Week 5: CLimate Change, polarisation, dissonance Flashcards
Right Between Your Ears:
Dr said the _________ area was lighting up when believing something
V.Medial pre frontal region
Right Between Your Ears:
did they find that the pattern of brain activation between belief and disbelief was consistent between all beliefs or just certain beliefs?
it was consistent for all beliefs, factual ethical and religious
Right Between Your Ears:
What did they find when they studied the brain activation in god believing and non god believing people when asked about god
the brain activation was almost identical whether they believed in god or not.
Right Between Your Ears:
Did the people who they interviewed who believed in judgement day believe in it wholeheartedly from the beginning?
No they all seemed to have some initial doubt, and even not that interested. The belief grew in time.
Right Between Your Ears:
Dissonance is a _____ state
motivational state
Right Between Your Ears:
What is dissonance as uncomfotable as?
Hunger of thirst
Right Between Your Ears:
As the feeling of anxiety and dissonance rises people will….
try and find a way to reduce it and alleviate the anxiety
Right Between Your Ears:
When we do something that violates the self-concept that we have it, creates
cognitive dissonance
Right Between Your Ears:
what are the two options we have when confronted with information that goes against our self concept?
revise our view of ourselves, dismiss the evidence [path of least resistance]
Right Between Your Ears:
What’s the third way of dealing with cognitive dissonance as described in the movie?
I remain a good person, and the thing I did remains a bad thing, now how do I learn from this wrong, bad thing, so i don’t repeat it, but without it effecting my self concept
Right Between Your Ears:
Maurice’s tests, when he didn’t know what judgement day was, questions where he had difficulty - after the fact of judgement day not arriving - showed …
increased activity in areas related to internal conflict. also activity in frontal brain, introspection and thinking about our own thoughts.
Right Between Your Ears:
why is it so hard to say I was wrong?
it requires integrity courage and guts
Leon Festinger’s work led to the development of….
Cognitive dissonance theory
The feeling of believing is like….
the feeling of knowing.
having knowledge has a feeling attached to it.
What is the generic definition of belief?
anything that our brain decides to be true [ but depends on sub discipline and context]
What are two main components of belief?
and what is this consistent with in terms of research?
Reasoned Component
- evidence, explanation
+
Intuitive Component
- it feels right, it all fits
consistent with ‘dual-process theories of cognition’
What is the basic premise of dual process theory?
That our brain engages in at least two ways of thinking, intuitive and reasoned
What did this study find?
What are the three brain states shown here from the harris Sheth and Cohen 2008 study?
What well known state is the belief brain state similar to?
What brain belief [of 3] state appears to require more cognitive effort to override the default state and why do they think this?
Disbelief, because you seem to need to override and turn down the DMN
Who thought that disbelief requires an extra step of rejection and not just acceptance like in belief?
Spinoza
What were the results?
Can the correctness of beliefs be found in our brains an what study showed that?
NO.
What did these neuroimaging studies show?
What did the Howlett and paulus study show about different dimensions in the brain?
Explain Carol Tavris and Eliot Aronson’s analogy of the pyramid….
The current theory is that belief change is driven by……..explain….
dissonance reduction mechanisms.
one study found that rationalization and self-justification processes may be engaged very quickly after the initial decision.
What happened when the documentary makers went back in Oct 21st?
1/3 people had believed the new prediction, but remembered the failure of May 21 and were aware they could be wrong again, which differs from Festinger’s findings and is more in line with more modern theories. most people have a point in which they update their beliefs to be in line with reality.
What areas implicated in negative arousal were activated in studies on the induction of cognitive dissonance?
Anterior Insula