Week 2 & 3- Pre Modern Growth Flashcards
How was China more developed than Europe prior to the Great Divergence?
China was richer, more scientific, more urbanised and had a strong sophisticated government.
What are some inventions of China?
-Paper
-Gunpowder
-Compass
-Printing
What are some statistics about China pre Great Divergence?
-The Song Dynasty lead the world GDP per Capita.
-1/3 of global manufacturing output was produced in China pre 19th century.
When did Japan reverse the Great Divergence?
Japan overtook China in the 18th century and Europe in the 20th century in terms of GDP per capita.
What is the Revisionist view on the Great Divergence?
-EUROPE = ASIA pre 18C
-Divergence was a product of 19C increasing returns. This was likely the result of coal, colonial policy and historical shocks (Opium Wars).
-Emphasis on resources advantages/constraints. I.e. negative colonial rule or European trade networks.
-Empirically based on ‘grain’ wage comparisons (goods based transactions) between Europe and Asian regions.
What is the traditionalist view on the Great Divergence?
-EUROPE > ASIA pre 18C (focus on North West Europe)
-NW Europe ahead due to institutions.
-Emphasis on commercial expansion, urbanisation, agricultural productivity, higher wages and cheaper energy.
-Empirically based on ‘silver’ wage (money) comparisons.
What are the two way of quantitatively assessing views on the Great Divergence?
(1) Wages
(2) Income
How are wages used as a quantitative method of measuring the Great Divergence?
-Traditionalists argue this comparison doesn’t make sense.
-Consider ‘silver wages’ not ‘grain wages’ as the price of food is lower in LDCs and manufactured goods more expensive in LDCs too.
-Comparison is easier through conversion into currency and price adjustment through comparable baskets of goods
Describe the nominal wage difference by century.
15C- Silver wages begin divergence.
16C- South Indian silver wages 1/5 that of England.
17C- Grain wages low but comparable
18C- Asian wages diverge from European.
Do the two types of wages give evidence to the Great Divergence?
Silver Wages- Yes
Grain wages- No
What is a more holistic approach to measure standards of living?
PPP (Wages adjusted by relative prices) to calculate a basket of goods.
What are the two basket of goods options?
(1) European Respectability Basket- 1940 Kcal and an 18C budget and diet
(2) Bare Bones Basket- 1940 Kcal and basic good foods.
What is the European real wage evidence?
-NW Europe remained rich after the plague in 1400.
-London/Amsterdam families 3-4 times subsistence.
-Rest of world low wages during 1500-1700
How can income be measured?
-Through production or expenditure
What ‘little divergences’ occurred within Europe?
1400: Southern Europe ahead until 1600
1600: Netherlands ahead until 1700
1700: Britain ahead until 20C
What ‘little divergence’ occurred in Asia?
900: China ahead until 1700
1700: India catches up to China
1700: Japan ahead until 20C
What are some beliefs about China as to why Europe developed ahead of it?
China was/had:
(1) Different demographics
(2) Poor government institutions
(3) Less urban
(4) Less agriculturally productive
(5) Expensive energy sources
(6) Less innovative
What demography issues did China have?
-Higher births/deaths
-High famine rate
-Institutions governed fertility and marriage
What are the components of population growth?
Natural Rate of Increase = Crude Brith Rate - Crude Death Rte
Crude Birth Rate = Births/Population
Crude Death Rate= Births/Population