Week 7: Diagnostic Studies, Clinical Prediction, Qualitative Research, Synthesis Research Flashcards
What type of research is Diagnostic Studies?
Exploratory and Descriptive
Diagnostic studies test a “special test” against a…
gold standard to assess its validity
Diagnostic tests have three potential purposes:
- focuses the examination
- identify problems that require physician referral
- assist in classification
Index test =
diagnostic test being studied
Gold standard =
an accurate indication of the patient’s true status
EBP Perspective
- all about probabilities and limiting uncertainty
- Pretest probability –> test –> posttest probability
pretest probability =
baseline probability of a certain condition before any testing takes place
posttest probability =
the revised likelihood of the diagnosis based on the outcome of the test
test threshold
“The probability below which a diagnostic test will not be ordered or performed because the possibility of the diagnosis is so remote”
yellow section
treatment threshold
“the probability above which a diagnostic test will not be ordered or performed because the possibility of the diagnosis is so great that immediate treatment is indicated.”
green section
Sensitivity
proportion of people WITH the disease who have a positive test result
True Positive
Specificity
Proportion of people WITHOUT the disease who have a negative test result
True Negatives
True positive is
positive clinical test, condition present
False negative is
negative clinical test, condition present
False positive is
positive clinical test, condition absent
True negative is
negative clinical test, condition absent
100% sensitivity
- detects all the TRUE POSITIVES
- helpful for “ruling out” the condition (when negative test)
- good screening tests are highly sensitive
100% specificity
- detects all of the TRUE NEGATIVES
- helpful for “ruling in” the condition (when positive test)
- more important for diagnostic special tests
SpPin
- a test with HIGH specificity
- that is positive
- helps rule a condition IN
SnNout
- a test with HIGH sensitivity
- that is negative
- helps rule a condition OUT
Likelihood Ratios (LRs)
sensitivity information combined with specificity information
if diagnostic test is positive:
use +LR
if diagnostic test is negative:
use -LR
with +LR, you want probability of false positives to be
to be LOW
with -LR, you want probability of true negatives to be
to be HIGH
Clinical Prediction Rules can be for
diagnosis, screening, factors that predict response to treatment
Diagnosis is for
rule in, specificity, +LR
Screening is for
rule out, sensitivity, -LR
Validating CPRs Steps
deriving the model, validation of the rule, impact analysis
deriving the model
- look for factors that contribute to diagnosis
- Sn and Sp: good for ruling dx in or out?
- OARs: Sn = 95%; Sp = 50% (better for ruling out)
validation of the rule
- confirm accuracy on different samples
- narrow vs broad
impact analysis
- has a CPR been adopted, and has it improved diagnosis?
- OARs have significantly reduced number of X-rays