Valuation Flashcards
What are the key considerations when undertaking a valuation?
- Competence: Do you have the correct level of skills, understanding and knowledge?
- Independence: Check for conflicts or personal interests
- Terms of engagement: Set out in writing confirmation of instruction and receive written conf.
What is the structure of the red book?
- Pt 1: Introduction
- Pt 2: Glossary
-
Pt 3: Professional Standards
o PS1 Compliance with Standards
o PS2 Ethics, Competency, Objectivity & Disclosures -
Pt 4: Valuation Technical and Performance Standards (VPS)
o VPS1 Terms of Engagement
o VPS2 Bases of value and Assumptions
o VPS3 Valuation Approaches & Methods
o VPS4 Inspections, Investigations & records
o VPS5 Valuation Models
o VPS6 Valuation Reports -
Pt 5: Valuation Practice Guidance Applications (VPGA)
o VGPA1 Valuation for Financial Reporting
o VPGA2 Valuation for Secured Lending
o VPGA8 Valuation of Real Property Assets - Pt 6: International Valuation Standards (IVS)
Outline PT.3 of the Red Book:
PT.3 PS (Professional Standards)
PS1 - Complaince with standards where written valuation provided
- PS1&2 mandatory for all members when undertaking valuation services by provision of written advice
- VPS1-6 not always mandatory
PS2 - Ethics, competency,
objectivity and disclosures
- appropriate skill & judgement
- act independetly, avoid COIs & integrity
- Rules of conduct
Outline PT.4 of the Red Book
PT4. VPS (Valuation and Technical Performance Standards)
VPS1 - Terms of Engagement
–> minimum matters confirmed in writing (idenitfication of parties, asset, purpose etc)
VPS2 - Bases of value, Assumptions and Special Assumptions
–> basis of value must be appropriate for purpose (6 bases)
VPS3 - Valuation Approaches & Methods
–> market, income, cost approaches
VPS4 - Inspections, investigations and Records
–> inspections/investigations must be sufficient for valuation
VPS5 - Valuation Models
–> IVS105 - model must be suitable
VPS6 - Valuation Reports
–> must accurately set out conclusion. min. requirements (TOEs)
What are Terms of Engagement?
They describe the fundamental terms applying to the provision of a valuation
- They include (but are not limited to):
–> the asset(s) being valued
–> the intended users of the report
–> the intended use of the valuation and
–> the principal responsibilities of the parties involved.
Also:
–> valuation date
–> assumptions
–> how fee calculated
full list can be found in VPS1 Red Book
What are the 6 bases of value?
- market value
- market rent
- investment value
- equitable value
- synergistic value
- liquidation value
Which valuations are Red Book excempt?
(VPS1-6)
- Agency or brokearage
- Acting as expert witness
- Performing statutory functions
- Internal Purposes
- During negotiation of litigation
When was the new Red Book published and what were the key changes?
- Include practice and process changes from evolving areas such as technology (AI) and ESG.
–> (i.e PS1 use of AI not prohibited, subject to prof judgement e.g confidentiality) - Valuers must consider any ESG factors related which might impact valuation
- Aligns with other global standards such as new IVS 2024
Aside from the RICS Valuation - Global Standards (Red Book) (2025), name some RICS Professional Guidance relating to valuations and key elements
- RICS Professional Standard: Valuation of Development Property, 2019
- Supplements IVS 410 ‘development property’ and guides valuer on the approach to development property valuations (residual).
- “best practice avoids reliance on single method” – i.e cross check residual with comparable method
- DCF good for complex projects, simple better to use residual
- Sensitivity analysis should be used
Define ‘all risks yield’
A growth implicit yield used in an investment valuation that reflects all of the risks and rewards of the subject property
What are the 5 types of valuation?
- comparative method
- investment method
- residual method
- profits method
- depreciated replacement cost method
How are the 5 methods grouped as per IVS103 (Valuation methods)? (Valuation Approaches)
How does IVS 410 (Development Property) differ?
- Income approach: investment, profits method
- Cost approach: DRC method
- Market Approach: comparative
Says that residual is a hybrid of market, cost and income
How would you do a Profits valuation, and for what type of asset?
–> Annual turnover
–> minus costs, working expenses and operator remuneration
–> = adjusted net profit / fair maintainable operating profit (FMOP)
- Used for pubs, care homes where value based on profit rather than building
How would you do a Depreciated Replacement Cost valuation, and for what type of asset?
–> Value of land in existing use
–> plus current costs and fees of replacing building minus discount for depreciation and obsolescence.
- Properties rarely sold on market e.g sewage works
What is a Discounted Cash Flow, and when would you use one?
- A DCF is used to value an investment or project by estimating its future cash flows and discounting them to their present value, to assess whether it’s worth the initial cost.
- Used for complex, multi-phased projects
What is IRR?
The discount rate that makes the net present value of a project zero
- Used to assess total return from investment oppiortunity (making assumptions)
- A higher IRR generally indicates a more attractive investment
what is the NPV?
The sum of the discounted cash flows of a project
- Used to determine if investment gives positive return against a rate of return
- When NPV positive = good investment
Which professional standard relates to hierarchy of evidence?
Comparable Evidence in Real Estate valuation (2019) (reissued 2023)
- Outlines principles in the use of comparable evidence
- Where limited availability of evidence - “the valuer should use a professional judgement to assess the relative importance of evidence on a case-by-case basis.”
How would you find comparable evidence?
- Published online databases (CoStar for commercial, Molior for housing)
- Speak to local agents
Where lack of transactional evidence, market sentiment = crucial
What makes a good set of comparables?
- Comprehensive, (i.e at least three)
- Very similar/identical (location, buiild quality)
- Recent
- Result of an arm’s length transaction
What is the purpose of a residual valuation?
Calculating the value of development land
- (GDV-GDC+Dev Profit=Land Value)
South Acton Residual
Talk me through your residual valuation in South Acton
- I calculated GDV using comparables in the area, favouring new builds over the abundance of Victorian terraces.
- I requested an internal high level OCE for construction costs.
- As the scheme was already consented, I allowed for 15% developer profit due to the low perceived risk.
–> This gave a very low land value, even when sensitised.
South Acton Residual
How else could you have calculated construction costs?
What would have been the downside of using such website?
BCIS (building cost information service)
- Slightly out of date (historical data)
- Data from tenders NOT achieved (competitive?)
- BCIS unable to capture specific designs
South Acton Residual
Why did you use residual valuation, and not a development appraisal?
- I wanted the output to be land value, rather than profit
- Market based rather than client based inputs