06. Civil Procedure Flashcards
What is the home-court-advantage rule?
A rule that prohibits removal from state to federal court when:
1) The federal court’s SMJ arises from diversity jurisdiction; AND
2) A defendant is a citizen of the state where the case was filed
When is the defense of lack of personal jurisdiction waived?
When it is not asserted in a pre-answer motion or an answer, whichever occurs first
When does specific jurisdiction exist?
1) The plaintiff’s claim arises from the defendant’s minimum contacts with the forum state; AND
2) The exercise of jurisdiction would comply with notions of fair play and substantial justice
How is personal jurisdiction established?
1) General jurisdiction
2) Specific jurisdiction
For federal question jurisdiction, where is venue proper?
Venue is proper in any federal district where:
1) Any defendant resides, as long as all defendants reside in the same sate;
2) A substantial part of the events occurred or a substantial part of the property at issue is located; OR
3) Any defendant is subject to the court’s personal jurisdiction (if the first 2 don’t apply)
What items must an answer include?
1) Admissions and denials
2) Motions that have not been waived
3) Affirmative defenses
4) Compulsory counterclaims
What happens if a required item is not included in an answer?
The items not included are waived
What must the court do when considering a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim?
1) Treat all well-pleaded facts in the complaint as true; AND
2) View the evidence and draw all reasonable inferences in the light most favorable to the nonmovant
When may a federal court exercise supplemental jurisdiction over claims that fall outside of its original SMJ?
When those claims share a common nucleus of operative facts with a claim that falls within its original SMJ
When should summary judgement be granted?
When the movant shows that:
1) There is no genuine dispute as to any material fact; AND
2) The movant is entitled to judgement as a matter of law
What is required for a jury verdict?
1) Verdict must be unanimous
2) Verdict must be returned by at least 6 jurors (but no more than 12)
When may the traditional requirements for a jury verdict be altered?
When the parties stipulate to any changes (i.e., not requiring unanimous verdict)
What is collateral estoppel?
Issue preclusion = precludes the relitigation of an issue that was actually litigated, determined, and essential to a valid final judgement on the merits
What is mutual collateral estoppel?
Parties from first action assert collateral estoppel in subsequent action against other parties from first action
What is nonmutual collateral estoppel?
Nonparties from first action assert collateral estoppel in subsequent action against parties from first action
What is defensive collateral estoppel?
Defendant in second action asserts to avoid relitigating issue from first action
When is offensive collateral estoppel NOT permitted?
1) Plaintiff could have easily joined first action
2) Defendant had little incentive to vigorously defend in first action
3) Second action affords procedural opportunities unavailable in first action; OR
4) Inconsistent findings on issue exist
What is offensive collateral estoppel?
Used by a plaintiff in the second action to establish an issue from the first action
How may a settlement of a federal class action be approved?
1) Approval by the court
2) AFTER the court holds a hearing AND
3) Issues findings that the settlement is fair, reasonable, and adequate
What types of matters may a federal court NOT take, even if diversity is met?
1) Probate matters
2) Domestic relations
Where is venue proper for a foreign citizen?
Any federal judicial district
What happens if a poll reveals a jury verdict is unanimous?
Enter judgement consistent with verdict
What happens if a poll reveals a jury verdict is NOT unanimous?
Direct further deliberation OR order new trial
How is domicile for an individual changed?
1) Establish a physical presence in a new place; AND
2) Manifest an intent to reside there indefinitely
What type of issue is jury selection?
Procedural = federal law controls
What type of law is applied under federal-question jurisdiction?
Federal procedural & Federal substantive law
When may a federal court grant a preliminary injuction?
1) Success = Movant is likely to succeed on the merits
2) Irreparable Harm = Movant is likely to suffer irreparable harm in the absence of relief
3) Balance = The balance of equities is in the movant’s favor
4) Public Interest = The injunction is in the best interests of the public
May interrogatories be served on nonparties?
No; interrogatories are a method of discovery in which a party serves written question on another party, not a nonparty (e.g., expert witness)
How may a party demand a jury trial (under FRCP 38)?
1) Issue = Have a triable issue (any legal claim where the amount in controversy exceeds $20)
2) Service = serve the other parties with a written jury trial demand no later than 14 calendar days after the last pleading
3) File = filing the jury trial demand with the court within a reasonable time after service of the demand
What type of service is required if a defendant’s identity and address are known or obtainable through reasonable efforts?
Personal service or some other means likely to notify the defendant
When may a party NOT conduct an oral deposition without the court’s leave or the parties’ stipulation?
1) Ten = the deposition exceeds the 10-deposition limit
2) Early = the deposition is sought before the initial planning conference
3) Done = the deponent was already deposed in the case
When may an immediate appeal be available (under the interlocutory appeals statute)?
- I = Injunction
- C = Certification by district court
- C = Class action certification
- A = Appointment of receiver
- A = Admiralty cases
- C = Collateral-order doctrine
- B = Bankruptcy cases (certain orders)
- M = Mandamus (petition for writ)
- P = Patent-infringement order (accounting left)
“In Certain Circumstances, An Appeal Can Be Made Prematurely”
When is a compulsory counterclaim NOT waived without an assertion?
If the action is dismissed before the defendant files an answer
NOTE: the claim can be raised in a future lawsuit
What is required to assert the Class Action Fairness Act?
1) 100 = Class contains at least 100 members
2) Minimal = minimal diversity (at least one class member and one defendant are diverse)
3) 5 = AIC for aggregated claims exceeds $5 million
What is a clerical mistake?
A misstatement of the court’s intent (e.g., court entered judgement for $10,000 instead of $100,000
When must a clerical mistake be corrected if there is an appeal?
Before appeal docketed, either on the court’s own initiative (sua sponte) or by motion
What is an oversight or omission?
When an exclusion misrepresents the court’s intent (e.g., judgement failed to include required interest in award)
When must an oversight or omission be corrected if there is an appeal?
After appeal docketed WITH appellate court’s leave
When may a party seek extraordinary relief from a district court’s final judgement?
WITHIN ONE YEAR from entry of final judgement:
1) Mistake, inadvertence, surprise, excusable neglect
2) Newly discovered evidence
3) Fraud, misrepresentation, misconduct
WITHIN REASONABLE TIME from entry of final judgement:
1) Void judgement (e.g., lack of jurisdiction)
2) Judgement:
- Satisfied, released, discharged
- Based on reversed or vacated judgement
- Will violate equity if applied prospectively
3) Other reason justifying relief (RARE)
If a defendant does not respond to damages-related allegations, are the allegations admitted?
No; damages-related allegations cannot be admitted by the defendant’s failure to deny them in an answer
Under Erie, when is state law considered outcome determinitive?
When failing to apply state law would result in:
1) Forum-shopping; OR
2) Inequitable administration of the laws
When is an issue considered substantive under Erie?
1) Outcome determinative; AND
2) No countervailing federal policy interest
When must a request for attorney’s fees be filed?
No more than 14 days after entry of final judgement
When must a renewed request for judgement as a matter of law be filed?
No more than 28 days after entry of final judgement
When must a request for a new trial be filed?
No more than 28 days after entry of final judgement
When must a request to alter or amend judgement be filed?
No more than 28 days after entry of final judgement
When must a request to correct a mistake be filed?
Freely OR with appellate court’s leave if docketed
When must a request for extraordinary relief be filed?
Either within 1 year from entry of final judgement OR within a reasonable time, depending on the basis of relief
What is subject-matter jurisdiction?
The power of the court to decide this type of case
What is personal jurisdiction?
The power of the court to decide the rights and liabilities of this defendant
What is venue?
Among the courts that have SMJ and PJ, which district(s) have proper venue (location)?