Week 2 Flashcards
You can see in somebody’s brain whether they are depressed? True or false
False
What diseases are there neuromarkers for
Epilepsy, Parkinsons, MS
These disorders moved from psychology to neurology
5E cognition
Phenomenological psychology
What if mental disorders are physical disorders but we have the wrong understanding of the body
4E cognition
-Embodied- Body not just as a physical thing but the anchor of our perception on the world and a means for interacting
-Embedded: In an environment
-Enacted: In interaction with the environment
-Extended: Tools
Valenstein and mental disorders
Wrote the book ‘Blaming the Brain’- The Truth about Drugs and Mental health
“The statement that mental disorders are physical diseases implies a lot more than can be justified”
Mind and body
Previously the word soul was used instead of mind
In ancient Greece there was understandings of the soul that were physical- Imagined soul was part of body
Mind and body are torn apart with words
Consequences of thinking of something as a brain problem
Become more passive because they think medication will do the work
DBS is a common treatment for
Parkinsons
Cortical equipotentiality
The whole brain has the potential to fulfil the same tasks
-Opposite of phrenology
Localization models
After cortical equipotentiality
Moved towards localization views using brain imaging
But moved back again as there are not as many specific brain systems
Delgado’s approach of introducing electrodes
Based on the assumption that psychological functioning is realised in localized brain areas
Delgado and ‘the pleasure centre’
Found in brains of rodents, cats and patients
Supported the idea of localized brain function
Free will and morality
If we don’t have free will, we cannot be held responsible for our actions
If we are not responsible for our actions, then we cannot be guilty for our actions
If we cannot be guilty for our actions, then penal law has to be revised
Arguments against free will
-We are not free because our brains are determined (Old philosophical problem of whether determination is compatible with free will)
-We are not free because our decisions are determined by unconscious brain processes (psychological problem of conscious will)
Original Libet experiments
- Subjects attached to EEG’s
-Hand movements measured in relation to brain signals (Hand movement terminates trial)
-EEG measures premotor area of frontal cortex (measures readiness potential)
-Subjects reported not always moving when feeling the “urge” - When people move it is initiated unconsciously- But you can consciously reject this unconscious urge (Conscious veto) therefore the original RP cannot be the cause of the movement
-Unconscious urge is necessary to move but there is another process which is also required to carry out the movement
-This experiment has been shown as an argument against free will
What did Libet’s experiment show about voluntary actions
They could be initiated unconsciously
How long before a movement can someone ‘veto’ it
Up to 200ms
Suggestions for improvement in science communication
-Publication of negative results
-Placing less weight on impact factor
-Insulating researchers from industry and commercialization pressures
-Independent science media organizations
-Educating science graduate students on communication
-Using the full breadth of media