Alex writers Flashcards
Positives of Plutarch’s writing
He was very personally, biographer,
Used ancient sources,
Entertaining
Negatives of Plutarch’s writing
Wrote hundreds of years later
Don’t have the ancient sources he used,
Compared to Julius Caesar
What did Plutarch think of Alex
Very positive
Positives of Arrian’s’ writing
Used ancient sources,
heavily military based,
Political and military experience
Celebrate and preserve Alex
sometimes criticises him
Negatives of Arrian’s’ writing
Wrote much later,
Excuses alex for his negative deeds
used positive sources
What did Arrian think of Alex
Likes him, Wanted to preserve his history and celebrate him
Positives of Diodorus writing
Moralist,
Used very contemporary sources
Negatives of Diodorus writing
Work is not complete,
Wrote much later
What is the problem with trusting the sources we study
We cannot tell whether the sources they used are correct and we cannot see if they are accurate or biased.