4.3.3 Strategies influencing growth & development Flashcards
What are free market approaches ?
- favour giving a larger role to private sector enterprises using liberalisation of markets,
structural supply-side reforms to raise incentives for people & businesses + increased transparency for
govt also high on the policy agenda
Examples of market led policies ?
- fiscal discipline: emphasising greater control of govt spending, budget deficits & national debt
- reallocating state spending: away from subsidies (e.g. minimum prices to farmers) towards health care, education & infrastructure
- tax reforms: incl. widening the base of taxation + encouraging lower tax rates to raise enterprise & work incentives as a means of creating wealth
- liberalising market interest rates: ie. letting financial markets allocate capital among competing uses
- floating rather than fixed exchange rates: implies an absence of central bank intervention
- trade liberalisation: via reductions in import tariffs & fewer forms of protectionism eg. import quotas & other non-tariff barriers
- privatisation: ie. moving state enterprises into the private sector
What is trade liberalisation ?
- involves a country lowering import tariffs & relaxing import quotas & other forms of protectionism
- aim: to make an economy more open to trade & investment so that it can then engage more directly in the regional & global economy
- supporters of free trade ague that developing countries can specialise in the goods/services which they have a comparative advantage
Micro effects of trade liberalisation ?
- ✅ lower prices for consumers/ households (increases their real incomes) + wider variety of goods/services available
- ✅ increased competition: exposes domestic businesses to international competition (drives innovation, efficiency & productivity) + lower barriers to entry attracts new firms
- ✅ improved efficiency (both allocative & productive)
- ✅❌ might affect the real wages of workers in affected industries
- ✅❌ employment: some industries may experience job losses (due to increased competition from imports) while others benefit from export opportunities & expanded market access
- ✅ investment: may attract FDI + facilitate tech transfer
Macro effects of trade liberalisation ?
- ✅ multiplier effects from higher export sales
- ✅ increased trade + investment: increase trade flows as barriers are reduced & can attract FDI
- ✅ lower inflation from cheaper imports (causing an outward shift of SRAS)
- ✅ price stability: by exposing domestic markets to international comp (diversifying sources of supply & reducing dependance on domestic producers)
- ❌ risk of some structural unemployment/occupational immobility
- ❌ may lead initially to an increase in the size of a nation’s trade deficit BUT can also stimulate export growth
Advantage of FDI ?
- improved infrastructure esp in power & transport sectors
- higher capital intensity/capital deepening ie. more capital per worker leading to higher productivity
- better training for local workers leading to improved human capital + less risk of structural unemployment
- investment grows a country’s export capacity (eg. via firms attracted into special economic zones)
- technology & know-how transfer: promoting diversification of the economy + reducing primary dependence
- more competition in markets which lowers prices for consumers & increases their real incomes
- creates new jobs leading to higher per capita incomes & increased household savings
- can promote a shift to higher productivity jobs & high-value added industries
Main risks from policies designed to attract investment into an emerging economy ?
- multinationals wield power within host countries especially LEDCs and they can gain favourable laws & regulations
- foreign multinationals take advantage of weak laws on anti-competitive practices & environmental protection
- multinationals have been criticised for poor working conditions in foreign factories
- profits made in an LEDC are often repatriated to the host country
- imports of components/capital goods initially have a negative effect on a country’s trade balance
- multinationals may only employ local labour in lower skilled jobs
- volatile FDI flows: FDI more volatile than remittance flows
- monopsony power of TNC’s: able to negotiate highly favourable prices
- inequality: profits from FDI flow disproportionately to powerful elites
- many multinationals use tax avoidance techniques to increase profits
Policies to attract FDI ?
- attractive rates of corporation tax
- soft loans & tax relief/subsidies
- trade & investment agreements eg. TPP
- flexible labour force + skilled workers
- creation of special economic zones
- high quality critical infrastructure
- open capital markets for remitted profits
- low labour costs
Advantages of govt subsidies ?
- in many developing countries, a sizeable number of producers esp in farming & energy received subsidies or other form of govt financial support eg. guaranteed min price
- subsidies can play an important role in improving incomes leading to higher capital investment + supports innovation & improved productivity in the LR
- subsidies encourage increased production to help overcome the challenges of malnutrition among the poor + help to generate surpluses for export
Disadvantages of govt subsidies ?
- subsidies distort the working of the price mechanism
- subsidies can stifle innovation as producers are less reliant on innovation as a way of making more profit
- producers/growers can become “subsidy-dependent” in the LR + there is risk of corruption
syphoning off financial support to those who don’t need it - environmental effect: subsidies can lower the incentive for producers to improve efficiency (rewarded by increasing the intensification of farming which can lead to deforestation, a loss
of biodiversity & increased water scarcity), farmers may overuse fertilisers/pesticides, which can result in soil degradation which reduces the max sustainable yield in the LR
Free market approach for govt subsidies ?
- lower/eliminate subsidies paid to consumers
- eg. many developing countries continue to use food-price subsidies or controls to improve nutrition (households might substitute some of their budget towards foods with less nutritional content because a subsidy effectively increases their real incomes)
- energy subsidies are widely adopted in developing countries: IMF recently estimated that the value of energy subsidies to consumers amounted to nearly 3% of global GDP
- economists concerned about environmental threats from climate change would make the case for getting rid of these subsidies so that the price of energy accurately reflects the externalities involved
- cutting subsidies due to the high opportunity cost (govt spending on subsidies might be better allocated to education, health services and public infrastructure?)
Benefits of a floating exchange rate ?
- shock absorption: allows economies to absorb external shocks more effectively by facilitating adjustments in relative prices & competitiveness - restores equilibrium in trade balances & external accounts
- reduced need for foreign exchange reserves: central banks don’t need to intervene to change the currency’s price meaning that they don’t have to maintain large reserves of gold & other foreign currencies = lower reserve accumulation & associated costs
- market efficiency: exchange rate movements convey valuable signals about relative economic conditions, helping to allocate resources efficiently + guide investment decisions
- flexibility: provides policymakers w/greater flexibility to pursue independent monetary & fiscal policies tailored to domestic economic conditions (central banks can focus on domestic objectives eg. price stability, full employment, or economic growth w/o being constrained by exchange rate targets or the need to defend a fixed exchange rate)
- capital controls will not be used to limit the inflow/outflow of currency = more attractive to foreign investment
- automatic adjustment: currency values adjust automatically in response to changes in market conditions eg. shifts in trade balances, capital flows, or economic fundamentals (helps to maintain equilibrium in the foreign exchange market w/o the need for intervention by central banks/govts
- eg. CAnada, Japan, Norway, Sweden UK, US, Eu, Russia
Evaluation of floating exchange rate ?
- a floating currency might be more appropriate for a country w/ a low trade to GDP ratio since exchange
rate fluctuations would have less of an impact on the trade balance & the inflation rate - have to consider whether a country has the size & reserves to be able to control their own currency
- many smaller EU nations have chosen to join the single European Currency
- an economy with one dominant trade partner might decide that the advantages of a pegged currency outweigh come of the possible gains from currency flexibility
- there has been a gradual shift among developing/emerging countries away from fixed (pegged) currency regimes towards managed floating or free-floating systems (managed floating remains the most common)
Different microfinance schemes ?
- microfinance refers to a large number of different financial products, including but not exclusive to:
- micro-credit: the provision of small-scale loans to the poor eg. by credit unions
- micro-savings: eg. voluntary local savings clubs provided by charities
- micro-insurance: esp for people/businesses not traditionally served by commercial insurance businesses (a safety net to prevent people from falling back into extreme poverty)
- remittance management: managing remittance payments sent from one country to another
Grameen Bank approach to microfinance ?
- reducing poverty by providing small loans to the country’s rural poor
- targeting of women on the grounds that compared to men, they perform better as clients of micro finance institutions & that their participation has more desirable long-term development
outcomes - initially focused on small groups ‘lending circles’ of largely female
entrepreneurs from the poorest level in the society (became the widely accepted view of what micro finance is) - in reality there are thousands of commercial microfinance institutions (MFIs) including some large international operators
Advantages & disadvantages of micro-credit ?
- ✅ helps overcome the savings gap which limits entrepreneurship
- ✅ encourages entrepreneurship esp social enterprises
- ✅ targeted at women entrepreneurs
- ✅ high rates of repayment because the system is built on social capital / trust
- ❌ high interest rates
- ❌ low success rate for new small businesses
- ❌ alleged forcible collection of debt in many villages (hard to monitor)
- ❌ perhaps relatively ineffective compared to the impact of migrant remittances & FDI
What is privatisation ?
- the transfer of a business, industry or service from public to private ownership
Advantages of privatisation ?
- private companies have a profit incentive to cut costs + be more productively efficient & raise efficiency
- govt gains revenue from the sale of assets + no longer has to support a potentially loss-making
industry - if a state monopoly is replaced by a number of firms this extra contestability in an industry will lead to lower prices (helps to increase the real incomes of poorer households)
- the competitiveness of the macro economy may also improve esp if privatisation leads to increased investment + benefits from economies of scale ➡️ improved competitiveness will drive higher exports & LR GDP growth
Disadvantages of privatisation ?
- social objectives given less importance as privately-owned firms are driven by the profit motive
- some activities are best run by the state operating in the public interest as they are strategic parts of the economy e.g. water supply, steel/railways & have the characteristics of a natural monopoly
- govt loses out on dividends from any future profits
- public sector assets often sold cheaply + the privatisation process may suffer from corruption
- job losses as firms increase their efficiency (increases risk of poverty)
- unless privatised corporations are regulated effectively, there is risk of creating private monopolies (who use their market power to increase prices & profits) this can have a regressive effect on the distribution of income
What are interventionist strategies ?
- govt intervention in markets designed to correct market failures, influence patterns of trade & investment + address the root causes of extreme poverty & inequality
- supporters of interventionist strategies believe in the concept of a developmental state (where
the govt can be an active & positive force in driving sustainable & inclusive growth and development)
Key possible roles of the state ?
- basic (universal) and health care
- accessible & affordable education of good quality
- infrastructure especially in telecommunications, health & transport
- core public goods that the free-market under-provides
- institutions of governance (including judiciary)
- public-private partnerships in supporting urbanisation
- smarter regulation eg. building codes, regulation of monopoly power
- welfare provision to provide a basic social safety net + encourage saving
- progressive taxation & state spending to reduce inequality of income and wealth
Development of human capital ?
- human capital is regarded as
complementary to investment in physical capital eg. new buildings, plant & equipment & the latest tech - differences in productivity & per capita incomes are strongly linked to variations in the quality & quantity of human capital available in a country
- between 10-30% of per capita GDP differences is attributable to cross-country differences in human capital
- in poorer countries, almost
1/4 of children under 5 are malnourished, and 60% of primary school students fail to achieve even a rudimentary education - more than 260 million children and youth are not in school worldwide
Interventions to improve human capital ?
- strategies to improve nutrition & reduce the extent of stunted growth among young people
- other health interventions can increase school attendance eg. in Kenya deworming in childhood reduced school absences while raising wages in adulthood by as
much as 20% - increased investment in primary & secondary schooling incl. policies to improve the quality of
teaching & access to online education - incentives to attract an inflow of skilled migrant workers + curb ‘brain drains’ of highly qualified people
- investment in training to re-skill people at risk of unemployment from the fast-changing pattern of
employment incl. robotics, automatic & AI - cash transfer interventions can increase demand for education esp among the poorest families who must make hugely difficult decisions about how to spend a meagre budget
➡️ building human capital may also require behavioural interventions to address social & cultural norms that often
prevent young people from starting or completing different grades of education