5. Language Development Flashcards
High Amplitude Sucking Procedure
- Used to test infants from birth to 4 months of age
- Relies on infants sucking reflex
- Infants hear a sound stimulus every time they produce a strong/ high-amplitude suck on a pacifier - The number of strong sucks is an indicator of the infant’s interest
- More strong sucks = more interest
- 2 variations of procedure: Discrimination and Preference
Discrimination Procedure
- Used to test whether infants can tell the difference between two auditory stimuli
- Variation of visual habituation paradigm
- Habituation phase: Each time infant produces a strong suck, a sound is played
–> Continues until sucking has declined significantly (e.g. by 20%) - Test phase: Hears new speech stimulus every time produces a strong suck
- If can distinguish between stimuli, sucking behaviour should increase
Preference Procedure
- Used to test infants’ preference for different stimuli
- 2 different stimuli are played on alternating minutes each time a strong suck is produced
–> i.e., minute 1 = Stimulus A, minute 2 = Stimulus B, minute 3 = Stimulus A - Number of strong sucks produced during presentation of each stimulus type is compared
- Preference = infants suck more during one stimulus minute type than the other
Preferential Listening Procedure
- Speaker on either side of infant’s head
- When looks at speaker, a recording of speech plays
–> Different speech from each speaker - How long an infant spends looking in a particular direction/ listening to a particular sound indicates how much they like it
–> Familiarity effect: Will listen longer to sounds they recognize
–> Novelty effect: If first habituated to a sound, will listen longer to new sound
Speech Perception in Infancy
- Using high amplitude sucking paradigms, research has shown that newborns:
–> Prefer to listen to speech sounds over artificial sounds
–> Prefer mother’s voice over another woman’s voice
–> Prefer to listen to native language vs. other language - Suggests that language learning starts in utero
Categorical Perception of Speech
Adults perceive speech sounds as distinct categories even though the differences between speech sounds are gradual
- Categorical perception is useful because focuses listeners on sounds that are linguistically meaningful while ignoring meaningless differences
–> E.g. difference between a 10ms VOT /b/ vs. 20ms VOT /b/ is meaningless in English
Infant Categorical Perception of Speech
- Do infants perceive the same speech categories as adults?
- Classic study by Eimaset al., 1971:
–> Tested 1 month old infants learning English
–> High amplitude sucking paradigm to test discrimination between /ba/ and /pa/
–> 2 groups:
*Different speech sounds: Infants habituated to /ba/ (20 msVOT) and then tested with /pa/ (40 msVOT)
*Same speech sounds: Infants habituated to 60 msVOT /pa/ and then tested with 80 msVOT /pa/
Newborns have same categorical perception of speech as adults
- Different speech sounds: Increased sucking when sound from new category (/pa/)
- Same speech sounds: No change in sucking when sound from same category (/pa/)
Infant Cross-Language Speech Perception
- Infants make more distinctions between speech sounds than adults
- Adults have difficulty perceiving differences between speech sounds that are not important in their native language
–> E.g. In French, difference between /ou/ and /u/ is meaningful, but not in English
Infant Cross-Language Speech Perception Experiment
- Classic study by Werkeret al., 1988:
–> Tested 6 month old American infants learning English
–> High amplitude sucking paradigm to see if they can discriminate between Hindi /Ta/ and /ta/
*English-speaking adults struggle to distinguish between these 2 sounds
–> Results:
*After habituating to one of these Hindi speech sounds, increased sucking when heard other speech sounds
*i.e., if habituated to /Ta/, then increased sucking when tested with /ta/
Implications
- Infants discriminate between speech sounds they have never heard before (i.e., speech sounds not found in their native language)
- Infants are biologically ready to learn any of the world’s languag
Perceptual Narrowing of Speech Perception
- Infants’ ability to easily distinguish between non-native speech sounds diminishes around 8 months
- By 10-12 months, infants’ perceptual abilities are narrowed to those sounds that are relevant to their native language
–> Improves perception of speech sounds in native language
Word Segmentation
- Knowing where words begin and end in fluent speech
–> Begins around 7 months of age
-Infants’ statistical learning enables them to segment words in a stream of speech
–> Stress-patterning
–> Distribution of speech sounds
Stress Patterning
- Different languages place stress on different parts of a word
–> English: stress usually on first syllable
–> French: stress usually on last syllable - Infants pick up on the stress patterning in their language and use it as clues to for word segmentation
Distribution of Speech Sounds
- Sounds that appear together often are likely to be words
- Sounds that don’t appear together often are more likely to be boundaries between words
- Example: “happy baby”
–> “ba” and “by” occur together often because make word “baby”
–> “ha” and “ppy” occur together often because make word “happy”
–> “ppy” and “ba” occur together less often because don’t make a word and many different words can come before “baby” (“happy”, “little” ) and many words can come after “happy” (“birthday”, “baby”, “puppy”)
Distribution of Speech Sounds Study
- Preferential listening procedure
- Habituation: 8-month-olds listened to a stream of syllables for a long time (2 mins)
–> Some syllables always occurred together
–> Others rarely or never occurred together - Test: Presented with a syllable sequence that always co-occurred (“tokibu”) vs. syllable sequences that rarely co-occurred (“bagopi”)
- Results: Listened longer to rarely occurring sequence
- Shows that infants understood word boundaries by detecting the likelihood of syllables belonging together
Developmental Milestones
- 2 months: Cooing and gurgling
- 7 months: Babbling
- 12 months: First words
- 18 months: Knows 50 words
Cooing
- Start around 2 months of age
- Drawn out vowel sounds, like “ooooohhh” and “aahhhh”
- Helps infants gain motor control over their vocalizations
- Elicits reactions from caregivers leading to back-and-forth cooing with caregivers
Babbling
- Start around 7 months of age (6-10 months of age)
- Repetitive consonant-vowel syllables, like “papapa” and “babababa”
–> Speech sounds not necessarily from native language
–> Infant babbling is very similar across languages - Manual babbling: Deaf infants that are exposed to sign language babble with repetitive hand movements made up of pieces of full signs
–> Deaf children do not verbally babble
–> Evidence that language exposure is critical for babbling
Functions of Babbling
- Social function: Practicing turn-taking in a dialogue
–> Infant babbling elicits caregiver reactions which in turn elicit more babbling - Learning function: Signal that the infant is alert and ready to learn
–> Infants learn more when an adult labels a new object just after they babble vs. learning the word in the absence of babbling
Understanding Words Precedes Production
- Infants appear to understand high-frequency words around 6 months of age
–> In lab studies, when 6-month-olds are presented with pictures of common items and hear one of the pictures being named, they look to the correct picture more often than chance
–> But cannot yet name these items themselves - Shows that infants understand more words than they can produce
- Shows that infants understand more words than their caregivers realize
First Words
- First words are produced around 12 months of age (10-15 months)
- First word: Any specific utterance consistently used to refer to a particular meaning
- Can be tricky to identify:
–> Babbling can sound like words
–> E.g. “mamamama”
–> Meaning of a first word can differ from its standard meaning
–> E.g. “woof woof” referring to “dog - Usually refer to family members, pets, or important objects
- Meaning of first words are very similar across cultures
–> Suggests that infants around the world have similar interests and priorities
Mispronunciations of First Words
- Often mispronounced in predictable ways:
–> Omit difficult parts of words: “Banana” => “nana”
–> Substitute difficult sounds for easier sounds: “Rabbit” => “wabbit”
–> Re-order sounds to put easy sound first: “Spaghetti” => “pisketti”
Limitations of First Words
- Infants express themselves initially with only one-word utterances so cannot clearly communicate what they want to say
- Overextension: using a word in a broader context than is appropriate
–> E.g. “dog” refers to any 4 legged animal
–> Does not mean that they don’t understand what the word refers to - Underextension: using a word in a more limited context than appropriate
–> “cat” only refers to the family’s pet cat
Learning More Words
- 18 months of age:
- Knows about 50 words
- Vocabulary spurt: Rate of word learning accelerates
How do Children Learn Words?
- Children’s assumptions about language
- Social context
–> Caregivers
–> Peers