5. Economic Growth Flashcards
GDP an effective measure of growth
Simon Kuznets - Gdp should never be confused with well being
- War, accidents - leads to an increases in gdp
- Env - not included
- Inequality
- informal - house work, volunteering
- Creative destruction- flight booking app led to job loss for travel agents
Case study — commission established in France to explore alternatives to GDP (which included members like Stieglitz and Sen) — recommended an expanded dashboard of multiple indicators unique to each country
Abhijeet Banerjee- GDP is a means and not an end ( inclusive growth, quality of life )
Uses of gdp
- Comparison - ex: imf uses gdp /gnp to compare
- Business investment choices
- Indicates where the economy is possibly headed
Benefits of internationalisation of rupee
- Appreciate currency value : increased convenience and reduced transaction costs of business
- Access to international financial markets and transactions not affected by exchange rate risk
- Opportunities for financial institutions - trade financing, currency hedging, settlement services
- reduced requirement of forex
- Can enhance India’s geopolitical advantage - increase its attractiveness as a reserve currency
Constraints in internationalisation of rupee
- india still doesn’t have capital account convertibility
- Current status - daily avg share of rupee in global forex hovers around 1.6%
- Infrastructure and settlement system completely dominated by west
- India’s low sovereign credit rating
- Usa on several occasions have placed india in the list of currency manipulator
Post internationalisation issue
1.Amplified impact of global economy — huge impact on domestic economy
- Triffin rating - conflict of economic interests that arises between short-term domestic and long-term international objectives for countries whose currencies serve as global reserve currencies.
Budget 23-24 envisions to reach the last mile . How does it propose to do it
- Aspirational blocks prog
- PM PVTG development mission
- Ekalavya model residential schools - 38000 new teachers and staff
- BHARATH SHRI - digitise 1 lakh ancient inscriptions
- Support for poor prisoners
- Water for drought prone area
Budget 23-24 puts forth the idea of green growth. What’s it ? How does it aim to achieve it
Climate change stands afront the global ploycrisis ( other being war, global slowdown ) as per the recent economic survey
Gg - green farming, green mobility and green jobs - growth thats environmentally sustainable
- Gobhardhan scheme - waste to weath CBG plants
- Amrit Darohar ( optimal use of wetlands) - ecotourism
- Mishti - mangrove plantation- linking it to MNREGA
- 35000 cr towards priority capital investment in energy transition project - electric vehicle
- Green credit - to incentivise envt sustainable action by individuals, companies and local bodies
- Pm Pranam
- Bharathiya Prakritik Kheri bio input resource centers
Do you think sovereign credit rating accurately portray India’s economic abilities
S&P BBB-, Moody’s - Baa3,
Economic factors and institutional factors
Es 2021 - not an accurate picture
1. India’s history of zero sovereign default
2. IMF world economic outlook report 2023 - bright spot
3. 3rd largest economy in ppp
4. Majorly dominated by domestic debt - less interest rate risk
5. Forex - 600 bn§$
6. Remittance - 89127- FY 22
7. IBC, GST
7. Instn - worlds largest democracy
Inspite of global poly crisis, IMF sees India as a bright spot. What are India’s growth drivers
- Strength of demography - domestic private consumption
- Remittance - 89127 mn in FY 22
- Increase in capex - 13 lakh crore ( 4.5% of GDP )
- Tax buoyancy - widening tax net ( digitisation+ gst), more TAX compliance due to faceless assessment
- Strong corporate balance sheet and banking sector ( 10 year low of 3.9%— RBIs financial stability report
- Digital infrastructure
- Investment destination ( China+ 1, derisking supply chain)
What are the major reforms that have been made in the union budget
- Improved transparency - ex: off budget expenditure
- Discontinued plan and non plan classification- which was leading to skewed distribution, lack of prioritisation and neglecting maintenance
- Merger of rail budget with general budget
- better overall picture
- prevented populism via railway - Shifting date of budget to February 1st
- no need of vote on account
- better planning and efficient resource utilisation
How do you interpret the low FLPR Of india ?
Societal
1. Education- USAID report - 23 million girls drop out annually from schools due to period poverty
2. Early marraige - unicef report - one in three worlds child brides lives in india
3. Double burden - DELOITTE WOMEN AT WORK REPORT - 85% of women bear household responsibility alone while performing task of being a bread winner
4.Motherhood penalty
Workplace related
1. Discrimination in recruitment ( ex: small and medium firm reduced women recruitment after passing of maternity benefit act)
2. Wage discrimination- ILO 34% less than men
3. Harassment and micro aggression at workplace
4. Glass ceiling and glass cliff
5. Leaking pipe syndrome - 35% judges in lower judiciary, while only 11% in SC
Economic
1. U - hypothesis
However economic survey 2023 also points
1. Overly broad categories
2. Single question approach
3. Narrow approach to measuring work
Steps taken by govt to improve FLFPR
- Code of social security 2020
- paid maternity leave of 26 weeks
- mandatory crèche facility > 50 employees
- permitting women workers in night shift with adequate safety measures - Code on occupational safety and health
- provisions to allow women work in above and below ground mines with adequate safety measures - Code on wages
- prohibits gender discrimination in wages and recruitment - Training via network of vocational training institutes
- Standup india
- NABARD SHG- bank linkage
Wf
1. Crèches
2. Career counselling
3. Safe workspaces- POSH awareness
Analyze the implications of increased capex in budget 23-24
Positive
According to RBI long run multiplier of capital outlay on GDP is 2.45
1. Imf world outlook report 2015
2. Reduce unemployment rate
3. reduce logistics cost - eodb
4. More exports
Negative
1. John KEynes ( who formally introduced the concept of expenditure multiplier) - in the long run we are all dead— unexpected outcomes - jobless growth, inflation due to global crisis
- Ricardian equivalence
- If weak banking structure
Wf
1. golden rule of fiscal policy es 2015 — borrow to fund capex not revenue exp
2. Center and state should work together as team india
Changes that GST brought
- Tax change
- 1.4 trillion April 2022
- more registered tax payers - 66, 1.38 - Business
- eway bill - logistical efficiency
- formalisation - Behavioural
- invoicing, regular filing
- voluntary complaints - Fiscal federalism
279A- pooled sovereignty , cooperative fedralism - Technology
- gstn
- single centralized registration
What are some of the issues with GST
- Economy
- tax revenue mobilisation— falling short of targets
- post gst inflation - clothin, footwear, housing etc
- inverted duty structure Ex: led lamps - GST rate
- multiple slabs ( 0,5, 12, 18, 28)
- exemptions - petroleum, alcohol, electricity
- gst rate increase - packaged food items - Fiscal fedralism
- gst compensation
- loss of revenue to producing states like TN
- Mohit minerals case - Small business
- increased complaince cost
- if not gst registered - big companies may not buy from them
Wf for gst
- Aravind Subramanian panel - RNR - 15-15.5%
- Report by GoM
- correct inverted duty structure
- withdraw exemptions - Report by GOM on system reforms
- physical verification ; to prevent shell companies for claiming tax credit
- biometric authentication
India value chain
Rbi report on internationalization of rupee
- Short term
- use existing clearing mechanism like ACU
- non residents - rupee accounts
- FPI regime rationalisation - Medium term
- exp of RTGS
- rupee in continuous linked system - Long term
- SDR basket
Features of India’s trade policy 2023
- Process re-engineering and autonomTion
- Towns of excellence - Varanasi , Mirzapur ( carpet weaving )
- Districts as export hubs
- SCOMET policy
- E- commerce
Challenges to India’s exports
India’s current account deficit was > 3 % in 22-23. India’s good exports form just 2% of the global goods trade
- Incentives vs quality
- Policy short fall - ex: remission rate of cotton is only 4% under RoDtep - not enough to make it competitive
- Access to trade finance and export credit
- Lack of basic infra - eodb
- R&D - 0.7% of gdp
- Es 2018- India’s export egalitarian exceptionalism - top 1% accounts for 38% of exports
- Rising protectionism, de globalisation and weaponisation of supply chain
E commerce benefits
- Customer
- vast choice at competitive price
- ease of living - Seller
- vast market access
- platforms providing efficient supply chain
- can produce optimally owing to better market intelligence
Vulnerable groups - Jharkhand online ‘deoghar markets’ to sell tribal products
- Economy
- more production
- technology and innovations - ex: Amazon prime air
- jobs , gig economy
- warehousing and logistics - rise of huge companies like Delhivery - Govt
- more taxes
- push to digital india - ex: ONDC
Issues with e-cooomerce
- Unfair trade practice
- predatory pricing - deep discounts killing brick and mortar
- drip pricing - firms advertise only part of a product price and reveal other charges as customer goes through with buying
- cross- selling and mis- selling - Conflict of interest
- platforms selling their own products
- prefertial treatment to few sellers - Exclusion of small players with no technical know-how
- Supply chain gaps - last mile problem of rural India
- Data protection - ex: data leak of bigbasket
ONDC paradigm shift
- Closed platform centric - open democratisation
- No opportunity model - equal opportunities
- Exclusion - inclusion
- Scaling what works to what works at scale
Challenges in national monetisation pipeline
- Govt
- pvt sector will prefer performing assets over idle assets - key to success
- govt unable to meet target — 26000 cr, 1.6 lakh crore, 22-23
- problem of undervaluation
- lack of scope of ex-ante renegotiation, dispute resolution
- possibility of nexus - Pvt sector
- unable to identify revenue streams
- tarrif regulated in some sector. Ex: power
- policy uncertainty
Es 2019- increase in policy uncertainty by 1 standard deviation above normal reduces investment by 11% - Common man
- fear of hiking user fee of non excludable public goods
- build by tax payers money - if imposition of user fees it would be akin to double taxation
- es 2018 pointed out — india has a problem of STIGMATISED CAPITALISM
What are the existing problems of India’s labor market
- Regulatory cholesterol - complex and outdated laws , eodb
- Firms - tendency to remain dwarf - missing middle
- Trade union - militant trade unions
Ex: violence at wistron iPhone facility in Karnataka - Market imperfections and changes
- capital intensive — less employee elasticity
- emerging wc like wfh, gig economy - Labor
- no social security for the informal labor
- gender discrimination
- underskilled and underemployed
What are the concerns regarding new labor codes
- No stake holder consultation- against the tripartite consultation mechanism of ILO ( convention 144)
- Enforcement
- huge opposition from trade unions
- state not actively implementing
- hire and fire — ex: in code of industrial relation- employer have power to renew fixed term contracts
- yet to decide a floor wage under code of wages - Exclusion
- proper definition of gig workers
- exclusion of unpaid labor
- ngo and charities - Discretionary power given to states ( ex. Power to exempt under code on occupational safety ) nexus