2. Types of investors and their objectives (Week 2) Flashcards
65 years old retiree
- Single, no children, healthy and active
- Live a comfortable lifestyle
- Renting, no mortgage, no credit card debt
- Only asset is $5 million cash in deposit account with NAB
what are the risks?
- unlikely to have high inflation to erode wealth.
- bankrupty of NAB
-
Ways in which investors can differ
Objectives
Risk preferences
Investment horizon
Investor circumstances
Business or personal considerations
receive company shares as part of bonus or incentive
tied up with same company .
diversify away from your company
Ways in which investors can differ
Objectives
Risk preferences
Investment horizon
Investor circumstances
reference portfolios
relevant for portfolio managers
benchmark to evaluate portfolio manager’s performance. Risk averse as portfolio managers. not too different from industry norm.
Ways in which investors can differ
Objectives
Risk preferences
Investment horizon
Investor circumstances
•need for liquidity or ‘immediacy’
need cash from their fund
Ways in which investors can differ
Objectives
Risk preferences
Investment horizon
Investor circumstances
- need for liquidity or ‘immediacy’
- costs – management fees, transaction costs, taxation, etc
- reference portfolios – legacy portfolio; ‘background’ assets like human capital, residential property
- business or personal considerations, e.g. career
Ways in which investors can differ
Objectives
Risk preferences
Investment horizon
•holding period vs. review period why?
Investor circumstances
Regularly review of portfolio performance give you chance to new changes of life and investment opportunities.
Ways in which investors can differ
Objectives
Risk preferences
Investment horizon
•holding period vs. review period
Investor circumstances
Holding period = entire investment horizon . 30-40 years of investment horizon
Review period = regularly check portfolio performance over certain period
Ways in which investors can differ
Objectives
Risk preferences
Investment horizon
Investor circumstances
- holding period (entire investment horizon) vs. review period
- dynamics, i.e. investing over more than just one period
Ways in which investors can differ
Objectives
Risk preferences
Investment horizon
Investor circumstances
Will continue until we do not need funds from superannuation
can be indefinite e.g. family trust. providing trust flow for future generations
Ways in which investors can differ
Objectives
Risk preferences
Investment horizon
Investor circumstances
Australian pension funds have
offered Defined benefit funds to defined contribution funds in the last 20 years
DB funds calculation
e.g. uni super
based on age
years of service
how much you’ve contributed
your salary over 5 years
Defined contribution Funds
features
make regular contribution. manage asset allocation in super account by yourself
when you retire, take what is in super account.
DB Fund
Risk
Chance the fund is not able to meet liability payment
value of total assets and value of liabilities. Difference measures the risk. Larger the difference, fund is in deficit and in trouble
DB Fund Objective
meet liability
benefits payout obligation for retiring members
investment horizon is indefinite
DC Funds Objective
Some may want to use it to payout their mortgage when they retire
set up family trust to benefit future generations
set up retirement living
How do portfolio managers manage DC Funds
Given benchmark. I invest in High growth in diversified portfolio product.
This portfolio manager will be given a benchment e.g.
Average performance of all of the high growth superannuation funds in Australia.
How do portfolio managers manage DB Fund
manage the gap
asset allocation decision: improve situation of fund. If there is deficit, try to reduce the deficit.
insurance companies
Put collected premium and put in investment fund
objective
Meet policy holders. Meeting liabilities
generate return as profit. impact of profit
Endowments & Foundations
Objectievs
certain programs to support e.g upgrade IT system, build library.
That will depend on income. Return greater than long term inflation
Fund managers
objective
e.g. retail mutual funds, colonial first state
concerned with profit of the fund and concern of the relative performance e.g. published by morning star and internal ranking of their performance. Under constant pressure to outperform.
Private investors incl SMSF
Objective
Risk
•
•70-year old retired surgeon
–Self-funded retiree
–Own house (paid off)
–Live a very comfortable lifestyle ($65,000/year)
–Superannuation $5 million
Other assets $15 million
is 5m enough for them to live with for the rest of their life
Not able to finance him the rest of his life
Private investors incl SMSF
Objective
Risk
•70-year old retiree
–Government pension
–Renting
–Live a modest lifestyle ($20,000/year)
–Total assets of $20,000 cash from inheritance
–Need $1,000 cash every year for a chronicle disease treatment
Generate 5% return P.a
Not being able to fund that
Definition Risk
- Risk as the possibility of an adverse outcome
- An adverse outcome as failure to meet objectives
Corporate Super DB Fund
Objective
Investment horizon
meet the benefits payment requirement (liability) of its members
•on-going, indefinite
Corporate Super DB Fund
difference from DB Fund
Profit target for managers, executives and board of directors
anything you take from the pocket of shareholders will go to DB Fund to form part of assets.
Corporate Super DB Fund
asset allocation decision
member
produce a perfect match
just need to be paid retirement funds
Corporate Super DB Fund
asset allocation decision
Executives
Board of DB Fund, they have own performance pressure e.g. total shareholder return, profitability target
Corporate Super DB Fund
asset allocation decision
sponsoring entity(the company)
Push for higher asset allocation to growth assets = higher expected returns, higher expected future incomes and higher chance of meeting future liability of the fund
BUT HAVE TO CONSIDER
higher volatility between assets and liability. high deficit. High difference between asset and liability. Another GFC, huge deficit b/c of asset allocation of 80% growth assets
Corporate Super DB Fund
asset allocation decision
is the outcome of “negotiations” among all stakeholder who have distinct objectives.
üSponsoring entity (the company)
üMembers
üPortfolio managers
üGovernment
Corporate Super DB Fund
members
Employees, union, company management eg CEO, members of DB Fund
Corporate Super DB Fund
Risk is defined by
difference between value of assets and value of estimated benefits Net PV of future benefits payout
that is for the fund
What is the asset allocation decision
To predict to relevant risk
e.g. allocating asset risk to manage the risk. higher chance of achieving objectives
the essence of investment management is the management of risk, not management of returns
how to measure risk for objective
Others - regret
probability of wrong choice
how to measure risk for objective
Relative Benchmark aka peer risk
Tracking error. How much you deviate from industry norm of asset allocation
200 index as benchmark. your asset allocation decision will help you meet that benchmark or perform as well.
Sometimes portfolio managers will take additional risk by allocating assets away from benchmark.
if there is 25% asset allocation with ASX 200 in banking sector, if you are embarrassed with banking sector given recent renovation by banking commission and want to allocate in portfolio of 20% or 15% in banking sector in your own portfolio.
Generating substantial peer risk. Other portfolio managers in the industry are allocation 25% and you are allocation 15%. if you are right
how to measure risk for objective
Absolute target return
objective by fund manager
e.g. 3% excess return above inflation using inflation as benchmark or 1% above australian equity funds in the market. difference of portfolio performance and benchmark will be the risk measure
Shortfall
how to measure risk for objective
Suppot spending programs for endowment funds
Shortfall
difference between desired spending and income generated by endowment funds
how to measure risk for objective
Consumption in retirement
Shortfall
difference between desired consumption and available superannuation income stream
how to measure risk for objective
Profit impact
profit volatility
any contribution made by sponsoring entities for company is taken from the profit available for distrubition to shareholders
how to measure risk for objective
Meeting liabilities
surplus volatility/shortfall
how to measure risk for objective
Maximize E[U(W)]
Maximise utility of wealth
•Asset/portfolio volatility (drops)
especially the downside
Issues with quantitative risk measures
Characterising the distribution
parametic vs non-parametric
We do both to have better understanding of risk
parametic (Model-based) have certain assumptions that return follows certain assumptions e.g. standard deviation.
vs
non-parametric (Data-based)
- don’t care about distribution of returns; only focus on data i have. Calculate the probability of loss. don’t care about Z score or confidence interval. don’t assume they follow assumptions
- rely on data, over different period, different numbers of quantitaitve measures of risk eg probability of loss
Issues with quantitative risk measures
•Matters that cannot be easily incorporated
Personal
personal assets .g. human capital, family home
difficult to quantify or assess
Issues with quantitative risk measures
•Matters that cannot be easily incorporated
Funding or
funding or cash flow uncertainty and illiquidity risk
- Funding or cash flow uncertainty
DB Funds, endowment or charity funds e.g. major blow of contribution. have to change their asset allocation to meet the expected expenditure. have to deal with other damages of the risk associated with the funds.
Issues with quantitative risk measures
•Matters that cannot be easily incorporated
Risks
–Business risk (bankrupty risk), personnel risk, counterparty risk, governance-related failures, changes in public policy
- very hard to forecast these