13 - Building Pathology - Concrete Flashcards
What three mechanisms cause concrete to deteriorate?
- Chemical mechanisms - carbonation, chloride contamination, alkali-aggregate reaction and sulphate attack.
- Physical mechanisms
- Environmental - freeze-thaw cycles, weathering and salt crystallization
-Physical - structural loading, abrasion, impact damage, shrinkage, and expansion. - Biological mechanisms - invasive plants and micro-organisms on the concrete surface
The most serious forms of deterioration are those that ultimately lead to the corrosion of the steel reinforcement. The reinforcement not only supplies crucial tensile strength that diminishes with corrosion, but as it corrodes also forms highly expansive products, which can cause the surrounding concrete to crack and, eventually, break off.
What are common defects in concrete buildings?
- High alumina cement
- Spalling
- Carbonation
- Suphate attack
- Alkali silica reaction
- Chloride attack
What is concrete spalling and how does it occur?
- Where the surface of the concrete begins to flake and peel away. This can be due to chemical reactions, natural weathering, or natural aging. It indicates a severe weakness in some parts or the entire structure.
- Spalling occurs when water penetrates the pores of the concrete and expands upon freezing, causing cracks that grow vertically and horizontally along their length. These cracks continue to grow, become unstable, and crumble away from each other due to thermal expansion forces.
How do you repair spalling in concrete?
- Install a new overlay on your concrete.
- Use a color-matching compound to patch the spalled area.
- Remove and replace the whole slab.
What are cracks in concrete and how do they occur?
- Is a whole or partial split of concrete into two or more portions caused by fracturing or breaking.
- Structural cracks caused by movement in the structure.
- Shrinkage cracks caused by water evaporating from the concrete mixture
- Concrete tends to shrink as it dries, allowing moisture to accumulate inside and causing the material’s surface to crack. It can also be caused by frost heave, improper mixing, humidity changes, poor quality concrete, or high water content.
- The cracks can be small or large depending on the amount of moisture present at the time.
How do you repair cracks in concrete?
- If the cracks are small, fill them with masonry cement.
- If the cracks are extreme, remove and replace the concrete.
- If you don’t like the appearance of the repairs, go for concrete resurfacing.
What is concrete efflorescence and how does it occur?
- Concrete efflorescence is the whitish powdery deposition that coats unfinished concrete surfaces. It’s salt that has been deposited on the surface of the concrete.
- Efflorescence occurs when vapor, carrying soluble salts, comes into contact with concrete. When the water evaporates, it leaves behind a white, powdery deposit. This defect occurs for several reasons, including poorly sealed or cured concrete, low temperatures, condensation, cracks or voids in concrete, use of salty water during concrete construction and deicing salt on concrete surfaces, and excessive humidity.
How do you repair concrete efflorescence?
- Apply pressurized water to dissolve efflorescence.
- Brush using a stiff bristle broom or brush.
- Use a mild acid rinse.
What is carbonation and how is it caused?
- Carbonation is the process by which carbon dioxide slowly penetrates concrete and dissolves in water present within its pores, forming a mildly carbolic acidic solution
- This acidic solution reacts with the alkaline calcium hydroxide (one of the components of concrete) to form calcium carbonate
- This results in a pH drop, reducing the alkalinity of the concrete (from more than 12.5 to approximately 8.5)
- This carbonation process progressively moves through the concrete over time
What problems are associated with carbonation?
- Corrosion
- Micro cracks and shrinkage
- The passive layer around reinforcing steel will deteriorate when the pH falls below 10.5
- Therefore, once carbonation reaches any steel, the concrete is insufficiently alkaline to protect the steel’s passive layer and thus becomes ‘active’ (aka depassivation)
- Moisture and oxygen ingressing through the porous concrete can now react with the steel, which may begin to rust and corrode
- If this happens, the steel will expand, which can cause cracking and spalling of the concrete cover, thus compromising its structural integrity
- This also makes it easier for aggressive agents to ingress towards the steel, thus further increasing the rate of corrosion
What factors affect the rate of carbonation?
- Quality and density of the concrete - good quality, well compacted concrete will carbonate at a much slower rate
- Exposure of the building to water and carbon dioxide (permanently wet conditions hinder penetration so carbonation will be low)
- Relative humidity of the atmosphere - carbonation is encouraged where RH is between 25-75% (optimum at 50-75%; anything over 75% usually hinders the rate of carbonation as the excess moisture slows the rate of carbon dioxide entry)
- Temperature - warmer temperatures increase the rate of carbonation (subject to RH)
Is the rate of carbonation greater internally or externally? Why?
The rate of carbonation is usually greater internally due to the higher relative humidity and temperature
Is carbonation more likely to cause corrosion in internal or external concrete? Why?
External concrete, due to the increased presence of moisture and oxygen that can penetrate the carbonated concrete
Under what circumstances is the risk of corrosion through carbonation particularly high?
If poor compaction and strength (perhaps caused by a too high water/cement ratio) is coupled with reinforcement with little cover
How would you identify carbonation?
Visual Appearance:
- Longitudinal cracking along the line of any steel reinforcement (hairline cracking can occur as early as a few months after construction)
- Brown stains as a result of the rusting steel
- Over time, the expansion of rusting steel will result in further cracking and spalling of the surface concrete
Chemical Testing:
- Used to determine depth of carbonation
- Phenolphthalein solution is sprayed onto a fresh sample of the concrete
- Non-carbonated areas will turn pink/purple (alkaline), whereas carbonated areas will remain colourless (neutral pH value due to reduced alkalinity)
- The depth of penetration can then be measured
How can carbonation be addressed?
(Repair/treatment)
Firstly consider the likely rate of ongoing deterioration and the required life of the structure to assess the cost effectiveness of different protection and repair strategies
Options:
- Patch Repair
- Re-alkalisation by Diffusion
- Electrochemical Re-alkalisation
- Increase Resistivity
What is the process of patch repairing carbonated concrete?
- Clean surface
- Remove loose concrete
- Remove corrosion (e.g. grit blasting)
- Prime the reinforcement with alkali-based solution
- Reinstate concrete cover using patch repair mortar, sprayed concrete or conventional concrete (for large areas only)
What is the process of remediating carbonated concrete through re-alkalisation by diffusion?
- For concrete that has only suffered minor carbonation
- A thickness of fresh alkaline concrete is applied to the surface of the concrete
- Migration of alkalis from the fresh to the original concrete will allow for gradual re-alkalisation
- Not advisable to rely on this method alone if the average depth of carbonation exceeds 10mm, as moisture from the fresh concrete can ingress and increase the rate of steel corrosion
What is the process of remediating carbonated concrete through electrochemical re-alkalisation?
- A temporary anode mesh is fitted close to the surface of the concrete and is electrically connected to the steel reinforcement (cathode) and a power supply
- An electrolyte (usually a sprayed cellulose fibre) is applied around the anode mesh
- The steel cathode then attracts alkali metal ions towards it, so high alkalinity is restored around the steel
- Process takes approximately 3-10 days
How can you increase the resistivity of carbonated concrete?
- Surface coatings - designed to restrict the penetration of carbon dioxide (must still allow the concrete to dry out)
- Hydrophobic impregnants - designed to repel water
- Sheltering the concrete component - e.g. ventilated external cladding
What is chloride attack?
Chloride attack is the process by which chloride ions are introduced into concrete, which reduces its alkalinity.
Corrosion takes place as the chloride ions meet with the steel and the surrounding passive material to produce a chemical process which forms hydrochloric acid. The hydrochloric acid eats away at the steel reinforcement and thus leads to concrete cracking, spalling, and eventually failure.
What are the three main sources of chlorides?
- De-icing salts
- Marine environment
- Intrusive chlorides
What are two types of intrusive chlorides?
- Calcium chloride admixture (accelerator)
- Contaminated constituents eg marine aggregates
How can chloride ions be introduced into concrete?
- Introduced as an accelerator during the mixing process (calcium chloride)
- Introduced naturally (e.g. from the use of unwashed marine aggregates)
- Introduced as a result of external contamination (e.g. de-icing salt, exposure to salt spray etc.)
When was it common to introduce chloride ions into concrete as an accelerator?
- Prevalent in the 1950s and 1960s - good for concreting in cold weather as the concrete or mortar would harden quickly, thus developing early resistance to freezing and thawing
- Common until around 1978
What method of introducing chloride ions into concrete can cause the most damage?
External contamination as the concentration can be more erratic and the ions are not chemically bound