Week 4 Flashcards
Reference Dependence (1st part)
What are context-dependent preferences
An individual’s choices and preferences can vary depending on the specific circumstances/context in which a decision is made
Several factors can influence context-dependent preferences
- Social norms
- Decision framing
- Availability of alternatives
What is mental accounting
How people categorize and treat money differently based on subjective criteria, such as the source of the money or its intended use, even though all money is technically interchangeable (e.g., money for groceries, holidays etc)
- People make decisions as if the accounts were unrelated
- Each mental account has its own utility function
Mental accounting includes 3 things
- Use of heuristics
- Loss aversion
- Sunk costs
What is the formula for MRS
MRS (Slope of IC) = -p2/p1 (Slope of BC)
Eply et al (2006) - Income tax rebate check experiment
87% of the income tax rebate check if it was called “bonus income” vs only 25% spent the “withheld income”
What are the keys to mental accounting
- Decisions are made as if the budget for different mental accounts are not exchangeable
- Losses and gains relative to a reference point in each account are treated differently according to a value function
- Individuals receive transaction utility as well as consumption utility
Transaction utility definition
Happiness that individuals derive from the process of making a purchase (separate to the utility they receive from consuming the good itself)
Reference-dependent Preferences Definition
An individual evaluates outcomes relative to a reference point, then classify gains and losses
Example of reference dependent preferences
Online privacy
- Individual privacy notices don’t always result in the same levels of disclosure
- Consumers evaluate privacy notices relative to the status quo (their current/past level of protection)
Status quo bias definition
Effect that people are biased in favour of choosing the status quo in decision problems (people’s preference for keeping things the way they currently are)
Example of status quo bias
2 systems of organ donation in Europe
- Explicit consent (e.g., UK)
- Presumed consent (e.g., France)
Reference dependence has many different causes - name 3
- Loss aversion
- Transaction costs
- Perceptual coding
Tversky and Kahneman (1991) - reference state
Although the reference state usually corresponds to the decision maker’s current position, it can be influenced by expectations, norms and aspirations
Redelmeier and Tversky (1992) - gamble experiment
Result: People tend to be very risk averse for lotteries that contain both gains and losses