ac3.3: examine the limitations of agencies in achieving social control Flashcards
recidivism
- if offenders continue to commit crime, social control will never be achieved
- recidivism has caused the prison population to rise drastically over the last 20 years
- anyone who has served 2 days to 2 years is required to serve minimum 12 months on probation
- the number of people recalled to custody has increased by 19%
supporting statistics
- around 3 in 5 prisons (61%) are overcrowded - 74 in 122 prisons
- inspectors found that safety wasn’t good in 6 of 10 men’s prisons they visited during 2021-22
- 16,300 prisoners are held in overcrowded accommodation
which theory is relevant?
social learning theory
- offenders may learn further negative behaviour in prison by copying others
how is recidivism a limitation for prisons?
- a high reoffending rate leads to overcrowding
- this causes safety issues, increased violence and aggression towards staff and other inmates
- limited access to jobs, education and rehab opportunities, which all help reduce reoffending
- an already stretched budget is further impacted
- staff to prisoner ratio is increased
- supporting stat: around 3 in 5 prisons (61%) are overcrowded
how is recidivism a limitation for probation?
- more people coming in and out of prisons
- causes staff to be overworked - there isn’t enough staff to cope with the demands on the probation service
- this could lead to mistakes and a potential MOJ
how is recidivism a limitation for police?
- a higher reoffending rate takes more time and resources for the police
- is this a waste?
how is recidivism a limitation for courts?
- recidivism increases the number of people in the CJS
- this may cause a backlog in the court system, affecting other agencies
- if the case takes a long time to get to court, eyewitnesses may forget their statements
civil liberties and legal barriers
- civil liberties are basic rights and freedoms granted to people through the law. e.g. freedom of speech, movement, from arbitrary arrest, assembly, association
- these freedoms may limit agencies’ ability to achieve social control
- e.g., foreign nationals with criminal convictions can’t be removed from the UK due to EU regulations. deportation cant happen as they are a threat to their home country
the case of abu qatada
- he was arrested for terrorist offences in the UK
- he couldn’t be deported as he claimed he wouldn’t have access to a fair trial
- he was held in the UK for 8 years until he was eventually deported
how are civil liberties and legal barriers a limitation for the police?
- they have rules about when they can and can’t arrest people - they have to read people their rights, give them a phone call and a lawyer
- they must follow these to ensure they don’t infringe on civil liberties
- this means they might miss people who should have been convicted
how are civil liberties and legal barriers a limitation for prisons?
they must comply with rules and human rights issues
access to resources and support
- if prisoners don’t get resources and support to prevent reoffending, social control won’t occur and they will reoffend
- 36% of prisons received pos rating in 2019-20 for purposeful activity work
- 35% of offenders spent less than 2 hrs out their cell a day
- 50% of people released march 2019-20 had settled accommodation on release
how is access to resources and support a limitation for prisons?
- lack of resources contributes to reoffending
- this increases prison pop and adds to neg state of prisons
- 62% of people entering the prison system were assessed as having literacy skills of 11-year-old (4x higher than general population)
how is access to resources and support a limitation for probation?
- they try to help ex-offenders get jobs and housing
- if they lack the necessary resources they won’t be effective - causing less chance of rehabilitation
how is access to resources and support a limitation for charities?
- they rely on public donations
- without this their resources will be limited