31.Parliament 06: Money Bill & Budget Flashcards
What are Motions and Resolutions?
Motions and Resolutions are not mentioned in the Constitution.
According to Article 106, who determines the salaries and allowances of members?
The salaries and allowances of members are determined by Parliament by law, as mentioned in Article 106.
What are bills?
Bills are draft laws that are discussed in parliament and, if passed, become laws.
What happens when a bill is passed by law by parliament and passed by the President?
When a bill is passed by law by parliament and passed by the President, it becomes the law.
Can you give an example of a bill becoming a law?
The Uniform Civil Code bill is an example of a bill becoming a law.
How many types of bills are mentioned in the Constitution?
The Constitution mentions two types of bills: Ordinary Bills and Money Bills.
Are there other types of bills in practice?
Yes, in practice, there are various types of bills, in addition to Ordinary Bills and Money Bills.
How many types of ordinary bills are there?
There are two types of ordinary bills: Government Bills and Private member Bills.
What subjects are ordinary bills concerned with?
Ordinary bills are concerned with any matter other than financial subjects, as per Articles 107 and 108 of the Indian Constitution.
Who can introduce an ordinary bill?
An ordinary bill can be introduced in either House of the Parliament by a Minister or a Private member.
Is a recommendation from the President required for ordinary bills?
No, there is no recommendation of the President required in the case of ordinary bills.
Can ordinary bills be amended or rejected by Rajya Sabha?
Yes, ordinary bills can be amended or rejected by Rajya Sabha through a simple majority vote. They can also be detained by Rajya Sabha for a period of six months.
What happens after an ordinary bill is passed by both houses of Parliament?
After being passed by both houses of Parliament, an ordinary bill is presented to the President for his approval or assent under Article 111 of the Indian Constitution.
Is there a provision for a joint sitting in the case of ordinary bills?
Yes, there is a provision for a joint sitting in the case of ordinary bills under Article 108 of the Indian Constitution.
What is Article 368 of the Indian Constitution concerned with?
Article 368 of the Indian Constitution is concerned with the provisions of amendment of the Constitution.
What is a Constitutional Amendment Bill?
A Constitutional Amendment Bill is a bill that seeks to change one or more provisions of the Constitution.
Who can introduce a Constitutional Amendment Bill?
A Constitutional Amendment Bill can be introduced either by a minister or by a private member, and it does not require prior permission of the president.
What majority is required to pass a Constitutional Amendment Bill?
A Constitutional Amendment Bill requires a special majority in each house to pass the bill.
Is there a provision for a joint sitting in the case of a Constitutional Amendment Bill?
No, there is no provision for a joint sitting to resolve a deadlock in the case of a Constitutional Amendment Bill.
What is the requirement for ratification by the states for a Constitutional Amendment Bill?
If a Constitutional Amendment Bill relates to the division of powers between the Centre and the States, it must be ratified by at least half of the states.
What is the role of the President in relation to a Constitutional Amendment Bill?
In the case of a Constitutional Amendment Bill, the President must give his assent to the bill. He cannot withhold or return the bill.
What are Money Bills?
Money Bills are those bills that are concerned with financial matters like taxation, public expenditure, etc.
What matters are specified in Article 110 of the Indian Constitution related to Money Bills?
Money Bills contain provisions that deal with all or any of the matters specified in Article 110 of the Indian Constitution.
In which house of Parliament is a Money Bill presented?
A Money Bill is presented only in Lok Sabha.
Is the President’s recommendation required before introducing a Money Bill?
Yes, a Money Bill is introduced only after the President’s recommendation.
Can a Money Bill be amended or rejected by Rajya Sabha?
No, a Money Bill cannot be amended or rejected by Rajya Sabha.
How long can Rajya Sabha detain a Money Bill?
Rajya Sabha can detain a Money Bill for a maximum period of 14 days.
What happens to the Money Bill after being detained by Rajya Sabha?
The Money Bill has to be returned to the Lok Sabha with or without the recommendations of Rajya Sabha. Lok Sabha has the power to reject or accept those recommendations.
When is a Money Bill sent to the President for approval?
A Money Bill is sent to the President for his approval only after being passed by the Lok Sabha.
Is there a provision for a joint sitting in the case of a Money Bill?
No, there is no provision for a joint sitting in the case of a Money Bill.
What is a Private Member’s Bill?
A Private Member’s Bill is a bill introduced by a Member of Parliament who is not a Minister.
What is the difference between a Private Member’s Bill and a Government Bill?
A Private Member’s Bill is introduced by a non-Minister Member of Parliament, whereas a Government Bill is introduced by one of the Ministers of the Council of Ministers.
Do Government Bills or Private Member’s Bills have a greater chance of being accepted by the House?
Government Bills generally enjoy greater chances of being accepted by the House than Private Member’s Bills.
What can Private Members do in terms of legislative proposals?
Private Members may move a legislative proposal or a Bill that they think is fit to be included in the Statute Book.
What assistance is provided by the Secretariat in drafting a Private Member’s Bill?
The Secretariat may render only technical advice, if desired, in the drafting of a Bill by a Private Member. The member is responsible for drafting the Bill.
Are Private Members provided with expert advice for their Bills?
In respect of Private Members’ Bills, the Members may not have access to expert advice, and there are certain procedures regulating the consideration of such Bills.
What is the first requirement for a Private Member’s Bill?
The first requirement for a Private Member’s Bill is that it should be within the legislative competence of the Parliament.
What documents are required to accompany the notices of Private Members’ Bills?
The notices of Private Members’ Bills are required to be accompanied by copies of the text of the Bill, together with a Statement of Objects and Reasons duly signed by the member giving notice.
What information should be included in a Private Member’s Bill?
A Private Member’s Bill should also provide an estimate of recurring and non-recurring expenditures likely to be involved if the Bill is passed into law.
When is the previous sanction or recommendation of the President required for introducing a Bill?
The previous sanction or recommendation of the President is required if the Bill is one that, under the Constitution, cannot be introduced without such sanction or recommendation. This includes Union power under Articles 3 and state taxes under Article 274 of the Constitution.
What should the member-in-charge of the Bill do if previous sanction or recommendation of the President is required?
The member-in-charge of the Bill should annex to the notice a copy of such sanction or recommendation, as the notice is not valid until this requirement is complied with.
What is the process for obtaining the recommendation of the President?
The member sends a request to the Secretariat for obtaining the recommendation of the President. The request is then forwarded to the concerned Ministry, which obtains the orders of the President and communicates them to the Secretariat. The Secretariat, upon receiving the intimation of the President’s order, communicates it to the member and publishes it in the Bulletin.
What is the requirement for taking into consideration or referring a Bill to a Select/Joint Committee?
A Bill that would involve expenditure from the Consolidated Fund of India cannot be taken into consideration or referred to a Select/Joint Committee unless the member-in-charge obtains the requisite recommendation of the President for consideration of the Bill under Article 117(3) of the Constitution.
What should the members-in-charge of such Bills do?
In the case of Bills that would involve expenditure from the Consolidated Fund of India, members-in-charge should obtain the recommendation of the President beforehand in order to proceed further with the Bill.
When was the last time a Private Members’ Bill was passed by the Parliament?
No Private Members’ Bills have been passed by the Parliament since 1970.
What percentage of Private Members’ Bills introduced in the 14th Lok Sabha were discussed?
Barely four percent of the Private Members’ Bills introduced in the 14th Lok Sabha were discussed.
How many MPs introduced all the Private Members’ Bills in the 14th Lok Sabha?
Only 67 MPs introduced all the Private Members’ Bills in the 14th Lok Sabha.
Which party’s MPs introduced more Bills on average, Congress or BJP?
On average, Congress MPs introduced more Bills than their BJP counterparts.
Can you provide an example of a Private Members’ Bill that was passed by the Rajya Sabha but defeated in the Lok Sabha?
The Rights of Transgender Persons Bill, 2014, moved by Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam MP Tiruchi Siva, was passed by the Rajya Sabha in 2015 but was defeated in the Lok Sabha.
How much notice must a Member give before introducing a Private Members’ Bill?
A Member must give at least a month’s notice before introducing such bills.