Week 4 - The Executive Branch Flashcards
3 main aspects of the Legislative branch
Legislative branch:
•Represents the people and is accountable via elections
•Debates public issues and bills
•Makes laws (really just passes them)
2 main aspects of the executive branch
Executive branch:
•Implements laws (and makes them)
•Be non-partisan at the bureaucratic level: faithfully carry out policies regardless of who forms government
What are the important interdependencies that act as checks and balances?
•Prime Minister/Cabinet are drawn from the legislature
•Prime Minister/Cabinet must maintain confidence of the House of Commons (i.e., responsible government)
•Prime Minister/Cabinet appoint justices, judges, and Senators
•Justices can rule whether laws are constitutional
But in practice these checks and balances between branches are much more limited – a fusion of powers. How so? (2)
•Majority governments ensure confidence of the House in the Prime Minister and Cabinet is automatic
•Executive branch dominates and legislative branch is unable to serve as a constraint on power (in majority governments)
Define the Crown, in practice what does the crown do?
•The King of Canada is the Head of State, and thus head of the executive branch
•In practice, the King delegates her authority to the Governor General, who resides at Rideau Hall
•Governor General: Mary Simon
Three sources of power for the Crown, as exercised by the Governor General:
•Prerogative (or reserve) powers
•Constitution Act, 1867
•Letters Patent, 1947
In theory, the Governor General exercises a considerable amount of power, known as prerogative or reserve powers. What are the powers? (5)
•Commander-in-chief of armed forces
•Selecting/dismissing the Prime Minister
•Dissolving Parliament and calling elections
•Proroguing Parliament
•Granting royal assent
How are the prerogative powers limited?
•Prerogative powers can be limited by the Constitution and by legislation
•Constitution Act, 1867 codified many powers, like royal assent, appointments, and parliamentary diss0lution but subjected them to conditions
•The Letters Patent explicitly transferred powers to the Governor General
•Other powers were removed from the Crown by Cabinet via legislation (e.g., making treaties, matters of war and peace, appointments of ambassadors)
by convention Governor General almost always needs to use powers in a specific way or with the advice of the Prime Minister. What are the powers of the crown in practice?
•Appointments, prorogation and dissolution are always done on the advice of the Prime Minister
•Leader of the majority party is always selected as Prime Minister; or leader of plurality party is given first chance to form government
•Royal assent is automatic; dismissal is never used
What was the King-Byng affair and the implications of the event
•Liberal government under Mackenzie King had a minority government backed by the Progressive Party
•Election resulted in PC plurality, but King maintained narrow minority with help of Progressives
•Scandal rocked the Liberal Party only a few months later and King requested an election – rejected by GG Byng on ground PCs should be given opportunity Undemocratic, or the right call?
What happened during the 2008-2009 Coalition crisis and implications of this?
•Conservatives won a minority government in 2008 election
•Coalition of Liberals and NDP with Bloc support signaled their intent to vote down the government on a motion of non-confidence
•Granted prorogation by GG Michaelle Jean and coalition collapsed with the delay
•What is democratic?
What happened with Tupper’s conservatives in the 1896 election?
•Tupper’s Conservatives lost the 1896 election despite capturing the most votes (48% vs. 41%)
•Tupper refused to resign as PM, arguing Laurier wouldn’t be able to successfully form government
•The Governor General – the Earl of Aberdeen – refused to grant appointments to Tupper forcing his resignation
What are the pros and cons of the crown’s roles
Pros:
•Prime Ministers are exceptionally powerful, prerogative powers can act as an emergency brake
•Important for office to be completely untethered to partisan conflict
Cons:
•Undemocratic to have an unelected Head of State with such power
•Causes unnecessary tension with French Canada
What is the cabinet?
Cabinet is technically where power resides in Canada’s system of government
•“There shall be a council to aid and advise…to be style the Queen’s Privy Council of Canada”
•The actions of the Crown shall be taken “by and with the Advice of the Queen’s Privy Council of Canada”
•All past and current members of cabinet retain title, but only current ministers have power
What is the operation of the cabinet?
- deputy PM
- Junior ministers
- Ministers with major portfolios
•Deputy Prime Minister operates as second in command – if one is appointed
•Followed by ministers with major portfolios (e.g., Defense, Public Safety, Finance, etc.)
•Sometimes there are junior ministers (secretaries of state, ministers of state, etc.) whose power varies by prime minister
What is ministerial responsibility?
•Another mechanism of accountability of the executive to the legislature is through ministerial responsibility
•Cabinet ministers must explain and defend the actions of their ministry to the legislature and resign in the event of serious controversy