wk6: BV - BV3 Diagnosis of Binocular Vision Disorders Flashcards
Describe how the fixation disparity approach works
plots the amount of prism required to eliminate FD. This is the associated phoria and can be used to determine amount of prism required to treat some BV disorders
What is fixation disparity?
Fixation disparity (FD) is the small misalignment of the eyes under binocular conditions from exact bifoveal fixation
How many profiles/types of fixation disparity are there?
- I, II, III, IV.
fixation disparity plots to indicate the binocular vision problem from among the 4 types
Is fixation disparity practical clinically? Explain
No because it is time consuming
When should we use fixation disparity?
Only use if prism is being considered in the management plan
Is graphical analysis practical clinically? Explain (2)
No. It is cumbersome and time consuming having to graphically plot findings
What is sheard’s criterion?
Reserve = 2 x phoria. So if reserve is less than 2 x phoria then you’re likely to have a BV problem
What is percival’s criterion?
Phoria = 1/3rd reserve
What is Morgan’s normative analysis?
Groups of BV data are analysed and profiles of patients are formed based on typical presentations
What is the disadvantage of Morgan’s normative analysis?
As this approach has not been modified to include more recent clinical tests, it falls short and fails to identify some accommodation and vergence problems
How many practitioners use OEP analytic analysis?
Not many
Is OEP analytic analysis an evidence based approach?
No. However it is consistent
What type of system does OEP analytic analysis use?
21 point system which relates to the 21 things you need to do in clinical settings
What are the disadvantages of OEP analytic analysis? (2)
Very rigid/strict approach
All behind phoropter (so no consideration of proximal cues)
Which approach is the most widely used clinically?
Integrative analysis approach
List 4 advantages of the Integrative analysis approach
- compares individual test results against expected published values
- identifies any patterns or characteristic signs that indicate a particular profile of an accommodative-vergence problem
- integrates this with patient’s symptoms, hx, risk factors, visual demands
- narrows and proposes possible diagnosis/diagnoses
(5. flexible, accurate)
How flexible is the Integrative analysis approach?
Quite flexible approach and more likely to produce an accurate representation of patient problems
Explain the Integrative analysis approach in 3 points
- compare test findings to a table of expected normative data
- group the findings that are outside the normal range to look for patterns
- identify the possible diagnosis based on the pattern especially if symptoms and signs fit
How does the Integrative analysis approach differ from Morgan’s normative analysis approach?
Integrative analysis approach analyses results one by one instead of as groups of data like normative approach
Integrative analysis is the circles inside circles thing. Starting from inner most circle outward, what are the important features we want to integrate? (4)
- patient symptoms
- patient needs + demands
- risk factors
- clinical findings, characteristic features