13 - Building Pathology - Masonry Flashcards
What are the causes of cracking in buildings?
- Drying shrinkage (sand-lime bricks, too strong rendering mixes)
- Thermal movement (lack of vertical movement joints)
- Water penetration and Frost action (freeze-thaw cycle)
- Ground movement (settlement, subsidence, heave)
- Wall tie failure
- Chemical reactions (carbonation, chloride attack, sulphate attack, ASR)
- Lack of lateral restraint (‘book-end’ effect)
- Overloading (roof spread, increase of internal imposed loads)
- Vibration (neighbouring works, earthquakes)
- Underpinning
Why is cracking a problem?
- Cause the building to be structurally unsafe
- Can lead to water penetration, leading to damp problems, which can exacerbate the cracking in some cases (frost action, carbonation, wall tie failure).
How do you monitor cracking and what are the procedures?
- Three studs/screws method - allows for the precise measurement of the sides of the triangle (ideally with a calliper or crack width gauge), indicating the extent and direction of the movement
- Proprietary calibrated tell-tale - measurement grid/scale is placed over the crack, however they are not always clear to read and are more easily affected by weather and vandals
- Glass tell-tale - placed over the crack and breaks if there is movement, therefore the least effective method, as it only indicates movement has happened, nothing else
- Specialised cameras - provides a precise and efficient means of tracking structural changes over time. These cameras can detect even the smallest of cracks, offering a high level of accuracy that is essential for effective monitoring.
- Crack monitoring discs: Provide a reference point for accurate measurements of concrete crack movements
- Crack width gauges: Can measure cracks up to 7 mm and work well in corners
Why should you monitor cracking?
- Regular monitoring helps ensure the safety and integrity of buildings, bridges, and other critical infrastructure.
- Even minor cracks can be indicative of significant structural issues that could compromise safety. Early detection through crack monitoring allows for timely maintenance and repairs, thereby preventing minor issues from escalating into major, costly problems.
Categorise the severity of cracking.
Category 1 and 2
- Less than 5mm
- Aesthetic problems only
- Unlikely to indicate a significant structural issue
Category 3 and 4
- Between 5mm and 25mm
- Cause serviceability issues (e.g. sticking doors, penetrating damp)
Category 5
- More than 25mm
- Require structural intervention
- BRE Digest 251, Table 1 gives 6 categories of cracks based on size
- Anything under 5mm (category 2) are not regarded as severe
What are the different types of cracking?
- Hairline cracks: Very thin cracks that are usually less than 1 mm wide. They are usually not a major concern, but should be monitored.
- Vertical cracks: Can be caused by normal settlement, but wider cracks at the top or bottom may indicate a serious foundation shift.
- Horizontal cracks: Can indicate severe structural stress, such as from soil pressure or improper construction.
- Diagonal cracks: Can be caused by differential settling of the foundation.
- Stair-step cracks: Can indicate significant foundation movement and are often serious.
What are the crack shapes and possible causes?
- Horizontal - repeated at regular intervals
- Corrosion of wall ties or other metals within the wall - Horizontal - Single horizontal joint - High level
- Roof spread; crack two or three causes below the eaves
- Wall tie corrosion
- Deterioration of the purlins within the roof or absence of diagonal bracing
- High wind vibration can cause roof movement; no holding down straps - Horizontal - Single horizontal joint - Above windows
- Concrete lintels
- Deterioration of brick slips set onto concrete lintels
- Timber bressumer failures behind a brick arch
- Collapse of a soldier arch
pg 181 Malcolm Ellis book.
What is subsidence?
Downward movement of a building foundation caused by loss of support beneath
What are the common causes of subsidence?
Usually associated with volumetric changes in the subsoil, possibly due to:
- Influence of trees on shrinkable (cohesive) soils
- Washing away of non-cohesive soils (e.g. leaking drains, burst water mains or underground streams)
- Change in ground-water levels (e.g. abstraction or land drainage)
- Mining
- Nearby excavations
How can trees cause subsidence?
Influence of trees on shrinkable (cohesive) soils:
- Trees and shrubs in close proximity to the building can cause the soil to become desiccated and lose its cohesion as a result of water being taken up through their roots
- Worse throughout periods of hot, dry weather (soils can become desiccated even without the presence of trees)
- As a tree grows it will extract increasingly more water from the ground, which can still cause desiccation even without hot weather
- Introducing new trees causes more water to be removed from the ground, thus heightening the problem
How can subsidence be rectified?
- Repair/alleviate the cause (e.g. repair/replace leaking drains, reduce height of trees)
- Consult with an arboriculturalist when removing/gradually reducing the height of trees is concerned
- Monitor the cracks and if no further movement occurs, repoint/patch/replace as necessary
- Where movement is excessive and on-going, underpinning may be required
- Where movement is slight and thought to be seasonal (usually where trees are concerned), it will be necessary to monitor the movement
Who usually pays for damage caused by subsidence?
Most insurance policies cover the cost of repairing the loss and damage caused by ground movement, but not necessarily the cost of preventing further movement
(relevant in NZ?)
What is heave?
Upward movement of a building foundation caused by the expansion or swelling of the subsoil
What are the common causes of heave?
- The removal of trees on shrinkable (cohesive) soils
- The freezing of ground water in frost-susceptible soils
How can trees cause heave?
- The ground slowly regains moisture that was once taken up by the tree roots
- Can last up to 10 years so care is needed when building on sites soon after trees have been removed
How can freezing ground water cause heave?
- After a period of high rainfall, water fills the voids between the particles and in freezing weather expands as it turns to ice
- Additional damage can be caused when the ice thaws and the ground settles
- Worse if ground has a high water table
What are the issues that trees can have on buildings?
- Foundation damage - from roots
- Subsidence - roots extract moisture from the soil
- Blocked drains and pipes - roots
- Roof damage - falling branches
- Pest infestations - harbor pests that move into building.
What are the problems with the removal of trees?
- Heave - ground can swell
- Subsidence
What are the problems of planting a tree near a building?
- Ground movement - Downward movement - Tree roots can exacerbate soil shrinkage and ground movement, which can cause foundation settlement.
- Tree roots can grow into foundations
What is the difference between settlement and subsidence?
Settlement is applied to the failure of the components of the building.
Subsidence is used where the building is damaged by a failure in the ground.
What is settlement?
- Natural compaction of soil due to the load imposed by the building
- Happens in all buildings and occurs soon after construction
- Only problematic if it is differential (i.e. happens in different parts at different times, perhaps due to variations in ground conditions or using old/different foundation depths)
Explain the process of diagnosing ground movement cracking.
- Inspect the cracks - location, size, direction, age
- Investigate the site - ground profile, soil type, tree proximity, drains testing, mining area
- Determine the cause of the cracks from steps 1 and 2
- Begin remedial action - alleviate cause, provide underpinning if necessary
- Monitor cracks - minimum 18 months
- Assess action for trees (if necessary) with an arboriculturalist
What features of a crack may indicate that it has been caused by ground movement?
- Extends above and below the DPC
- Affects both internal and external surfaces
- Diagonal in direction (stepped along brickwork)
- Tapered
How does the width of a crack help determine which type of ground movement has caused it?
- Heave - cracks are wider at the top and narrower at the bottom (both the cracks themselves and their location on the building)
- Subsidence - cracks are narrower at the top and wider at the bottom (both the cracks themselves and their location on the building)
- Local subsidence - cracks are wider at the top and narrower at the bottom