3.10.1- Managing change Flashcards
What impact can trade unions have on overcoming resistance to change?
if trade union agrees with the change then they can get the employees on board
it may help management to understand why there is resistance if they engage with workers’ representatives
can influence the balance of (Lewin’s) forces that either support or resist change
-how can trade unions help with overcoming resistance to change and how could they make it more difficult
management may ignore outcomes of consultation
-may create too much delay
- the nature of the strategic change creates too much conflict
-the extent to which workers within the firm/industry are represented by a trade union
-whether relations with unions are strong or not
What are the 6 methods of dealing with resistance to change (Kotter and Schlesinger)
education + communication
participation + involvement
facilitation + support
negotiation +agreement
manipulation + co-optation
explicit + implicit coercion
When is education + communication commonly used in situations (methods of dealing with resistance to change)
where there is a lack of information or inaccurate information and analysis
When is participation + involvement commonly used in situations (methods of dealing with resistance to change)
when the initiators do not have all the information they need to design the change, and where others have considerable power to resist
When is facilitation + support commonly used in situations (methods of dealing with resistance to change)
where people are resisting because of adjustment problems
When is negotiation + agreement commonly used in situations (methods of dealing with resistance to change)
where someone or some group will clearly lose out in a change, and where that group has considerable power to resist
When is manipulation + co-option commonly used in situations (methods of dealing with resistance to change)
where other tactics will not work or are too expensive
When is explicit + implicit coercion commonly used in situations (methods of dealing with resistance to change)
where speed is essential, and the change initiators possesses considerable power
Advantage of education + communication (methods of dealing with resistance to change)
one persuaded, people will often help with the implementation of the change
Disadvantage of education + communication (methods of dealing with resistance to change)
can be very time - consuming if lots of people are involved
Advantage of participation + involvement (methods of dealing with resistance to change)
people who participate will be committed to implementing change and any relevant information they have will be integrated into the change plan
Disadvantage of participation + involvement (methods of dealing with resistance to change)
Can be very time consuming if participants design an inappropriate change
Advantage of facilitation + support (methods of dealing with resistance to change)
no other approach works as well with adjustment problems
Disadvantage of facilitation + support (methods of dealing with resistance to change)
can be time consuming, expensive and still fail
Advantage of negotiation + agreement (methods of dealing with resistance to change)
sometimes it is a relatively easy way to avoid major resistance
Disadvantage of negotiation + agreement (methods of dealing with resistance to change)
can be too expensive in many cases if it alerts others to negotiate for compliance
Advantage of manipulation + co-option (methods of dealing with resistance to change)
where other tactics will not work or are too expensive
Disadvantage of manipulation + co-option (methods of dealing with resistance to change)
can lead to future problems if people feel manipulated
Advantage of explicit + implicit coercion (methods of dealing with resistance to change)
it is speedy and can overcome any kind of resistance
Disadvantage of explicit + implicit coercion (methods of dealing with resistance to change)
can be risky if it leaves people mad at the initiators
Famous examples of resistance to change
“There is no chance that the iphone is going to get any significant market share” Steve Ballmer, microsoft CEO 2007
“TV wont be able to hold any market - people will get tired of staring at a plywood box every night” - Darryl Zanuck, executive at 20th century fox- 1946
Kotter and Schlesinger- 4 reasons for resistance for change
Parochial self-interest
misunderstanding and lack of trust
different assessments
low tolerance for change
What is self interest
concerned with how changes will affect their own interests