Approaches L5-8 Flashcards
What is a subsection of the cognitive approach?
Cognitive neuroscience
Describe cognitive neuroscience
- Cognitive and biological processes can be integrated, leading to a discipline known as cognitive neuroscience.
- This is the scientific study of the neurological structures, mechanisms, processes and chemistry which are responsible for our thinking processes.
Describe the practical applications of cognitive neuroscience
- Brain imaging techniques such as Position Emission Tomography (PET) and Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) have been used to locate different types of memory in different areas of the brain, for instance episodic memories are in the hippocampus, semantic memories are in the temporal lobe, and procedural memories are in the cerebellum.
This has led to more effective treatments for memory disorders.
What are the strengths of the cognitive neuroscience?
- it is very dominant today in Psychology. The Cognitive approach can be applied to practical and theoretical contexts and has helped develop cognitive neuroscience. For example Cognitive Psychology has helped contribute to the development of artificial intelligence and, “thinking” machines such as robots.
- it has been founded on the idea of, “soft determinism.” This means that humans recognise that their cognitive thinking system operates within the limits of what they know and humans are free to think before they respond to stimuli. The cognitive approach is more interactionist than other approaches and is not as deterministic as the behavioural approach
- its focus on theoretical computer models emphasises scientific methods such as laboratory experiments when collecting data. This means that high levels of control can be exercised in these settings and cause and effect relationships can be identified between the IV and DV.
What are the criticisms/weaknesses of cognitive neuroscience?
- The cognitive approach uses computer models. Phrases like storage and retrieval are taken directly from computing. However, there is an important difference between the sort of information processing that takes place within a computer programme and the processing that takes place in the human mind. Computers do not make mistakes/ ignore available information/ forget. Humans do all of these things.
- The approach can be seen as mechanical or reductionist in regarding human thinking as processing like the computer. It doesn’t consider the irrationality often seen in emotional behaviours.
Outline the study related to cognitive neuroscience
- Maguire wanted to investigate if brain anatomy was predetermined, or whether the brain is susceptible to plastic changes in response to environmental stimulation (driving a taxi)
- Taxi drivers undergo extensive training and make an ideal group for the study of spatial navigation.
- The aim was to examine whether structural changes could be detected (using MRI scans) in the brain of people with extensive experience of spatial navigation.
- 32 healthy males (avg age 44) were investigated and split into 2 groups
- experimental: 16 licensed male London taxi drivers (drove for at least 18 months) and control: were 16 males (had never driven taxis).
Describe the findings of the study related to cognitive neuroscience
- The right posterior hippocampus in the brain of the taxi drivers’ was larger
than the control group; this was related to the length of time the taxi driver had been in the job. - The longer they had been a taxi driver, the larger the right posterior hippocampus. This part of the brain is responsible for storing visual representations of the environment and this links to the fact that taxi drivers have to navigate around the streets of London.
- This demand in knowledge resulted in a physical change in the brain which was identified by the MRI scan. A positive correlation was found between the amount of time spent as a taxi driver and volume in the right posterior hippocampus.
Briefly evaluate the study related to cognitive neuroscience
- An advantage of the study by Maguire is that is supports the key aspects of cognitive neuroscience which combines both cognitive and biological factors to help explain internal thought processes. The study uses MRI brain scanning to investigate the hippocampus area of the brain. The study also emphasises how the brain is “like a muscle” and the more an area of the brain is used or exercised, the larger it becomes (+)
- only investigated males therefore lacks ecological validity. Results cannot be generalised to females. Individual differences is an important factor to consider when examining the brain and cognitive functions, and every brain is different.
3) There is research evidence to support the idea that the right posterior hippocampus is involved in spatial awareness. Previous rodent and monkey studies have found the (posterior) hippocampus to be involved in spatial navigation. Such an involvement may also be true for the posterior part of the hippocampus in birds and rats. Therefore it seems that the right posterior hippocampus is responsible for spatial awareness in humans and animals, and the functionality of the brain is similar across many species (+)
define genetics
The genetic makeup of an organism, the genes they carry
define genotype
define phenotype
hence, what are the main differences?
explain the biological approach
*not define
- Individuals inherit characteristics which are carried on genes (on chromosomes).
- Psychologists research genetics by studying twins (monozygotic identical twins, or dizygotic non identical twins).
- Twin studies allow psychologists to look at concordance rates between twins
- For instance from using gene mapping, it has been found that chromosome 13 carries the gene for schizophrenia, and chromosome 11 carries the gene for bipolar depression
what is a concordance rate?
- usually in twin studies psychologists to look at concordance rates between twins
- these are the chances of both twins inheriting a certain trait (e.g. depression or intelligence).
what are the strengths of genetics
as a part of the biological approach
- when examining genes and the role they have on behaviour, gene mapping can help psychologists locate specific genes on chromosomes which could help to identify a disorder of genetic vunerability. These precise methods of investigation are highly scientific and objective.
- genetic research often involves using twin/ adoption studies. This is useful when examining MZ twins who are identical as it can help psychologists examine concordance rates in relation to behaviour. The research by Gottesman and Shields would support the idea that certain illnesses such as schizophrenia are transmitted genetically
- Genetics can help psychologists screen people to see if they carry genes for certain illnesses. This would involve gene mapping and it can help psychologists identify individuals who might be at risk from certain illnesses or diseases such as depression or some forms of cancer. This means that people might get psychological help before they become unwell (preventative)
what are the weaknesses of genetics
as a part of the biological approach
- when examining the role of genetics, it is reductionist. It takes a complex human behaviour such as IQ and reduces it down to small components alone such as genes. This idea seems inaccurate, as IQ is not solely dependent on genes; other factors need to be considered such as the environment
- Other models and approaches in Psychology are being ignored. E.g. the cognitive and behavioural approaches would also need to be considered when examining behaviour. An example is that someone who has depression might carry the gene for depression, but they might also have faulty and negative cognitions which have been ignored. (-)
which study could be linked to the role of genes (as a part of the biological approach)?
Gottesman and Shields
describe the study by Gottesman and Shields
- investigated 224 sets of twins from 1948-1993 who appeared on the Maudsley twin register
- 106 sets of twins were MZ and 118 were DZ.
- 120 males and 104 females in total took part in the study.
- average age of the participants’ was 46, and they came from a range of different ethnic backgrounds.
- the study was conducted in a London hospital
- longitudinal study following the participants’ over 25 years.
- The study relied on the fact that one twin already had the illness of schizophrenia, and concordance rates were investigated; which examined the likelihood or the chances of the healthy twin becoming schizophrenic over time. The methods that Gottesman and Shields used to diagnose schizophrenia included the following:
- In depth interviews
- Doctors case notes
- The DSM
what were the results of the study by Gottesman and Shields
- 48% of MZ twins were both concordant for schizophrenia by the end of the study
- 17% of DZ twins were both concordant for schizophrenia by the end of the study
what were the strengths of the study by Gottesman and Shields?
- It was longitudinal. This means that the schizophrenic patients could be tracked over long periods of time in order to monitor the development of the illness schizophrenia. This means that longitudinal studies are very valuable when investigating whether schizophrenia is caused by genetics
- The research supports the biological (genetics) approach as the results show 48% concordance rates for schizophrenia in MZ twins and 17% concordance in DZ twins. Therefore the results support the biological argument that schizophrenia can be transmitted by genetics
what were the weaknesses of the study by Gottesman and Shields
- The research ignores the behavioural approach when examining the causes of schizophrenia. Identical twins often copy and model each other’s behaviour, so it could be that the healthy twin has modelled or copied schizophrenic behaviour rather than getting the illness via genetics. Therefore we must investigate fully whether the healthy twin gained schizophrenia via genetics or from observing and copying behaviour
- The research could be criticised because it relied on interviews with patients. Schizophrenia patients often have difficulty with their speech and communication and therefore some patients might have found it difficult to communicate their symptoms effectively to the psychologists/psychiatrists. Therefore this issue could have had a negative effect on the diagnosis and classification of schizophrenia
within the biological approach what variables impact behavour?
- genes
- evolution
- neurochemistry
who proposed the theory of evolution?
- Charles Darwin (1851)