Week 11-12 (Consciousness) Flashcards
<p>What is consciousness in research? (2)</p>
<p>In psychology/cognitive science, the term “Consciousness” is used interchangeably with “Awareness.”</p>
<p>Visual awareness, self consciousness (etc) are terms to refer to different forms or “contents” of consciousness</p>
<p>What is the easy problem vs the hard problem?</p>
<p><u>The easy problem</u></p>
<p>The difference between total unconsciousness vs anything more than that? (Unconsciouness vs Anything Else)</p>
<p><u>The hard problem</u></p>
<p>The quality of the experience colours, sounds, feelings (Why is the experience of colour different from sound)</p>
<p>- We are trying to solve the easy problem</p>
<p>What are experimental methods for consciousness research?</p>
<p>1.Binocular Rivalry</p>
<p>2. Backward Masking</p>
<p>Using stimuli that generate switches in perception without changes to the stimuli (like binocular rivalry or masking) with brain imaging or neural recordings can help identify activity associated with a conscious experience.</p>
<p>What is binocular rivarly as a experimental method for consciousness?</p>
<p>When two different images are simultaneously presented to the two eyes [constant stimuli], you will only be conscious of one of the two images at a time [fluctuating awareness].</p>
<p></p>
<p>What is backward masking as a experimental method for consciousness?</p>
<p>Manipulating time gap between mask (clap) and target (xxx)</p>
<p>The greater the delay between target and mask the more likely it will “make it through” to conscious access.</p>
<p>What is NCC (2). What are its limitations? (2)</p>
<p>Neural Correlates of Consciousness (NCC)</p>
<ul> <li>Minimal set of neuronal events that give rise to a conscious percept (easy problem)</li> <li>At any point, some neurons correlate with consciousness and some does not. What is the difference?</li></ul>
<p><u>Limitations</u></p>
<ul> <li>NCC is not a complete explanation of consciousness.</li> <li>Might be a mystery now but the mystery will disappear when the biology is understood (like with DNA).</li></ul>
<p></p>
<p>What is 1st theory: Sparse Coding Model?</p>
<p><u>“Sparse Coding”</u></p>
<ul> <li>Relatively small collection of individual neurons (a few thousand) will be selective for a specific “concept” (identity, object or idea etc)</li></ul>
<p></p>
<ul></ul>
<p></p>
<p>Example of Sparse Coding Model (3)</p>
<p><u>Grandmother/Jennifer Anniston Neuron</u></p>
<ul> <li>Conscious experience of grandmother requires neurons in your brain coding “grandmother” to fire.</li> <li>Activity of this cell ensemble is invariant (insensitive) to orientation, size, location etc and would fire every time you saw or imagined (heard or smelt) your grandmother.</li> <li>Using binocular rivalry, they also found neurons which fire when "bill clinton" is consciously perceived</li></ul>
<p>What is 2nd theory: Global Workspace Theory</p>
<ul> <li>Information is loaded into workspace and powerful cognitive processes can make use of it</li> <li>Act of transmitting these data from working memoryto the functional modules (e.g., percept, cognition, motor areas)giverise to consciousness.</li></ul>
<p>[Not that a separate system (man in the head) “sees” information in the workspace to make it conscious.]</p>
<p></p>
<p>What, and where is the global workspace in the brain?</p>
<p>Consciousness:</p>
<ul> <li>Signal is sufficiently strong to “break into” prefrontal cortex, allowinginformation to be transmitted between other brain areas</li> <li>Stimuli will have unconscious processing before moving into PFC (which will have consciousness)</li></ul>
<p>Initial fMRI studies on Consciousness</p>
<p>A summary of studies showing areas of <u>parietal and frontal cortex</u> with activation correlated with changes in visual awareness</p>
<p>(Sensory processing /=/ consciousness)</p>
<p>What did“No report” paradigms find?</p>
<p>Activity in the <u>frontal</u> part of the brain appears to be important for the <u>response</u> component of the task. If participants don't have to respond, frontal becomes inactive</p>
<p>Suggest parietal area is the key.</p>
<p>What is the Integrated Information Theory?</p>
<ul> <li>Consciousness = Integrated Information</li> <li>The greater the number of <strong>mutually exclusive</strong> possible states a system can hold, the more conscious it is.</li> <li>Any system with integrated information is conscious (including computers)</li></ul>
<p>Integrated Information: Experiences</p>
<ul> <li>Our experience is integrated and unified <ul> <li>It can’t be experienced as its components (contrast, location, content etc)</li> </ul> </li> <li>Our experience is informative <ul> <li>It is specific and distinct from alternative experiences</li> <li>Total black (an absence of sensory input) is informative for what it is not [Something vs Nothing]</li> </ul> </li></ul>
<p>Integrated Theory: Cerebellum and Gut</p>
<ul> <li>Cerebellum andgut show limited signs of consciousness, despite having millions of neurons.</li> <li>IT suggests cerebellum and gut are not conscious because the neurons are not connected to each other like they are in the cortex.</li> <li>Any system with integrated information is conscious</li></ul>
<p>Limitations of Integrated Theory</p>
<p>Contradictions</p>
<ul> <li>Theory states that consciousness=integrated information andsystem will be conscious if phi > 1</li> <li>Predicts gut has thousands of micro-conscious units, but our brains can't accessseparate gut consciousness?</li></ul>
<p>Time Scales</p>
<ul> <li>Many bodily systems signal at the different speed</li> <li>Predicts we have multiple layers of consciousness overlaid in different time scales?</li></ul>
<p></p>
<p>Theory vs Theory</p>
<ul> <li>Sparse coding requires a network of specific cells to fire for consciousness. Does not say where in the brain or to what extent networks integrate</li> <li>Potentially consistent with Global work space or IIT</li></ul>
<p></p>
<ul> <li>Involvement of distributed frontal brain regions consistent with IIT, Global Work Space and potentially sparse coding (if sparse network is distributed widely)</li></ul>
<p>Summary of Theories</p>
<p>All of these theories simply state that consciousness is the result of “X” condition, but they do not explainwhy “X” condition should lead to a conscious experience.</p>
<p><strong>SAQ</strong>. What is binocular rivalry and why is it a good tool for consciousness research?</p>
<p>Binocular rivalry is the presentation of 2 stimuli simulataneously but we can only be conscious of1 at a time.</p>
<p>It is good because withchanges in percept, we can use neuroimaging and neural activity for example toidentify what is assoicated with the percept change.</p>
<p><strong>SAQ</strong>. What is <b>Backward Masking</b>and why is it a good tool for consciousness research?</p>
<p>Actual stimulus is the same but by manipulatingthe time gap between target and mask, we sometimes don't perceive the target.</p>
<p>Hence, can use neuroimaging or neural recording to compare responses between when we see target and we don't see target and what is associated with consciousness.</p>
<p>What is the question in reference to "levels of consciousness"</p>
<p>Changes in the intensity or degree of consciousness.</p>
<p>Even if we can answer this question, we still won't know about the content of the person's experience (e.g., what does 'less consciousness' feel like?)</p>
<p>What are 2 dimensions of consciousness</p>
<p>Awareness: Levelsof consciousness</p>
<p>Vigilance: Awake behaviour, eyes open</p>
<p>If we want to measure consciousness, what can we not rely on?</p>
<p>Measure of consciousness that does not rely on sensory processing or behaviour as consciousness can exist with undeveloped/impaired sensory processing and/or motor output.</p>
<p>Problem of diagnosis in acute brain injury?</p>
<ul> <li>High levels of misdiagnosis in Coma, Vegetative State (VS), and Locked-in Syndrome as all 3 states are “non-responsive” despite different levels of awareness & cognition</li></ul>
<p>In cases like brain death, it is clear it is brain death if there is total loss of activity throughout the brain. Normally, if you put someone in the brain scan you can still see activity in the brain</p>
<p>Evidence of consciousness in VS? (3)</p>
<ul> <li>Healthy people and a non-responsive VS patient (GCS = 4) was asked to imagine “playing tennis” or “visiting rooms in your house”</li> <li>Brain activity in the VS patient was found to be similar to the healthy people</li> <li>Even if people failed, they show minimal consciousness</li></ul>
<p>What is consciousness not linked to? (2)</p>
<p>Level of consciousness:</p>
<ul> <li>Not directly linked to neural activity (though zero activity= zero consciousness) (e.g., sleep)</li> <li> <p>Not directly linked to amount of neural synchrony (e.g., anesthesia show increase synchrony as consciousness is lost)</p> </li></ul>
<p>IIT's argument on level of consciousness. (2)</p>
<p><u>Integrated information theory (IIT)</u></p>
<ul> <li>Greater the complexity of the neural signal = Greater consciousness</li> <li>Highly complex brain activity patterns = Greater consciousness</li></ul>
<p></p>
<p>How does IIT assessconsciousness</p>
<p>IIT reduces complexity to a single score to separate those that are conscious from those that are not</p>
<ul> <li>Stimulate brain with TMS > Record "complexity" of brain with EEG > Compress (Remove redundant information) > Complexity Index</li></ul>
<p>"Complexity" is defined by information (e.g., football fan). The more random it is, the more complex it is.</p>
<p>How do we separate out individuals in different states of consciousness?</p>
<p>Complexity index gives a number between 0 and 1 and there is a cut off.</p>
<p>If the complexity of the brain’s response is measuredand they get a complexity index below the cut off, then they are considered unconscious</p>
<ul> <li>LIS = Above cut-off</li> <li>VS and Coma = Below cut-off</li></ul>
<p></p>
<p>Deep brain stimulation and coma</p>
<p>Electrical stimulation to the Thalamus (<em>Relay Centre)</em>has been used to successfully “jump-start consciousness” in people in a vegetative or minimally conscious state.</p>
<p>Anaesthesia and consciousness</p>
<p>Anesthetic drugs are used everyday but their mechanism of action remains a mystery.</p>
<p>However, it impacts the thalamus (often deactivated in VS and some of the first to reactivate when recovered)</p>
<p>What does IIT and Global Workspace Theory say about cortico-thalamic loops?</p>
<p>Integral part of many theories of consciousness</p>
<ul> <li>IIT: Connections from many areas goes through the thalamocortical system (Integrated Hub)</li> <li>Global Workspace Theory: Thalamocortical area is the workspace</li></ul>
<p>Consciousness and psychedelics</p>
<p>Uni-demsnional level-based account might be too simplistic to account for the full range of human conscious.</p>
<p>Might have multiple dimensions of consciousness</p>