W2 Flashcards
Cambell
argues speakers in Dramatic Monologues suffer from an ‘unwilling powerlessness’
speakers employ voiceless subjects and auditors
to generate power of speaker’s role
Ulysses
- unspecific soldiers are objects, Ulysses refers to ‘my mariners’ = sense of ownership
- mariners in fact dead; disembodied language e.g. ‘souls’ obscures view of auditors as actual characters –> Ulysses appears sole character
Browning continuous motif of absent subject
although the women in ‘My Last Duchess’ and ‘Poryphria’s Lover’ are the primary concerns of the poems - they are absent from the direct narrative!
The Last Duchess (1842) posthumous absent women
- ‘my last’ = plurality , possessiveness
2. metrical emphasis on ‘my’ = objectification
Porphyria’s Lover (1836) absent
shift in subject/object syntax from her as active to speaker active (‘she put my arm’ –> I wound/Three times her little throat around, /And strangled her.’ + caesura; perfunctory and simplicity suggests control
Differing methods of exerting/exhibiting power
PL = brute physical force vs MLD = social hierarchy (emissary)
Linda K Hughes
argues that the mariners are in fact dead; the very men who were killed on their previous journey back to Ithaca
Duke’s character
wide critical consensus that his character alludes to Alfonso II, the fifth Duke of Ferrara, an aristocratic figure in the Italian Renaissance
Duke’s thinly veiled rhetorical request ‘Will’t please you rise?’
posing imperative statement within question format; social control
Ulysses name precedes him
as a canonical character in Greek and Roman mythology (As Hayley E. Tartell notes)
Ulysses’ hubris
Tennyson’s ironic “I am a part of all that I have met”; the speaker assumes his overarching effect on those he has encountered during his travels, rather than him being affected by others
Browning and Tennyson both construct their speakers’ supposed power…
in order to discredit it
Duke transforms wife into object; but objects hold power in preoccupation
“none puts buy/ The curtain I have drawn for you, but I”.
Earl G. Ingersoll
through literal objectification of lovers, the love / power can never be lost