09. Criminal Procedure Flashcards
What type of actions do constitutional protections apply to?
Government action
When may constitutional protections apply if the actor is NOT the government?
1) Agents = Private persons acting as government agents
2) Defense = Defense counsel (both public and private) are treated as government actors for purposes of the 6the Amendment with respect to effective assistance of counsel
What is a seizure?
Occurs when an officer, by means of physical contact or show of authority, intentionally terminates or retrains the person’s freedom of movement
What is the test for whether something is a seizure?
Whether a reasonable person would feel free to disregard the officer and leave
What are the types of seizures?
1) Terry Stop and Frisk
2) Traffic Stops
3) Arrests
What is a Terry Stop?
An officer stops and individual when the officer has a reasonable suspicion, based on articulable facts, to believe the suspect is or is about to be engaged in criminal behavior
What are the types of suspicion?
1) Beyond a Reasonable Doubt
2) Probable Cause
3) Reasonable Suspicion
What type of suspicion is needed for a conviction?
Beyond a reasonable doubt
What does it mean if suspicion is beyond a reasonable doubt?
A firm believe in defendant’s guilt
What type of suspicion is needed for an arrest?
Probable cause
What does it mean if suspicion is probable cause?
“More likely than not” = reasonable belief crime was committed OR evidence will be found
What type of suspicion is needed for a Terry Stop?
Reasonable suspicion
What happens if an officer is mistaken in their reasonable suspicion?
An officer’s reasonable mistake of law can give rise to reasonable suspicion
What may an officer physically do during a Terry Stop?
Pat down a detainee for weapons
What may an officer NOT physically do during a Terry Stop?
Pat down a detainee for evidence UNLESS the shape of the object makes its identity obvious contraband (at which point the officers may seize the item)
What happens if an officer develops probable cause during a Terry Stop?
The officer can make an arrest
What happens if a Terry Stop is NOT based on adequate suspicion?
- If the initial stop is unlawful BUT the officer develops the basis for a lawful arrest during the stop, then evidence seized can be used at trial
- If the initial stop is unlawful AND no basis develops to make a lawful arrest, then evidence seized during the arrest cannot be used at trial
What level of suspicion is needed to stop a car?
Reasonable suspicion
When does an officer NOT need reasonable suspicion to stop a car?
At checkpoints where everyone is being stopped
What may an officer do following a lawful traffic stop?
Once there is a lawful stop, officers may pat down an occupant for weapons IF they have reasonable suspicion that the person has a weapon
What is needed to make an arrest?
There must be probable cause (objective) to believe that the arrested individual has committed a crime
Is a warrant needed for an arrest?
No; arrests may be made with or without a warrant
What is a pretext arrest?
As long as the police have PC to believe an individual committed a crime, it is irrelevant whether the officer stopped that person for the crime for which there is PC or for some other crime
NOTE: Fine under 4A, but may be issues under EPC if the officers choose who to stop based on race or other discriminatory criteria
What is a warrant?
Authorizes an officer to arrest a particular person
What is required for a warrant to be valid?
1) Neutral = Be issued by a neutral and detached magistrate
2) PC = Be based on a finding of probable cause to believe that the named individual has committed a particular crime
3) Identify = Name the person and identify the offense
What does it mean once a warrant is issued?
- Allows officers to enter an individual’s home to arrest that individual
- Does NOT authorize officers to enter a third party’s home or business
NOTE: Must also have a search warrant to search the premises for the individual or meet an exception to the warrant requirement
When can officers arrest someone inside a dwelling if they do NOT have an arrest warrant?
1) There are exigent circumstances
2) There is consent to enter
When may an officer make a warrantless arrest?
An officer can arrest an individual without a warrant in a public place, either for a crime committed in the officer’s presence OR based on probable cause to believe the individual committed a felony
If a crime was NOT committed in the officer’s presence, what is required to make a warrantless arrest?
The crime committed was a felony (+ PC)
What happens if there is an unlawful or illegal arrest (e.g., no probable cause)?
While this does not stop prosecution for the crime, is might result in the exclusion of evidence discovered during the arrest
What is SILA?
A lawful arrest permits the arresting officers to make a contemporaneous search of the person arrested and the immediate surrounding area to:
1) Protect officers from weapons or other danger; AND
2) Prevent the destruction or concealment of evidence
T or F: Any evidence discovered an seized during a SILA search can be used against the person arrested
True
What is the area that may be subject to SILA for an arrest on the street?
Suspect + suspect’s wingspan
What is the area that may be subject to SILA for an arrest at home?
Suspect + immediate arrest area
What is the area that may be subject to SILA for an arrest in a car?
Passenger compartment of a vehicle as long as the person/suspect still has access to the vehicle at the time