2020-theft/robbery/burgulary Flashcards
What is the definition of theft
Dishonest appropriation of property belonging to another with the intention of permanently depriving
What is appropriation
Taking on rights of owner
Eg destroying property
Selling on property
Taking it
R v Morris ( appropriation case )
2 ds caught switching price labels in supermarket, still appropriation theft before attempting to buy
Lawrence v commissioner for MP. ( appropriation)
Foreign tourist offers wallet to taxi driver to take money for short trip, taxi driver takes £6 when it was only 60p. Guilty still as only given permission to take correct amount
R v Gomez (appropriation)
Manager and his friends use fake cheques to steal £16,000 worth of goods. Guilty still as the argument of consent failed
R v hinks (appropriation)
Woman deceives older man into giving her £60,000. Argued he was giving it to her but failed
Why did R v atakpu fail ( appropriation)
Theft is not a continuing act and the crime was committed abroad
What comes under property
Money- coins and notes
Real property- term for lands and buildings
Personal property- all moveable items even a corpse
Things in action- cheques
Intangible property- patents, exam paper Qs
R v Kelly and Lindsay (property)
Women sculpts dead bodies when only given permission to draw
LP- court decided it was property
Attorney general for Hong Kong v chan Nai-keung
Property
Held that a licence was property
Oxford v Moss ( property)
Knowledge of exam paper not property, would have been if he intended to take paper permanently
What cannot be stolen
animals and plants from the wild unless done for resale
Who classes as “belonging to another”
covers wide defintion
owner, someone who has control over property at a certain time, can be when item was stolen.
R V Turner (belonging to another)
D steals car from garage so he doesnt have to pay for repairs- shows you can steal from yourself
Woodman (belonging to another)
Someone can be owner of property even although they are unaware it is on their land
Webster (belonging to another)
Army Sgt sells duplicate medal on ebay. MOD still had proprietary intrest and therefore theft
Hall (belonging to another)
Travel agent deposits money for customers into general store account and doesn’t manage to book tickets. not under obligation to deal with tickets in certain way
Klineberg and Marsden (belonging to another)
had clear obligation to deal with moeny certain way- guilty of theft
Davidge v Bunnett (belonging to another)
given money for gas bill and spends on xmas presents. informal but still given under obligation
Attorney General’s Reference 1985 (belonging to another)
guilty to return money she was overpayed and she acted dishonestly.
R v gilks (belonging to another)
betting transactions not enforcable by law so not guilty of theft.
what are the three ways stated in the theft act which do not classify as dishonesty
s 2 1a- believe has right to deprive on behalf of themselves or third party
s 2 1b- thought they would have Ds consent if they knew of appropriation
s 2 1c-if person can’t be reached taking reasonable steps.
R V Holden shows
s 2 1 b- he believed he would have been given tires from the supervisor
R v Robinson shows
s 2 1 a- believed he had the right to £5 note
R v small shows
s 2 1 c- believed the cars owner couldn’t be found
what test can be relied upon if theft act does not cover D’s “dishonest” actions
the ghosh test
what did the ghost test create
subjective and objective test