16 - Remuneration of directors and senior execs Flashcards
6 reasons why remuneration is such an important CG issue
- Remuneration is a very important aspect of attracting and retaining talented execs
- Remuneration incentives can be used to motivate executives to achieve better results for the company
- It is pivotal to not reward directors for failure
- Incentive schemes need to be aligned with interests of shareholders
- High levels of exec pay can undermine public trust
- Directors should not be able to decide or influence their own remuneration
5 components of executive remuneration
- Basic salary
- Payments into pension scheme
- Annual bonus
- Long-term incentives - share options and share grants
- Other benefits - such as company car
2 elements of remuneration pay that components can be divided into
- Fixed
- Variable
Which components of remuneration make up fixed element?
- Salary
- Pension contributions
- Other benefits
What can variable element of remuneration pay be divided into?
- Short-term incentives - usually cash
- Long-term incentives - share options or share grants
How are annual bonus payments typically achieved?
Meeting financial performance targets
5 KPIs for financial performance re. short term remuneration
- EPS (profits divided by shares in issue)
- Profit before interest and taxation (PBIT)
- Total shareholder return (dividend and share price appreciation)
- Earnings before interest, taxation, depreciation and amortisation (EBITDA)
- Return on capital employed (ROCE)
Explain deferred annual bonus schemes
Company may offer to provide annual bonus either in full or part as shares in the company. Usually held on trust for 3 years
Why is a share option a long-term incentive for execs?
Exercise price is fixed, typically at market value at time of issuing. The more that the share price rises before the option is exercised, the more of a good deal (and opportunity for immediate profit) the director gets.
Typically 10 year max on exercising
Explain grants of shares
‘Performance shares’, ownership of which will be conditional on achievement of targets.
Closer to target, higher % of shares awarded
2 most common performance measures for long-term incentives
EPS & TSR
Grant Thornton CG Review 2018
9 problems/considerations in linking remuneration with co’s performance
- Whether to include non-financial targets
- Setting thresholds (obtainable but challenging)
- Whether to place a cap
- Ensuring targets promote LT success
- Ensuring targets do not promote bad behaviour
- Difficulties in isolating each execs performance
- Difficult to prevent new execs benefitting from legacy effects
- Directors may expect rewards regardless of success
- Major shareholders should consider scheme satisfactory
Use of comparative pay data in remuneration
Companies may decide to base fixed and/or variable remuneration on that of competitors
Issue to consider with comparative remuneration pay
If all companies in comparative group decide to pay above average pay, pay will spiral up and up
3 drawbacks to using share options for long-term incentive schemes
- Shareholders may prefer dividends, and execs may have interest in keeping dividends low until options are exercised
- Share prices may rise in line with general stock market rise, rather than co’s success (vice versa)
- Share option will not provide any incentive if share price drops
Meaning behind provision 35 - ‘Independent judgement should be exercised when evaluating advice of third parties [on remuneration]’
Remuneration committee should not blindly follow recommendations of remuneration consultants
According to Code, should NEDs’ remuneration be performance based?
No
How does UKCG Code define ‘senior management’
The executive committee or the first layer of management below board level (including the CoSec)
Are the board responsible for remuneration consultants?
No, the remuneration committee are
3 main concerns over remuneration consultants
- Objectivity
- Believed to have played role in promoting spiralling exec pay
- Intentionally complex
3 reasons behind concerns on remuneration consultants
- CoIs if engaged by execs to advise on other aspects or if connected to an exec, meaning they may make recos which favour execs over company
- Inclined to recommend complex schemes to raise their fees and make them harder to dispense of
- Execs, senior management and consultants themselves may put pressure on rem com to accept advice
Rem Com report for quoted co’s must include: (2)
- Details regarding membership of committee
- Statement summarising major decisions made in relation to remuneration, and context