Voting Systems Flashcards
FPTP: used for…
UK general elections
STV : used for…
Northern Irish Assembly
SV : used for…
Mayoral elections
AMS: used for…
Scottish elections
FPTP PROS
Single party majority government
Simple
Clear constituent/representative links
FPTP CONS
Disproportional (winners bonus)
Lots of wasted votes (electoral desserts)
Some votes mean more than others
STV PROS
Proportional (ranking 1-7) seat share to vote share is equal
No safe seats (no compliance)
Produces coalitions (representative)
STV CONS
No safe seats (no security)
Coalitions (illegitimate power? - extremist parties?)
Representative is not clear
SV PROS
Single party system (no extremist power)
Clear constituent/representative bonds
SV CONS
Votes are unequal (safe seats)
Complicated for voters (voter apathy?)
Not proportional or representative (winner can receive under 50%)
AMS PROS
Produces coalition governments (representative)
Proportional (vote share = seat share)
AMS CONS
Coalition governments (unstable? - unproductive?)
Complicated system (voter apathy?)
Constituent/representative links are weak (constituents are large)