Unit 6 Flashcards
chapter 8, 9, 13
why are experiments better than non experiments?
from experiments we can learn that altering one variable causes another variable to change (manipulate independent variable)
what is a straightforward manipulation?
operationalize independent variables using instructions and stimulus presentations (verbally, written form or video)
ex. in a study they worded job interviews feminine or masculine, it was discovered that women liked feminine and men liked masculine
ex. looking at pictures
what is high mundane realism?
whenever the tasks involved in a study mimic experiences and conditions present in everyday life
ex. looking at job interviews is more realistic to everyday life
what are staged manipulations?
series of events that occur during the experiment to manipulate the independent variable (can involve actors)
deception is often involved in staged manipulations
what are the two main reasons why staged manipulations are employed?
- researcher may be trying to create a certain psychological state in participants such as frustration, anger or temporary lowering of self esteem
- used to simulate situations that occur in the real world
what is a confederate?
introduced as a participant in the experiment but may be used to create a particular social situation or administer the independent variable
(an example of staging)
what is the difference between experimental realism and mundane realism?
the tasks in a study might not resemble real world experiences (low mundane realism) but can still engage participants in a meaningful way producing psychological experiences that are impactful (high experimental realism)
what are 3 considerations when manipulating the independent variable?
strength of the manipulation
cost of the manipulation
manipulation checks
it is a good idea to try to make the manipulation as strong as possible, why?
in order to have the levels of the independent variable maximally different while keeping everything else between the two groups the same (this will increase the chances that your results will reveal an effect of the independent variable on the dependent variable)
what is a manipulation check?
directly measures whether the manipulation of the independent variable was successful inducing the participants
provide evidence for the validity of your manipulation
can include self reports, behavioral measures or a physiological measure
examples of self report techniques or tools?
paper and pencil questionnaire
face to face interview
online questionnaire
when would a self report measure be used?
attitudes about something
intentions to do something
a persons values, self esteem, mood, anxiety, relationship satisfaction, personality traits
what are examples of behavioural techniques or tools?
audio or video recorder
eye tracker
electronic activated recorder
weight scale
still camera
when would behavioural measures be used?
self control (amount of ice cream eaten, length of persistence on boring task)
creativity (number of ideas generated per minute)
reaction time (speed of detecting a flashing light)
facial expression of emotion (coded photographs)
attention (eye tracker, number of hazards avoided in driving simulator)
liking (distance seated apart from someone)
efficacy of a bulimia intervention (weight gained or lost)
memory (number of items recalled)
generosity (amount of money donated)
what are examples of physiological techniques or tools?
GSR
EMG
ECG
EEG
blood analysis
saliva analysis
heart rate
breathing rate
blood pressure
MRI
fMRI
when would physiological measures be used?
stress (sweating from GSR, cortisol in saliva)
genetic marker for mental illness (blood analysis)
physical fitness (heart rate change during exercise)
size of amygdala or damage to hippocampus (MRI)
brain activation when looking at image of romantic partner (fMRI)
what are the two advantages to manipulation checks?
- used in an early pilot study and reveals your manipulation is not effective, you can change the procedures before running the actual experiment
- manipulation check is advantageous if the results show no effect of the independent variable on the dependent variable
what are considerations when measuring variables?
sensitivity
multiple measures
cost of measures
what is sensitivity?
ex. “do you like someone, yes or no” is less sensitive than asking “how much do you like someone on a scale of 1-7”
important for behavioral measures of performance
what is the ceiling effect?
when everyone does well, there wont be much variability in the scores and so the measure lacks sensitivity to detect differences
what is the floor effect?
when all the scores are low
what are multiple measures?
when researchers use multiple measures of the same variable (to avoid carry over effects present the important measure first and the less important ones later or counterbalance the order presenting the measures or rely on complete randomization of order)
what does it mean to set the stage?
prepare consent forms
explain to participants why the experiment is being conducted (might bend the truth a bit and tell them more generally your interest)
what does a good research design mean?
eliminating as many alternative explanations for the results as possible
ex. avoiding confounding variables
what are considerations for ensuring control?
controlling for participant expectations
controlling for experimenter expectations
what does controlling for participant expectations consist of?
demand characteristics
placebo effects
what is a demand characteristic?
any feature of a study that might inform participants of the study’s purpose and consequently affect their behaviour (participants who know the hypothesis tend to act in ways that confirmed it)
what is a way to control for demand characteristics?
use deception to mislead participants of the study
what are filler items?
a set of unrelated items that disguise the dependent measure by using an unobstructive measure
when are demand characteristics eliminated?
when people are not aware that an experiment is taking place or that their behaviour is being observed
in a drug study if the placebo group improves as much as the experimental group, what does that mean?
the improvement observed due to the experimental drug is likely just a placebo effect
what is an example of a balanced placebo design?
theres 4 groups to study nicotine
1. given nicotine and told nicotine
2. given no nicotine and told no nicotine
3. given nicotine and told no nicotine
4. given no nicotine and told nicotine
what is experimenter bias/ experimenter expectancy effect?
when experimenters are aware of the purpose of the study and likely have expectations about how participants should respond, these expectations can bias the results
what are the two potential sources of experimenter bias?
- experimenter might unintentionally treat participants differently depending on what condition they are in
- when experimenters record participants behaviours with subtle differences emerging in how the experimenter interprets and records behaviours for people in different conditions
what are examples of research on expectancy effects?
ex. clever hans, a horse that could do math (really the experimenter was giving the horse subtle cues)
ex. participants were told that the study would cause them to walk fast or slow, this unintentionally influenced participants responses
what are solutions to the expectancy problem?
- run everyone in all conditions simultaneously so that the experimenters behaviour is exactly the same for all participants
- use experimenters who are unaware of the hypothesis (double blind) (single blind is only when participants dont know)
what are two decisions that must be made before applying for ethics approval?
participant selection process
debriefing procedures (explain the ethical and educational implications of the study verbally or written)
what is funnelled debriefing?
questions asked to the participants that begin broadly but then narrow in on the key deception
what are two issues to keep in mind when collecting data?
whether to complete a pilot study
the commitments that researchers have to the participants (contracts with participants)
when is a pilot study conducted?
when procedures are costly or when there will be only a single opportunity to collect data researchers might run a pilot study
what is a pilot study?
trial run with a small number of participants to test out the procedures (must be included in ethics application)
what occurs after data have been collected?
analyze data then write a report that details why you conducted the research (professional conferences, journal articles)i
what are the 8 steps in the experimental design?
- develop a theory
- review the literature
- generate a testable hypothesis
- define your variables
- identify and sample your population
- assign the sample to experimental and control groups
- run the study
- analyze your findings and then report them
what is a directional hypotheses?
specify precisely the outcome of any research project
the results from the population that is exposed to the independent variable (μ1) will be smaller or larger (directional) than the results from the population that is not exposed to the independent variable (μ2)
ex. group Z will score significantly higher than group T
ex. social media will increase grades
if the results from the population that is exposed to the independent variable (μ1) is smaller (directional) than the results from the population that is not exposed to the independent variable (μ2), how is this represented?
Ha: μ1 < μ2
or
H1: μ1>μ2
if the results from the population that is exposed to the independent variable (μ1) is larger (directional) than the results from the population that is not exposed to the independent variable (μ2), how is this represented?
Ha: μ1>μ2
or
H1: μ1>μ2
what is a nondirectional hypothesis?
do not precisely specify the outcome of a research project
ex. group Z scores will differ significantly from the scores of group T
ex. social media will affect grades
if you plan to perform statistical procedures with the data you gather, you must develop statistical hypothesis, what is that?
created by simply restating the research hypotheses into two distinct statistical hypothesis (H1 and H0)
what does the null hypothesis state?
independent variable will have no effect on the dependent variable (μ1=μ2) or no effect in the population (r=0.00)
ex. estrogen will not reduce bone loss
what is the alternative research hypothesis state?
states that independent variable does have some effect on the dependent variable (μ1 ≠ μ2)
ex. estrogen will reduce bone loss
what is the independent variable?
variable that the experimenter has control over (required in order to make a causal inference or cause and effect statement)
what does it mean that as we change the independent variable the dependent variable must change in some predictable fashion as well? example
ex. independent variable (pain medication) on the dependent variable (joint pain)
when we manipulate te independent variable (give more or less meds) pain perception increases or decreases)
what is a population? what is population mean denoted as?
complete group of people or events that are of interest to the researcher
pop mean: μ
what is a sample?
group that is selected to represent the population
what does the simplest possible experimental design have?
two variables: independent (experimental and control group) and a dependent variable
what is an experimental group?
the group of participants that will be exposed to the manipulation of the independent variable
what is the control group?
group that undergoes the exact same experimental procedure as the experimental group except the independent variable is not manipulated
also called placebo or sugar pill group
why is the control group important?
because it helps to ensure that any causal inferences we make regarding our findings are accurate since the control group helps to eliminate all other possible explanations for the observed relationship
what is a confounding variable?
an uncontrolled variable that is unintentionally allowed to disrupt the results of a study
(variable not of interest to the researcher that changes along with the independent variable and could provide an explanation for the results observed)
what are the two frequent forms of bias?
demand characteristics
experimenter bias
what are demand characteristics?
cues or features within an experiment that may lead participants to respond in a particular fashion
ex. if a participant knew or thought they were getting alcohol they may act drunk
what is the good participant effect?
when participants behave in a manner that they perceive the experimenter wants them to behave in