2.a. The geography of gender inequality is complex and contested. Flashcards
What is gender inequality?
The unequal treatment of individuals based on their gender where by men or usually women are denied the same rights and opportunities across sectors of society.
Statistics show that in many instances, females suffer from gender inequality the most. How?
The average wage gap between men and women in 2013 was 19.7%.
What can gender inequality majorly limit?
Development.
Global patterns of gender inequality are closely related to what?
Disparities in respect for the rights of women.
How is gender inequality measured? Who created it?
The Global Gender Gap Index (GGGI).
Devised by the World Economic Forum (WEF).
What are the 4 key areas that the Global Gender Gap Index focuses on?
Health and survival.
Educational attainment.
Economic participation and opportunity.
Political empowerment.
State 2 factors measured in the ‘health and survival’ area of the GGGI.
Sex ratio at birth.
Healthy life expectancy.
State 2 factors measured in the ‘educational attainment’ area of the GGGI.
Literacy rate.
Enrolment in primary education.
Enrolment in secondary education.
Enrolment in tertiary education.
State 2 factors measured in the ‘economic participation and opportunity’ area of the GGGI.
Labour force participation.
Wage equality for similar work.
Estimated earned income.
Legislators, senior officials and managers.
Professional and technical workers.
State 2 factors measured in the ‘political empowerment’ area of the GGGI.
Women in parliament.
Women in ministerial positions.
Years with female head of state (last 50).
What is a strength of the GGGI’s ‘economic participation and opportunity’ key area?
Good discriminator for ACs.
Highlights the effectiveness of opportunities to education and rights.
What is a strength of the GGGI’s ‘educational attainment’ key area?
Shows more students being given the opportunity to attend school.
Education level split may indicate the dropout gender split. E.g. women married off to have children.
What is a strength of the GGGI’s ‘health and survival’ key area?
Some countries restrict gender differences, e.g. China prefers boys than girls - so forced ratios can easily be recorded.
Equality in access to healthcare.
What is a strength of the GGGI’s ‘political empowerment’ key area?
Women in parliament are able to make informed decisions on the basis of their own gender. This allows governments to provide for a wider population.
What is a weakness of the GGGI’s ‘economic participation and opportunity’ key area?
Female desire for job preference is not accounted for.
Wage differences are affected by job/ career choice.
What is a weakness of the GGGI’s ‘educational attainment’ key area?
Enrolment does not assess actual learning. High enrolment does not equal high attendance.
Education is the first step but of little use if opportunities stop.
What is a weakness of the GGGI’s ‘health and survival’ key area?
Doesn’t cover aspects of actions like FGM or access to family planning.
What is a weakness of the GGGI’s ‘political empowerment’ key area?
Women may be in political positions, but this doesn’t consider the inputs they provide.
Years in power distorted by long-term head of state, so is not representative.
What are the high priority recommendations for the government in order to improve Human Rights in Saudi Arabia?
(Modern slavery in Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States: Case Study)
Remove laws or policies that prevent or make it difficult for workers to leave abusive employers without risk of loss of visa and deportation and/or security deposits.
Criminalise forced labour in line with international conventions.
Increase the legal age of marriage for males and females to 18 years.
How many people in SA and the GS are estimated to be living in modern slavery?
(Modern slavery in Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States: Case Study)
1.7 million. (10.1 per 1000).
How many people in SA and the GS are in forced labour? What about forced marriages?
(Modern slavery in Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States: Case Study)
52% in forced labour, and 48% in forced marriages.
What is Saudi Arabia’s modern slavery vulnerability score?
(Modern slavery in Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States: Case Study)
56%.
What Gulf states have the best government response to modern slavery?
(Modern slavery in Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States: Case Study)
Bahrain (55%).
UAE (50%).
Qatar (49%).
What Gulf states have the worst government response to modern slavery?
(Modern slavery in Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States: Case Study)
Lebanon (33%).
Iraq (33%).
Kuwait (37%).
In 2021, an estimated how many individuals in the Arab States region were living in modern slavery?
(Modern slavery in Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States: Case Study)
1.7 million.
In the Arab States region, what was the most common form of exploitation? How many people does this account for?
(Modern slavery in Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States: Case Study)
Forced labour.
This accounts for just over half of people living in modern slavery (52%).
What country has the highest estimated number of people in modern slavery, compared to other Gulf States?
(Modern slavery in Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States: Case Study)
Saudi Arabia.
What is the Kafala system?
(Modern slavery in Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States: Case Study)
A system used to monitor migrant laborers, working primarily in the construction and domestic sectors in Gulf Cooperation Council member states
Has the Kafala system been positive?
(Modern slavery in Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States: Case Study)
No, the kafala system in certain countries has increased the risk of labour exploitation for migrant workers in the region.
How has conflict (particularly in Syria, Iraq, and Yemen) contributed to modern slavery experiences?
(Modern slavery in Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States: Case Study)
Forced and child marriages.
Trafficking.
Exploitation of displaced families.
Yazidis face persecution by ISIS, due to ongoing terrorist attacks in Kurdish regions. How can this be applied to modern slavery?
(Modern slavery in Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States: Case Study)
Yazidi men and women abducted by ISIS in 2014 remain missing, with reports of some still being enslaved in various locations.
What may lead to inaccurate modern slavery estimate statistics? Give an example.
(Modern slavery in Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States: Case Study)
Data collection gaps and limitations in conflict-ridden countries.
E.g. child soldier recruitment and organ trafficking, may not be fully captured.
Outline conflict as a driver of vulnerability to modern slavery in Arab States.
Conflict is a significant driver of vulnerability in the Arab States, with heightened risks of modern slavery in Iraq, Syria, and Yemen due to conflict. Oman and the UAE, experiencing comparatively low conflict levels, show less vulnerability.
Discrimination against minority groups, political instability, and lack of political rights contribute to vulnerability.
Outline COVID-19 as a driver of vulnerability to modern slavery in Arab States.
COVID-19 has exacerbated risks, leading to increased wage theft, detention, confinement, and unemployment, particularly affecting migrant workers in GCC countries.
During the pandemic, women and girls in the region faced heavier domestic work burdens and increased risk of gender-based violence.
Outline gender inequality as a driver of vulnerability to modern slavery in Arab States.
Gender inequality is a large issue, with all Arab States (except the UAE) ranking poorly in the World Economic Forum’s 2021 Global Gender Gap Index.
Outline erosion of state protection as a driver of vulnerability to modern slavery in Arab States.
The erosion of state protection in conflict-affected countries increases the risk of conflict-related sexual violence and slavery.
Outline climate change as a driver of vulnerability to modern slavery in Arab States.
Climate change effects, such as severe drought in Syria and desertification in Jordan, contribute to extreme water stress across most Arab States.
Climate change exacerbates push factors for modern slavery, including poverty, and loss of livelihoods.
Climate change effects, such as severe drought in Syria and desertification in Jordan, contribute to extreme water stress across most Arab States.
Climate-related resource scarcity can trigger conflict and recruitment into armed groups, compounding vulnerability to modern slavery.
Outline natural disasters as a driver of vulnerability to modern slavery in Arab States.
Natural disasters in Yemen and disruptions to food imports worsen the humanitarian crisis.
Outline threatened livelihoods as a driver of vulnerability to modern slavery in Arab States.
Threatened livelihoods may lead to negative coping mechanisms like forced and child marriage, and irregular migration, heightening trafficking risks.
What is the variation in the global pattern of the gender gap?
The greater a countries HDI, the greater its GGGI.
ACs have better gender equality than LIDCs.
Scandinavian countries have the highest GGGI.
However, there are exceptions such as Uganda (LIDC) which has a low HDI but a GGGI that is much greater.
Compared to Italy (AC), Uganda has 0.010 GGGI, but 0.355 lower HDI.
What is the mean GGGI for Western Europe?
0.802
What is the mean GGGI for Sub-Saharan Africa?
0.652
What is the mean GGGI for Middle East and North America?
0.570
What is the median GGGI for Western Europe?
0.806
What is the median GGGI for Sub-Saharan Africa?
0.652