03. Real Property Flashcards
What are the ways property can be transferred?
1) Sale
2) Gift
3) Divise (will; effective when decedent dies)
4) Intestate succession
What is another word for “transferred” in property?
Alienated
How are ownership interests divided in real property?
In time between present interests and future interests
What is the key distinction in the division of ownership interest of real property?
The timing of possession (e.g., who has the right to possess it NOW?)
T or F: Someone must be in possession of property at all times
True
What is the largest possessory estate?
Fee Simple (or Fee Simple Absolute)
What does the “absolute” mean in “Fee Simple Absolute”?
It means that nothing stops the fee simple estate from continuing or passing on
Why is a fee simple estate considered the largest possessory estate?
Because it is capable of lasting forever
What does it mean for something to be inheritable?
Upon the owner’s death, the owner can pass it by will or be intestate succession; can also be transferred by gift or sale during owner’s life.
What are the “magic words” to create a fee simple estate?
“and his/her heirs” (but this is not required, can just be “O to A”)
What happens if a grant of real property is ambiguous?
Ig a grant is ambiguous, it creates a fee simple
What is the default estate?
Fee simple absolute
Why is fee simple absolute the default estate?
There is a presumption that the grantor conveys the most that she has
What effect do precatory words (e.g., “my hope and wish”, words of intent or purpose) have on a conveyange?
No effect - if the grantor wishes to make a conveyance, they have the explicitly say it or it won’t count
T or F: There is a future interest associated with a fee simple estate
False: Because a fee simple estate is capable of lasting forever (e.g., the big wheel of cheese hasn’t been sliced, diced, or bitten), there is no future interest. If you see something like “O to A, then to B when A dies”, then A got a life estate, not a fee simple.
What are defeasible fees?
Interests that may be terminated by the occurrence of an event (but still capable of lasting forever if the event doesn’t happen); in other words, a condition will cut the fee simple short
What is a fee simple determinable?
Limited by specific durational language
What are examples of durational language that trigger a fee simple determinable?
1) “So long as”
2) “While”
3) “During”
What is a fee simple subject to condition subsequent?
Limited by specific conditional language
What are examples of conditional language that trigger a fee simple subject to condition subsequent?
1) “But if”
2) “Provided that”
3) “On the condition that”
What is the future interest associated with a fee simple determinable?
Possibility of Reverter
What is a Possibility of Reverter?
A future interest held by a grantor following a fee simple determinable that invests automatically after the durational period ends
What is the future interest associated with a fee simple subject to condition subsequent?
Right of Entry
What is a Right of Entry?
A future interest held by the grantor following a fee simple subject to condition subsequent that does NOT vest automatically, but must be reclaimed through a specific action by the grantor
What is a fee simple subject to executory interest?
Will end upon the happening of an event and the future interest will vest in a third party (NOT the grantor)
What is the difference between a fee simple subject to condition subsequent and a fee simple subject to executory interest?
FSSCS –> future interest = grantor
FSSEI –> future interest = third party
What is an executory interest?
A future interest that will cut short or terminate an earlier interest (NOT THE GRANTOR)
What is another term for terminating a prior interest
Divest
What is a life estate?
A present estate that is limited by life
What words are used to create a life estate?
“For Life” (doesn’t have to be the grantor’s life)
NOTE: If ambiguous, look for the grantor’s intent to create an estate that will end upon the death of the measuring life (i.e., To A to live in your house; you can only live in a house while alive, so probably a life estate)
When does a life estate terminate?
Ends naturally when the measuring life ends
Is a life estate transferable?
Yes!
T or F: A life tenant (measured by the tenant’s life) can pass the property by will
False: the life estate ends at the life tenant’s death
What is a reversion?
When possession of the land goes back to the grantor after the life estate ends
What is a remainder?
When possession of the land goes to a third party after the life estate ends
What is the difference between a reversion and a remainder?
Reversion –> possession goes back to grantor
Remainder –> possession goes to third party
What is common between a reversion and a remainder?
1) Both follow a life estate
2) Both result in a fee simple
What is waste in terms of real property?
Comes into play when more than one party has an interest in the same piece of real property, and a present interest holder’s actions are impacting the future interest’s value.
What are the types of waste?
1) Affirmative
2) Permissive
3) Ameliorative
What is affirmative waste?
Waste caused by voluntary conduct, which causes a decrease in value
Ex: dumping hazardous waste
What is permissive waste?
Waste caused by neglect toward the property, which causes a decrease in value
Ex: not cleaning up after a natural disaster
What is ameliorative waste?
Special situation where a life tenant or other person in possession changes the use of the property and actually increases the value of the property
Ex: Renovation of a house, construction of a dam, fixing a fence
In what situations does the doctrine of waste usually apply?
1) Landlord v. Tenant
2) Co-tenant out of possession v. tenant in possession (concurrent estates)
3) Mortgagee (bank/lender) v. mortgagor (borrower)
How to spot a waste problem on the bar
1) Do multiple parties have simultaneous interests? (e.g., life tenant, remainder, future interests, landlord v. tenant)
2) Is there a change in the value of the property due to the actions/inactions of the party in possession?
3) Will the waste substantially change the interest taken by the party out of possession? (Do I stop or encourage the waste?)
T or F: A remainder cannot follow a vested fee simple
True: (Remainders are Patient) A future interest following a vested fee simple would have to divest the prior interest, but a remainder does not function that way because it instead waits for the prior interest to end
What are the two categories of remainders?
1) Vested
2) Contingent
T or F: RAP generally applies only to vested remainders
False: RAP generally applies only to contingent remainders
What are the two requirements for vested remainders?
1) Given to an ascertained grantee
2) Not subject to a condition precedent
What happens if the remainder is either not to an ascertainable grantee or subject to a condition precedent?
Then it is a contingent remainder
What happens if the holder of a vested remainder dies?
The interest passes to the holder’s heirs
What happens if a contingent remainder does not vest before it becomes possessory?
The grantor has a reversion
What is a vested remainder subject to open?
1) Vested remainder in a class gift; AND
2) Full class membership is unknown
What happens if no one in the class has vested?
The remainder is contingent, NOT vested subject to open
What happens when all members of a class are identified?
The class is closed
When is it presumed people may have children in property law?
From the time their born until the time they die
T or F: RAP applies to a vested remainder subject to open
True
What is the Rule of Convenience?
A class-closing mechanism to avoid application of RAP to a class gift
How is the Rule of Convenience applied?
If the grant does not have an express closing date, the Rule of Convenience closes the class when any member of the class becomes entitled to immediate possession.
What is the Doctrine of Worthier Title?
Prevents against reminders in a grantor’s heirs & creates a presumption of a reversion to the grantor
Ex: Changes “to Anna for life, then to my heirs” into a reversion in O with a life estate for Anna
What is the Rule in Shelley’s Case?
Prevents against reminders in a grantee’s heirs & uses the doctrine of merger to create a fee simple
Ex: Changes “to Anna for life, then to Anna’s heirs” to “to Anna”, so Anna has FSA
T or F: Executory interests are not subject to RAP
False
What is an executor interest?
Future interest that cuts short (i.e., divests) a prior vested interest
(“He’s a jerk!”)
What are the two types of executory interest?
1) Springing
2) Shifting
What is a springing executory interest?
Divests the grantor
What is a shifting executory interest?
Divests a prior grantee
Exam tip for executory interests - count the parties
1) 2 parties –> likely springing
2) 3 parties –> likely shifting
What does RAP prevent?
Remote vesting
What is RAP testing for?
Certainty (operates like a statute of limitations for contingent future interests)
What is the time period for RAP?
A life + 21 years (approximately 2 generations)
When are the two times interests can be created?
1) Inter vivos transfers = interests created at time of the grant
2) Devise (will) = interests created at testator’s death (NOT when the will is drafted)
Which interests does RAP apply to?
1) Contingent remainders
2) Executory interests
3) Class gifts (vested remainders subject to open) if NOT closed by rule of convenience
What is a relevant life (RAP)?
Person who affects vesting, usually mentioned or implied by the grant
Ex: prior life tenant, the parent where a conveyance is made to a child
What is a validating life (RAP)?
Person who tells us whether or not the interest vests within the perpetuities period (lifetime + 21 years)
What are the requirements for a validating life?
1) Must have been alive when the interests were created
2) Can validate own interest
3) If no validating life, then interest is NO GOOD and we strike it from the grant; if there is a validating life, the interest is GOOD
If a portion of a transfer is found to violate the Rule Against Perpetuities, how will courts treat the transfer?
The portion of the transfer that violates the rule is void, and the rest is valid.
T or F: If the gift to any member of the class is void under RAP, then the gift is void as to all members of the class
True: The gift is all or nothing
What are the exceptions to the “all or nothing” Class Gift rule?
1) Transfers of a specific dollar amount to each class member
2) Transfers to a sub-class that vests at a specific time
What are the exceptions to RAP?
1) Charities: RAP does not apply to a gift from one charity to another charity
2) Options: RAP does not apply to an option held by a current tenant to purchase a fee interest in the leasehold property OR to an option (or right of first refusal) in a commercial transaction
What is the modern RAP approach?
“Wait and See”: Rather than invalidating transfers from the outset under RAP, you wait and see if an interest subject to RAP vests within the perpetuities period (some states have changed the vesting period to 90 years)
What is cy pres?
An equitable doctrine (borrowed from the law of trusts) that allows a court to reform a transfer to avoid RAP
What are concurrent estates?
Ownership or possession of real property by two or more persons simultaneously
What is the basic rule of concurrent estates?
Concurrent owners each have right to use or possess the whole of the property
Exception = concurrent owners can contract out of the basic rule
What are the types of concurrent estates?
1) Tenancy in common
2) Joint tenancy
3) Tenancy by the entirety
What is tenancy in common?
Concurrent owners have separate but undivided interests in the property with NO right of survivorship.
Default Rule: Any conveyance to more than one person is presumed to be a tenancy in common
What is the default concurrent estate?
A tenancy in common
What does it mean if a concurrent estate has no right of survivorship?
Each co-tenant can transfer the property freely at death as well as during life
What type of concurrent estate generally will not have a right of survivorship?
Tenancy in common
What is the defining characteristic of a joint tenancy?
The right of survivorship, whereby the surviving joint tenant(s) automatically take the deceased tenant’s interest
Oliver conveys Blackacre “to Anna and Ben as joint tenants with a right of survivorship.” Anna dies in a tragic hunting accident. Anna’s will leaves everything to her daughter Amy. Who owns Blackacre?
Ben, who takes under the right of survivorship (which trumps Anna’s will).
How do you create a joint tenancy?
1) Grantor must make a clear expression of intent; PLUS
2) Must be survivorship language
Ex: “as joint tenants with a right of survivorship”
What is needed to create a joint tenancy?
The four unities
What are the four unities?
PITT or T-TIP
1) P: Possession = Every join tenant has an equal right to possess the whole of the property
2) I: Interest = Joint tenants must have an equal share of the same type of interest
3) T: Time = Joint tenants must receive their interests at the same time
4) T: Title = Joint tenants must receive their interests in the same instrument of title
What happens if one of the unities is lost?
The joint tenancy is severed and becomes a tenancy in common
T or F: Transfer during life of a joint tenancy will not sever the right of survivorship
False: the transfer will sever/destroy the right of survivorship and convert the estate into a tenancy in common
What happens if only one of more than two joint tenants conveys their interest in an inter vivos transfer?
This does NOT destroy the joint tenancy of the remaining joint tenants.
What happens if a tenant of a joint tenancy has a lien and then dies?
Any lien against a joint tenant’s interest terminates upon that tenant’s death, so the surviving tenants’ interests are not encumbered
A joint tenant grants a mortgage interest in the joint tenancy to a creditor. Does the mortgage sever the joint tenancy?
Majority = Lien Theory –> mortgage treated like a lien and does NOT destroy joint tenancy
Minority = Title Theory –> mortgage severs title and the tenancy between the joint tenants and the creditor is converted into a tenancy in common
A joint tenant leases her share in the property to a tenant. Does the lease sever the joint tenancy?
Jurisdictions are split!
- Some jurisdictions hold that the lease severs the joint tenancy
- Other jurisdictions treat the lease as a temporary suspension of the joint tenancy
What is a tenancy by the entirety?
A joint tenancy between spouses
A joint tenancy with a 5th unity of marriage
T or F: Tenants by the entirety cannot alienate or encumber their shares without the consent of their spouse
True
How do you convey a tenancy by the entirety?
Property conveyed “as tenants by the entirety, with a right of survivorship”
What happens if a grant of tenancy by the entirety is ambiguous?
Courts presume property is held as joint tenants or as tenants in common
What is the general rule for possession and use of concurrent owners?
Each co-tenant has right to possess all of the property, regardless of that co-tenant’s share and regardless of the type of co-tenancy.
Does one co-tenant owe the other a duty to pay rent?
No, a co-tenant in possession is not require to pay rent to co-tenants out of possession
What is an ouster?
Co-tenant in possession denies another co-tenant access to the property
What must a party show to claim ouster?
You must manifest an intent to possess the property and be denied access (e.g., one tenant changes the locks or throws out the co-tenant’s stuff)
What are remedies for the ousted tenant?
1) Get an injunction granting access to the property; and/or
2) Recover damages for the value of the use while the co-tenant was unable to access the property
How is rent divided among concurrent owners?
Rent received from a third party’s possession of the property, minus operating expenses, are divided based on ownership interests on each co-tenant
Anna and Ben own Blackacre as tenants in common. Anna has a 10% interest and Ben has a 90% interest in Blackacre. Carmen is renting Blackacre for $1,000 a month. How much is Anna and Ben each entitled to?
Anna = $100 (10% of $1,000)
Ben = $900 (90% of $1,000)
What are operating expenses?
Necessary charges, such as taxes or mortgage payments
How are operating expenses divided between co-owners?
Based on ownership interest of each co-tenant
What happens if a co-tenant pays more of her share of the operating expenses?
A co-tenant can collect contributions from the other co-tenants for payments in excess of her share of the operating expenses
What happens if a co-tenant pays for necessary repairs?
There is no right to reimbursement from co-tenants for necessary repairs, but they can get credit in partition action.
What happens if a co-tenant pays for improvements?
There is no right to reimbursement from co-tenants for improvements, but they can get credit in partition action.
What is a partition?
An equitable remedy available to all holders of tenancy in common or joint tenancy (unilateral right) to divide the property into distinct portions.
NOTE: This is NOT available for tenants by the entirety
What are the two types of partitions?
1) Partition in kind (physical division)
2) Partition by sale
What type of partition is preferred by the court?
Partition in kind
When will a court order a partition by sale?
If the physical partition is:
1) Not practical (e.g., land has complicated terrain); OR
2) Not fair to all parties
How are proceeds from a partition by sale divided?
Proceeds from a partition by sale are divided among the co-tenants based on their ownership interests.
Anna and Ben own a condo unit as tenants in common, each with a 50% share in the property. Anna sues for partition. What kind of partition will the court order?
A partition by sale, because a physical partition is not feasible.
Can co-tenants agree not to partition?
Yes; such agreements are enforceable, as long as they are:
1) clear; and
2) the time limitation is reasonable
What does the FHA do?
The Fair Housing Act (FHA) prohibits discrimination in the:
1) Sale;
2) Rental; AND
3) Financing
of dwellings (homes, apartments, etc.)
It also prohibits advertising that states a discriminatory preference
Who is the primary focus of the FHA?
Multi-family residential housing
What are the 3 exemptions from the FHA?
1) Single-family housing that is sold or rented without a broker
2) Owner-occupied buildings with 4 or fewer living units
3) Religious organizations and private clubs
What are the protected traits under the FHA?
1) Race
2) Color
3) Religion
4) National Origin
5) Sex (includes orientation & gender identity)
6) Disability
7) Familial Status (families w/ children under 18 or someone pregnant)
When may a landlord treat someone differently under the FHA?
When providing reasonable accommodations for persons with disabilities (e.g., ramp, elevator, etc).
What is prohibited under the FHA?
Based on a protected trait:
1) Refusing to rent, sell, or finance a dwelling;
2) Requiring different rents;
3) Falsely denying that a unit is available;
4) Providing different services to facilities; OR
5) Stating a discriminatory preference in an advertisement
What intent is allowed in FHA cases?
1) Disparate Treatment (intent)
2) Disparate Impact (effect)
What must be shown in an FHA case?
That the prohibited behavior is linked to the protected trait (causal nexus)
What is the default controlling law in property?
Law of the Situs = controlling law is based on where the property is located
When does law of the situs not control?
1) If the instrument in question designates an applicable jurisdiction
2) Marriage: the domicile of the party may override, specifically with respect to classifying property as marital or separate
3) Mortgage: mortgage documents require repayment to be made in another state
What types of interests are created by a lease?
1) Contract
2) Property
What are the 4 tenancies that govern the landlord-tenant relationship?
1) Tenancy for years
2) Periodic tenancy
3) Tenancy at will
4) Tenancy at sufferance
What is a tenancy for years?
Measured by a fixed and ascertainable amount of time (doesn’t have to be in years)
What is required to create a tenancy for years?
1) An agreement by the landlord and the tenant (purpose = demonstrate the intent to create a leasehold)
2) IF longer than 1 year, then the agreement must be signed and in writing (Statute of Frauds)
How is a tenancy for years terminated?
1) At the end of the term = automatic (no notice needed)
2) Before the end of the term = tenant surrenders the lease OR the tenant or landlord commits a material breach
What is a periodic tenancy?
Estate that is repetitive and ongoing for a set period of time (e.g., month-to-month, year-to-year) that renews automatically at the end of each period until one party gives proper notice of termination
What is required to create a periodic tenancy?
Parties must intent to create a periodic tenancy, which can be express (e.g., a signed lease) or implied (e.g., payment of rent)
How is a periodic tenancy terminated?
- Renews automatically until proper notice is given
- OLD: in a year-to-year, need at least 6 month notice
- NEW: most states lowered to month’s notice
- Proper Notice = terminating party gives notice before the start of what will be the last term
- Most jurisdictions require written notice of termination
- Notice is effective on the last day of the period
What is a tenancy at will?
May be terminated by either landlord or tenant at any time, for any reason
What is required to create a tenancy at will created?
Can be created by express agreement or by implication
How is a tenancy at will terminated?
Can be terminated by either party without notice
- If the agreement gives only the landlord the right to terminate at will, the tenant also gets the right to terminate by implication
- If the agreement gives only the tenant the right to terminate at will, the landlord is NOT given the right to terminate at will
- If the landlord or tenant dies, the tenancy at will terminates (NOT true for tenancy for years or periodic tenancy)
What is a tenancy at sufferance?
- Created when a tenant holds over after the lease has ended
- A temporary tenancy that exists before the landlord either:
1) evicts the prior tenant OR
2) re-rents the property to the tenant (creates a new tenancy with the holdover tenant) - Tenant owes the landlord reasonable value of the daily use, as well as reasonably foreseeable special damages
What is required to create a tenancy at sufferance?
Created by actions of the tenant alone
What is the difference between a tenancy at will and a tenancy at sufferance?
- Tenancy at will: Created by agreement of the landlord and tenant (meeting of the minds)
- Tenancy at sufferance: Created by actions of the tenant alone
How is a tenancy at sufferance terminated?
1) Tenant voluntarily leaves;
2) Landlord evicts tenant; OR
3) Landlord re-rents to the tenant