3.A - USA migration case study of an AC Flashcards

You may prefer our related Brainscape-certified flashcards:
1
Q

USA migration facts

A
  • 13% of population are migrants (41 mill)
  • strong influence on global migration = honey pot destination
  • increase in number of immigrants through rate of growth may be slowing
  • more than 50% of the USA’s most valuable technology companies were founded by immigrants, as were 40% of its 500 largest TNCs.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

what does this case study look at? (USA)

A
  • this case study looks at the USA and focuses on the USA-Mexico migration corridor (classic South-North intra regional migrant flow).
  • it should be clearly noted thar in migration flows, the richer country will ALWAYS control the flow (through immigration policies and border controls), and the AC will always benefit more from the flows compared to the source country.
  • this exacerbates inequalities between the countries, acting as a positive feedback loop to increase the gulf in development between the 2 countries.
  • whilst there are opportunities and challenges for the USAs migration policy, the opportunities will outweigh the challenges (if they did not, the USA would change their policy)
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

which source countries are the main contributors to migrant populations in the US? (2013)

A
  • Mexico (28% of all foreign born US residents)
  • India (5%)
  • China (5%)
  • the Phillipines (4%)
  • Puerto Rico (3.5%)
  • Vietnam, El Salavdor, Cuba and South Korea (3%)
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

for what political reasons is the USA popular?

A
  • the positive immigration policy and possibility of obtaining a Green Card (permanent residence)
  • the policy on refugee admission
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

for what economic reasons is the USA popular?

A
  • employment opportunites for both low and high skilled workers
  • wage differential and the opportunity to send remittances
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

for what social reasons is the USA popular?

A
  • educational opportunities and access to other services such as healthcare
  • the importance of family reunification w/in the migration policy
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

what 5 types of visa does the USA issue?

A
  1. reunification of families (480,00 p/yr available for family members to join legal residents)
  2. admission of migrants w/ skills valuable to the US economy (140,000 visas available for highly skilled workers)
  3. protecting refugees (no of admissions decided each year - 70,000 visas in 2013)
  4. promoting diversity (the diversity Immigrant visa program = 50,000 immigrant visas annually. 2014 mostly went to African countries)
  5. humanitarian relief (temporary visas available for relief from natural disasters/ongoing armed conflict)
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

DIFFERING OPINIONS - economic impacts of migration flows

A
  • one view is that migrants are a vital part of the US economy’s growth engine.
  • from New York restaurant kitchens to California’s vineyards, legal and illegal migrants work long hours for low pay.
  • Citigroup Research suggests that 2/3 of US growth since 2011 is directly attributable to migration.
  • this is because migration self-selects entrepreneurial people who are more likely to start their own businesses wherever they live.
  • despite this evidence, high unemployment in some deindustrialised places has led to calls for immigration to be curbed.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

DIFFERING OPINIONS - Impacts on international security

A
  • the terrorist attacks on the USA in 2001 ushered in an era of heightened security concerns.
  • support grew for the anti-immigration ‘Tea Party’ movement.
  • in 2016, before he became US President, Donald Trump suggested that Muslims should be banned from entering the USA on the basis that global terror group ISIS pledges allegiance to Islam.
  • Many people found this deeply offensive.
  • Trump insisted he was simply thinking of ways to safeguard national security.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

DIFFERING OPINIONS - demographic impacts

A
  • in the USA and other developed countries, youthful migration helps offset the costs of an ageing population.
  • yet the higher birth rates of some immigrant communities is changing the ethnic population composition of the USA.
  • in 1950, 3 million US citizens were Hispanic.
  • Today, the figure has reached 60 million..
  • this is more than 1/5 of the population
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

DIFFERING OPINIONS - cultural change

A
  • migrants change places when they influence food, music and language.
  • Hispanic population growth is affecting the content of US media as programmers and advertisers seek out a larger share of the audience by offering Spanish-language soap operas on platforms like Netflix.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

how does migration develop POLITICAL interdependence between the USA and Mexico?

A
  • since the formation of NAFTA, bilateral trade between USA and Mexico has increased significantly.
  • political power relations remain imbalanced but increasingly there has been co-ordination and cooperation over issues in common:
    > border security, drug trade, human trafficking and environmental issues such as water security
    > joint management of Colorado River Basin
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

how does migration develop SOCIAL interdependence between the USA and Mexico?

A
  • (2013) 11.5 million Mexican lived in USA
  • 1 million Americans in Mexico
  • growing social and cultural connectivity
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

how does migration develop ECONOMIC interdependence between the USA and Mexico?

A
  • low skilled Mexicans (many illegal) contribute to the US economy by working in agriculture, construction and low paid services. Wages are much than higher in Mexico
  • since the formation of NAFTA, bilateral trade between USA and Mexico has increased significantly.
  • reciprocal merchandise trade alone = $1.4 billion per day
  • Mexican industry has benefitted e.g. development of aerospace and IT sectors boosted mainly by FDI from USA
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

SOCIAL OPPORTUNITIES of USA-Mexico migration

A
  • the introduction of Mexican cultural traditions to America, especially in states w/ large numbers of migrants, have helped to improve cultural aspects of those states
    > Mexican themed food = v. popular w/ burrito and taco fast food shops. New food and music has helped to improve cultural diversity of America significantly.
  • with such a large number of Mexican migrants not speaking fluently = common for Spanish to be taught in schools, widening the skillset of the younger population and improving potential career opportunities for students. also slightly helps ease social tensions.

- LT. INCREASE OF TOURISTS

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITIES of USA-Mexico migration

A
  • almost 1 in 3 employed workers in farming, fishing and forestry occupations was from Mexico.
    > overall, Mexican immigrant workers made up 3.4% of total employed labour force
    > construction and extraction, production, transportation, material moving and service
  • conversely, the increased money being sent back to Mexico is helping its economy greatly as people now have money to spend on goods and services

LT, FILLING GAPS IN LABOUR MARKET

16
Q

SOCIAL CHALLENGES of USA-Mexico migration

A
  • assimilation into American communities = problematic (less of an issue over time)
    > many can’t speak English fluently and don’t improve as they live in closed communities
    > reduces their need to assimilate = increased tension between migrants and locals = segregation and violence
  • concerns that immigrants are increasing crime rates in areas they migrate to.
    > low income and poor education = crime
    > Mexico associated w/ drug trafficking, concerns that Mexican migrants could be smuggling drugs into America = drug related crimes
17
Q

SOCIAL CHALLENGES of USA-Mexico migration = ASSIMILATION

A
  • assimilation into American communities = problematic (less of an issue over time)
    > many can’t speak English fluently and don’t improve as they live in closed communities
    > reduces their need to assimilate = increased tension between migrants and locals = segregation and violence
18
Q

SOCIAL CHALLENGES of USA-Mexico migration = CRIME

A
  • concerns that immigrants are increasing crime rates in areas they migrate to.
    > low income and poor education = crime
    > Mexico associated w/ drug trafficking, concerns that Mexican migrants could be smuggling drugs into America = drug related crimes
19
Q

ECONOMIC CHALLENGES of USA-Mexico migration (BIG ONE)

A
  • Mexican migrants often take low paying, menial jobs which offer higher wages than they’d earn in Mexico
    > at first, this was advantageous but as unemployment increased in America, Americans want these menial jobs, but migrants have already taken them.
    > can lead to ↑ social tension as Americans believe their jobs are being taken
  • migrants work at incredibly low wages. Americans who are desparate for work are now often expected to work at these incredibly low wages too, which they can’t afford = ↑ poverty in America
    > many companies are now replacing American labour w/ cheaper migrant labour, also ↑ unemployment rates as people are forced out of their jobs
  • while legal migrants are working and paying taxes, they often send money they earn back to their families in Mexico, rather than spending it in America, which can affect the country’s economy as there is less money being spent on products which are taxed in America
  • unemployent rates are considerably higher amongst Mexican immigrants (9.4%) than native citizens (5.6%), suggesting that Mexicans struggle to find work and then need support from the state, putting pressure on services.
    putting up more barriers for migration ↑ illegal migrants therefore more drug smuggling etc
20
Q

ECONOMIC CHALLENGES of USA-Mexico migration = MENIAL JOBS

A
  • Mexican migrants often take low paying, menial jobs which offer higher wages than they’d earn in Mexico
    > at first, this was advantageous but as unemployment increased in America, Americans want these menial jobs, but migrants have already taken them.
    > can lead to ↑ social tension as Americans believe their jobs are being taken
21
Q

ECONOMIC CHALLENGES of USA-Mexico migration = LOW WAGES

A
  • migrants work at incredibly low wages. Americans who are desparate for work are now often expected to work at these incredibly low wages too, which they can’t afford = ↑ poverty in America
    > many companies are now replacing American labour w/ cheaper migrant labour, also ↑ unemployment rates as people are forced out of their jobs
22
Q

ECONOMIC CHALLENGES of USA-Mexico migration = REMITTANCES

A
  • while legal migrants are working and paying taxes, they often send money they earn back to their families in Mexico, rather than spending it in America,
  • can affect the country’s economy as there is less money being spent on products which are taxed in America
23
Q

ECONOMIC CHALLENGES of USA-Mexico migration = UNEMPLOYMENT RATES

A
  • unemployent rates are considerably higher amongst Mexican immigrants (9.4%) than native citizens (5.6%), suggesting that Mexicans struggle to find work and then need support from the state, putting pressure on services.
    putting up more barriers for migration ↑ illegal migrants therefore more drug smuggling etc
24
Q

For the USA, to what extent do the challenges outweigh the opportunities?

A
  • for USA, opportunities outweigh challenges
  • if it was a really big challenge they would limit migration more
  • opportunities in USA more significant in south where migrants are concentrated
  • disproportionate impact of Mexican migration to USA
  • substantial migrant population along southern/border states
25
Q

patterns of immigration/emigration

A
  • spatial and temporal variations (economic and political reasons)
  • financial crash of 2007-8 in USA. people moved back to Mexico as service sector roles weren’t needed
  • net migration from Mexico to US returned to positive between 2013 and 2018. overall less people moving in. it will never go back go 1995-2000 levels due to stricter rules and border control.
  • rise in children crossing led to fear-mongering
  • migrants of Mexican origin concentrated around the border/big cities. up to 40% of populations (SPATIAL VARIATION)
  • 2020, more Mexican migrants than non-Mexicans in border apprehensions.