1.5.2 Government intervention and failure Flashcards

1
Q

The polluter pay principle

A

Price of a product that pollutes should reflect both the private costs of production and external costs (social cost) → happens when external costs can be internalised and changing laws/regulations can cause this

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

Incentive

A

Any factor (financial or not) that enables or motivates a particular course of action, or is a reason for preferring one choice to the alternatives

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

what does gov intervention address

A

Government intervention addresses a number of market failures:
- Reducing the impact of external costs
- Ensuring that potentially under-produced products are available to all, as with healthcare and education
- Ensuring that over consumed goods (demerit goods) are discouraged or prevented
- Reducing the impact of anti-competitive business behaviour so prices are fair to the consumer

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

5 different strategies to oppose market failure

A
  • Regulation → rules that apply to organisations. Gov, the EU and trade associations make rules that enforce standards across whole industries
  • Legislation → passing new laws to restrict activities that create negative externalities and over consumption
  • Indirect taxation → can increase the price of products that are over produced, making them more expensive to consume and reducing demand (sugar tax) → CONTRACTION
  • Grants and subsidies → make under consumed products cheaper and encourage increased consumption (merit goods)
  • Voluntary agreements → work well when there is a widespread agreement on the need for change
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

regulations

A

A particular type of legislation that defines the rights and obligations of individuals and organisations.
- Govs can use it to influence the extent to which negative externalities affect the quality of life in our society.
- Politics can influence what is regulated and by how much it is regulated

Usually for environmental standards and then monitor and control activity:
- May take the form of a quota or setting minimum standards for environmental emissions
- Regulatory bodies can inspect and prosecute businesses that fail to comply, but full monitoring can be costly to enforce and difficult
- The UK environment agency set out all the regulation that affect the environment in the UK

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

regulation for demerit and banned goods

A

For demerit goods
- Can see what the socially acceptable quantity demanded should be to internalise external costs,
- This informs the government on how to implement regulation

For banned goods
- At all levels social cost> social benefit
- The gov action would be to - completely ban (guns, drug)
There is no equilbrium reached

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

extending property rights

A

This is a way of internalising the externality → making the producer responsible for the spill-over costs
- consumers/individuals are given the right to sue firms for damages to cover spill-over costs, so the firm is forced to pay these costs by the courts

  • Advantage: courts/experts resolve the settlement and the firm has to pay the spill-over costs/compensation
  • Disadvantage: the damage is already done, and it focuses on rectification instead of prevention of the negative consequences; damages are often qualitative and are hard to measure
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

pollution permits

A

gov/eu sets the amount of acceptable pollution and grants each producer a permit to pollute
- Efficient firms can sell their permits to polluting firms
- The efficient firms gain revenue and profits, while the polluting firms face a loss due to the cost of the permit
- This provides an incentive for the polluting firms to become efficient by changing their behaviour in order to increase their profit/rev + gain competitive advantage IN THE LONG RUN
- No longer having to buy a permit and being seen as more socially responsible is profitable as they form a loyal customer base IN THE LONG RUN

  • Advantage: the market generates the solution and firms have time to adapt and change int he LONG RUN
  • Disadvantage: in the SHORT RUN, pollution levels do not actually change
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

legislation

A

New laws change individual and business behaviour, and failure to comply leads to a penalty
- The government decides to what extent externalities will be permitted and the appropriate penalty for non-compliance (drug trafficking is illegal and this is widespread in education)

Advantages
- Expected standards are clear
- Failure to comply has consequences
- The consequences are known

disadvantages
- The law may be difficult to enforce
- Enforcement can be expensive
- Penalties may not deter behaviour

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

indirect taxation

A

The gov can control some negative externalities by creating an incentive or disincentive that will change consumer or producer behaviour and reduce/elimnate some external costs
- Involves taxing over consumed products
- High indirect taxes on alchohol/tobacco etc raise their prices, discouraging consumption and reducing some of the negative externalities they produce (healthcare costs on the tax payer, affecting the quality of life)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

imposition of a tax

(how has supply shifted, what is tax, it depends?)

A

The imposition of a tax shifts the supply curve vertically upwards by the amount of the tax.
- This tax reflects the external cost caused by the production of the good
- This is hard to measure due to qualitative features of external costs

  • Price has increased from P1 to P2 and quantity demanded has fallen → contraction of demand

BUT the impact of higher prices on consumption will depend on its PRICE ELASTICITY OF DEMAND (inelastic = not that much of an effect)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

inelastic demand and tax

A
  • If ped = inelastic, Usually due to habit and addiction, so people will not change their habits
  • Need a good to be elastic for people to stop using
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

elastic demand and tax

A
  • Even if consumption decreases by a small bit the gov uses revenue from the tax to invest in healthcare, education, schemes to stop the demerit good being used (eg anti smoking)
  • This helps decrease consumption in another way, decrease addiction and make the good more ELASTIC
  • Demand curves are more ELASTIC at the beginning, and more INELASTIC at the bottom
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

road pricing and hypothecation

A
  • Advantage: A market solution is reached
  • Disadvantage: everyone has to pay the same charge, regardless of their income
  • The supply of roads is fixed → perfectly inelastic
    -The road is priced 0
  • For roads qd>qs, there is no equilibrium and excess demand → congestion
  • When an equilibrium is reached, the price can be determined as a congestion charge, to reduce road usage
  • It is designed to increase the price and make demand contract so there can be reasonable road use (£15 in london)

Road pricing is a form of HYPOTHECATION → creating a tax for one purpose and using it for another set purpose
- Congestion charge can be put towards funding for public transport (new buses are easy to create than trains etc) to further reduce road use

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

grants and subsidies

A
  • Subsidies can increase the consumption of under consumed goods (merit goods)
  • The gov tries to subsidise goods like solar panels, wind turbines and home insulation to make them cheaper and encourage consumer to buy them more
  • This reduces demand for non renewable energy, which carries negative externalities
  • Grants may be provided to help pay for activities that improve the quality of life (leisure centres)
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

voluntary agreements

A
  • The gov can try to persuade businesses within a specific industry to change the way they behave and adopt common codes of practice that reduce harmful externalities
  • Can be effective but not all businesses will sign up, especially if it includes extra costs and subsequent loss of price competitiveness
  • Can be successful if the industry deems voluntary agreements better than the possibility of stricter regulation being enforced
17
Q

other ways gov intervene

A

Education –> Consumer behaviour cna be brought about by direct education in schools or campaigns to raise awareness about issues

Free provision –> Many govs provide schemes to minimise negative externalites (rehab, free condoms, contraception etc)

Advertising –> Campaigns to stop harmful behvaiour (smoking, drink driving, safe sex) to reduce NEx

18
Q

what is government failure

A
  • occurs when governments try to deal with market failure but in doing so they create other problems
  • they worsen the problem or create a new one
19
Q

causes of government failure

A

Sometimes gov intervention causes a new and different inefficient allocation of resources, requiring further intervention

  1. Govs do not have enough information to make good decisions → solutions have unintended consequences that worsen the position
  2. Some govs decide on popular policies that have not been thought through → politics may trump efficient solutions
  3. Some gov departments and bodies responsible for policy implentation do not act fast enough or far enough to solve the worst problems
20
Q

how does gov failure occur

A
  1. price signal distortion
  2. unintended consequences
  3. excessive admin costs
21
Q

price signal distortion

A

Firms may see subsidies provided as an incentive to produce extra revenue, and are not actually efficient with providing the GS → increase in faulty GS

22
Q

unintended consequences

A

Hard to predict, even if an action had good consequences → higher wages for minimum wages = firms recruit less workers
- introduction of vaping to reduce smokers, but caused a vaping epidemic in the youth

23
Q

excessive admin costs

A

A problem when they involve monitoring compliance in a situation where many people are not committed to adhering to the regulatory framework
- If risk of being caught seems remote a firm will carry on with its harmful behaviour, causing negative externalities → will require testing and expensive legal action to solve

24
Q

gov failure in various markets

A
  • Lack of tax on popular goods (oil) which can be used on struggling state organisations (NHS)
  • UK needs new roads, railways and airports, but progress is slow
  • Young people and finding reasonably prices housing → ‘help to buy scheme’ 2014 increased demand further and prices increased too
  • Legislation can be introduced to solve these things, but they have not yet been introduced → GOV FAILURE
25
Q

3 examples of gov failure by causing unintended side effects

A

vapes
- gov advertised vape pens to solve cigarette addiction.
- However, due to information failure, people who did not smoke started using them (young people), leading to overconsumption

petrol vs diesel cars
- gov incentivised consumers to buy diesel cars as they had lower carbon emissions
- Sadiq khan found that diesel burned with particulates and children with asthma were dying in places where the air quality had deteriorated due to particulates
- now instead electric cars are being incentivised
- BUT: lithium batteries are a scarce resource, the national grid cannot deal with the electricity needed, and due to their quietness, they can cause more road accidents

targets for hospitals:
- labour policy to get people seen at A&E in under 4 hours as it was initially a slow process
- treatment became inefficient as there was a misallocation of resources so those with the most serious injuries may not be seen if others are running out of time

26
Q

gov failure when the impact can only be predicted

A
  • in the UK cannabis is totally banned, as the negative externalities are considered too great by the government
  • other countries: looked at the cost of the ban and decided it would be better if legalised –> better to put resources in other places in the country
27
Q

government failure with policies

A

introducing a sugar tax
- drinking artificial sweetners can lead to more health problems, and those who need sugary drinks for type 1 diabetes struggle
- low income households need to pay more aswell

policy to ensure that all children receive a free breakfast at school - coalition
- would lead to higher nutrition, more productivity, more concentration etc
- however some children already have a better breakfast at home, so they dont want this lower-quality breakfast at school
- to rectify they can try to improve the quality of the meal, and limit who can have this free breakfast to cut costs (most disadvantaged)