3 Flashcards
What are the 5 elements of Bowlby’s Monotropic Theory?
- Adaptive
- Social releasers
- Critical period
- Monotropic
- Internal working model
Who proposed the Monotropic Theory?
Bowlby
Why did Bowlby propose the Monotropic Theory?
He rejected the Learning Theory in regards to attachment - wanting to take a more evolutionary stance
Is Bowlby on the side of nature or nurture?
Nature - he believes attachment is innate
Outline the ‘adaptive’ part of Bowlby’s theory?
- Attachment is innate
- Species have evolved/adapted to form an attachment, as it gives them a survival advantage (protection, food, etc)
Outline the ‘social releasers’ part of Bowlby’s theory?
- Infants display social releasers
- Social releasers = innate ‘cute’ behaviours infants exhibit to attract the attention of adults, so they reciprocate attachment behaviours
- E.g. smiling, cooing, gripping
- Adults respond through displays of SENSITIVE RESPONSIVENESS (e.g. engaging in interactional synchrony)
Outline the ‘critical period’ part of Bowlby’s theory
- Critical period = sensitive period in which infants can form attachments
- Bowlby believed infants have a critical period of 2yrs
- (First 6 months of the 2 yr period is most sensitive)
- After 2 yrs, if infants haven’t formed attachments they will struggle to
Outline the ‘Monotropic’ part of Bowlby’s theory?
- Monotropic = emphasis on attachment to one particular caregiver
- Bowlby believed this Monotropic attachment was to the mother
- (Has since been believed to be to any ‘primary attachment figure’)
- Bowlby claimed more time with this figure strengthened attachment (used LAW OF CONTINUITY + LAW OF ACCUMULATED SEPARATION)
What is the Law of Continuity?
The more constant + predictable the care, the better the attachment
What is the Law of Accumulated Separation?
The effects of every separation (from primary attachment figure) add up + worsen attachment
‘Safest dose is therefore a zero dose’ - Bowlby (1975)
Outline the ‘Internal Working Model’ part of Bowlby’s theory
- Internal working model = mental representation child has of their relationship with their primary attachment figure, believed to act as a template, setting the expectation for future relationships (including own role as a parent)
If first relationship is loving, what does the internal working model suggest about that person’s later relationships?
Will expect love + reliability from relationship partner, and will act that way themselves
If first relationship is bad, what does the internal working model suggest about that person’s later relationships?
Expect poor treatment from others, and may treat others poorly
Give 2 positive evaluation points for Bowlby’s Monotropic Theory?
Research support from animal studies
- Harlow: critical period, monotropic, internal working model
- Lorenz: adaptive, critical period, monotropic
Research support for internal working model
- Bailey et al (2007): study on 99 mothers + their own mother/infant relationships used internal working model for parental relationships
- Hazan + Shaver (1987): ‘Love Quiz’ used internal working model for later love relationships
Give 2 negative evaluation points for Bowlby’s Monotropic Theory
Research to refute critical period (actually sensitive period)
- Rutter et al (1998)
- Romanian orphan research
- Despite being disadvantaged, orphans did have ability to form later attachments (just less likely)
- Concluded critical period ISN’T ONLY time to form attachments, its just the EASIEST time for form attachments
Monotropy has issue of social sensitivity
- Feminists (e.g. Erica Burman 1994) say his theory pressurises women to stay at home
- Women worried to work due to negative affects of law of continuity + accumulated separation
- Should be reevaluated in modern society
What is the Learning Theory?
Behaviourists place emphasis on the role of learning in the acquisition of behaviour