate to the argument?
ACs will describe the assumption/flaw
Flaw
ASSUMPTION BASED QUESTIONS
How does the AC relate to the argument?
ACs will ask a question that addresses the assumption
Evaluate
ASSUMPTION BASED QUESTIONS
How does the AC relate to the argument?
ACs will make the assumption more likely to be true
Stregthen
ASSUMPTION BASED QUESTIONS
How does the AC relate to the argument?
will have a correct AC that contains an argument that displays the same assumption as the argument in question
Parallel Flaw
ASSUMPTION BASED QUESTIONS
How does the AC relate to the argument?
ACs will state the assumption of the argument in language that is slightly broader or stronger than the perfect assumption.
Reasoning Conforms
ASSUMPTION BASED QUESTIONS
Question Stem Language
conclusion will follow logically if AC is true | conclusion will be properly drawn if AC is true | AC justifies the conclusion
Assumption sufficient
ASSUMPTION BASED QUESTIONS
Question Stem Language
assumption required | assumption on which the argument depends, relies, needs | assumption underlies argument
Assumption necessary
ASSUMPTION BASED QUESTIONS
Question Stem Language
AC strengthens | AC supports | AC most justifies | argument supported by the AC
Stregthen
ASSUMPTION BASED QUESTIONS
Question Stem Language
undermines | calls into question
Weaken
ASSUMPTION BASED QUESTIONS
Question Stem Language
error in reasoning | vulnerable to criticism
Flaw
ASSUMPTION BASED QUESTIONS
Question Stem Language
evaluate | evaluation | validity
Evaluate
ASSUMPTION BASED QUESTIONS
Question Stem Language
error in reasoning similar to which one of the following | flawed reasoning most similar
Parallel Flaw
ASSUMPTION BASED QUESTIONS
Question Stem Language
argument or reasoning conforms to the following principle
Reasoning Conforms
ASSUMPTION BASED QUESTIONS
How does the AC relate to the argument?
ACs will provide a statement that “almost has to be true” according to the information given and “Generally Accepted Reality.”
Inference
INF
INFERENCE BASED QUESTION
How does the AC relate to the argument?
ACs will provide a statement that both speakers addressed directly or indirectly in such a way that you infer that they disagree (or agree) with one another about that statemen
Point at issue
PAI
INFERENCE BASED QUESTION
How does the AC relate to the argument?
(“Fill in the Blank”) ACs will build on information given in the argument and key words leading up to the blank.
Guided Inference
GI
INFERENCE BASED QUESTION
How does the AC relate to the argument?
ACs simply state THE conclusion of the argument.
Main Point
MP
STRUCTURE BASED QUESTIONS
How does the AC relate to the argument?
ACs describe WHAT the argument is doing, usually in very vague terms.
Method of Argument
METH
STRUCTURE BASED QUESTIONS
How does the AC relate to the argument?
ACs describe the way that one particular part of the argument fits into the argument as a whole.
Function
FUN
STRUCTURE BASED QUESTIONS
How does the AC relate to the argument?
ACs will present an entire argument that parallels the logical (not necessarily physical) argumentative structure of the main argument.
Parallel Reasoning
LL
STRUCTURE BASED QUESTIONS
Question Stem Language
argument supports AC | AC supported by argument | AC must be true/false | a conclusion | AC follows logically or is properly drawn from the argument
Inference
INFERENCE BASED QUESTION
Question Stem Language
point at issue | disagree | agree
PAI
Point at issue
INFERENCE BASED QUESTION
Question Stem Language
most appropriately fills in the blank | most logically completes the argument
GI
Guided inference
INFERENCE BASED QUESTION
Question Stem Language
the conclusion | statement that the argument is attempting to establish
MP
Main Point
STRUCTURE BASED QUESTIONS
Question Stem Language
method of reasoning | proceeds by | technique | by
METH
Method of Argument
STRUCTURE BASED QUESTIONS
Question Stem Language
role | figures in the argument | purpose
FUN
Function
STRUCTURE BASED QUESTIONS
Question Stem Language
reasoning most similar | parallel reasoning
LL
Paralllel Reasoning
STRUCTURE BASED QUESTIONS
Question Stem Language
explain the surprising results | resolve or reconcile the discrepancy | explain the difference| resolve the paradox
DOX
Paradox
SITUATIONAL QUESTIONS
Question Stem Language
rinciple illustrated above | principle stated above
PA
Principle Above
SITUATIONAL QUESTIONS
Question Stem Language
following proposition … exemplified by the situation above | example above illustrates … the following proposition |situation above most conforms to … the following principle/ generalization | situation above best illustrates the following
SCON
Situation Conforms
SITUATIONAL QUESTIONS
What is the question stem?
How does the AC relate to the argument?
ACs will state a general principle or just an idea that applies to the situation described in the argument above.
SCON
Situation Conforms
SITUATIONAL QUESTIONS
How does the AC relate to the argument?
ACs will take the general principle that was stated or illustrated in the argument above and apply that principle to a new, specific situation
Priciple Above
PA
SITUATIONAL QUESTIONS
How does the AC relate to the argument?
ACs will help to explain or resolve the situation in the argument that seems contradictory.
Paradox
DOX
SITUATIONAL QUESTIONS
In Assu-Based Questions, we say …
the AC supports the arg
In Inf-Based Questions, we say …
the arg supports the ACs
What are the 6 ambiguous Q-ID terms
The following terms show up in various Q-Stems, so do NOT automatically
assume that you know the Q-Type simply based on these terms
“Supports” * “Justifies” * “Follows Logically” *
“Properly Drawn”
“Principle”
“Infer” (any version of this word)
synonmyms of “principle”
- proposition
- generalization
- policy
Is this an assumption question or an inference question?
Which one of the following statements provides the most support for the statements above?
this is an assumption question bc the AC supports the argument direction of support is pointing upwars
Is this an assumption question or an inference question?
Which one of the following can be properly drawn from the statements above?
argument supports the answer choices so it is inference based
Is this an assumption question or an inference question?
The conclusion above would follow logically if which of the following is true?
the AC are supporting the argument so it is an assumption based question
Is this an assumption question or an inference question?
Which one of the followin**g can be properly inferred **from the statements above?
argument supports the AC so it is inference question
Is this an assumption question or an inference question?
Which one of the following would do the most to justify the conclusion above?
the AC support the argument so it is assumption based question
Is this an assumption question or an inference question?
which of the following is most strongly supported by the information above?
inference question bc the arguement is supporting the ac
above is what is doing the supporting
Is this an assumption question or an inference question?
Which one of the following, if true would most support the argument above
AC is supporting the arguement
Is this an assumption question or an inference question?
Which of the folllow is supported by the converstation above?
inference question
following supported by above INF
what question type is this questions
which one of the following principles justifies the conclusion drawn above?
STN
what question type is this questions
which one of the following conforms most closely to the principle illustrated above?
PA
what question type is this questions
Which one of the following most clearly violates the policy cited above?
PA-MBF
looking for something that violates that
what question type is this questions
Of the following, which one most closely conforms to the principle that the passage illustrates?
PA
when principle above is in the arguement it is always a
PA
when “principle” is in the question stem then
ex- he argument above most conforms to which one of the following principles?
it is some sort of assumption based question type
this is a RCON