Week 3 - Cross-Cultural Cognition Flashcards
CULTURAL
DIMENSIONS THEORY: Hofstede (2001)
Individualism–collectivism
* How interdependent is a culture?
Uncertainty avoidance
* How do people deal with ambiguity?
Power distance
* How hierarchical is a culture?
Long-term/short-term orientation
* Connection with tradition, also economic orientation
Masculinity/femininity
* How distinct are gender roles? Distribution of classical male/female traits
CULTURAL VARIATION
Cultures = fluid and dynamic, changing
over time
ideas and norms don’t necessarily emerge to
address universal problems…
result from cultural learning
SOURCES OF
CULTURAL VARIATION
-Ecological and geographical differences
- Local ecologies (cultural values and norms)
Proximate causes vs. distal causes
Evoked culture vs. transmitted culture
PROXIMATE AND
DISTAL CAUSES
Proximate causes: Differences that have direct and
immediate effects
Distal causes: Early differences that lead to effects
over long periods of time
EVOKED AND
TRANSMITTED CULTURE
Evoked culture: “biologically encoded”; Specific environments evoke specific
responses from (all) people within that environment,
becoming part of a culture
Transmitted culture: Cultural information passed on or
learned via social transmission or modeling
–> Not always clearly separated!
Transmitted culture is arguably always involved in
maintaining cultural norms, even when evoked cultural
responses are also present
TRANSMISSION OF
CULTURAL INFORMATION:
Biological evolution vs Cultural evolution
Biological evolution: ideas need to be retained and passed on
- Natural selection
- Sexual selection
–> Sometimes conflicting! (e.g., peacocks males and their feather tales are easy to spot, not good for hiding)
Cultural evolution: Similarities with biological evolution
- Ideas can be persistent (high survival rate)
- Ideas can be more prone to being passed around
(reproduced more)
Cultural evolution: differences from biological evolution
- More copying errors in cultural ideas
- Cultural ideas can be transmitted horizontally among
peers, not only vertically across generations (ideas move faster than psychological traits) - Cultural ideas do not have to be adaptive
Information going viral: Memes
Agents of cultural transmission (Dawkins)
–> Shared jokes/context
COMMUNICABLE
IDEAS: In order to be easily shared, information might be especially…
- useful or informative
- elicit emotional response
- simple to communicate
Ideas generally spread within social networks, leading to
clustering of attitudes: ???
Dynamical social impact theory (Norms develop among those who communicate regularly)
PERSISTING IDEAS: persist longer how?
Ideas that have a small number of counterintuitive elements
persist longer
- minimal
- religious narratives / myth/storytelling
CHANGING CULTURES: changing and evolving
in several ways…
- Increasingly interconnected
- Increasingly individualistic
- People increasingly intelligent
CHANGING CULTURES: INCREASES IN
INTERCONNECTEDNESS
- easier & cheaper transports and long-distance communication
- create a global culture
- countered by increased tribalism or modern populism
CHANGING CULTURES: Individualism vs Collectivism
(Cultures often studied on an Individualism/Collectivism (I/S)
dimension (cf Hofstede))
- Individualism = individuals encouraged to consider
themselves as distinct from others and prioritize own personal
goals over collective goals - Collectivism = individuals encouraged to place more
emphasis on goals of one’s collective or in-group
CHANGING CULTURES: INCREASES IN
INDIVIDUALISM
Visible when comparing younger and older Americans,
proposed reasons include
* More pressures of time and money
* Increased suburbanization
* More electronic entertainment
* Higher socioeconomic status
* More secular
* Decrease in rates of infectious diseases (!)
CHANGING CULTURES: INCREASE IN INDIVIDUALISM (in collectivistic society)
Also visible in traditionally collectivistic cultures, e.g. Japan
* Higher divorce rates
* Decreases in family size
* Placing higher value on independence in children