Unit 3 - Criminal Law Pt. 4 Flashcards
Intent of the Youth Justice System
- To prevent youth crime by addressing the underlying circumstances of a young persons’ offending behaviour
- To rehabilitate + reintegrate youth offenders
- To ensure that youth are subject to meaningful consequences for criminal behaviour
1984 - Youth Offenders Act (YOA)
- Criminal proceedings similar to full court trials
- Provided new ways of dealing w/ “at risk” youth through sentencing that would address the ‘underlying causes of crime’
- More safeguards for youth against ppl in positions of authority
Reports from Youth Justice Strategy (1998) & Summit on Justice (1999)
Recommended changes:
- Prevention
- Meaningful consequences
Harsher punishment for violent repeat offenders
Key recs.
- Lowering age of responsibility
- Holding parents accountable
- Use of incarnation as last resort
- Alt. measures as sentences
Youth Criminal Justice Act (2004):
4 Main Principles
- Prevention by addressing causes of crime + Encourages community effort to reduce crime
- Meaningful consequences to hold all youth offenders accountable
a. To help them understand the implication of the harm they’ve caused - Rehabilitation + reintegration into society
- Flexibility for provinces to establish youth Justice policies that best meet their local needs
Meaningful Consequences
- Address the crime
- Mean smth to the offender
- Reinforce respect for Cnd values
- Help fix the harm done
- Respect gender, ethnic, cultural, + language differences
- Involve family, community, other groups
- Respond to the needs + lives of Aboriginal your + youth w/ special requirements
Criminal Responsibility Age Groups
0-11 = NO responsibility
12-17 = PARTIAL responsibility
18+ = FULL responsibility
Major Changes w/ the YCJA
- Increased role for rehabilitation programs for non-violent, violent, repeat offenders
- Introduced stiffer sentences for violent offenders
a. eg. murder, manslaughter, aggravated sexual assault committed by 14+ yrs can have adult sentences - Hardships for Aboriginal offenders need to be considered when sentencing
- Equal to 1/2 of sentenced time in custody must be served in community as period of supervision
Rights Under the YCJA
- Rights to talk to a lawyer w/out delay at any stage of the proceedings
- Must be advised of this right upon arrest or detention, in any written notices, during any proceedings
- Must be given a reasonable opportunity to exercise this right - Right to consult w/ a parent or other adult upon request
- Cannot have their name or faces published
- Unless granted by a judge or the youth has been convicted of a serious violent crime + received an adult sentence
Extrajudicial Measures - Key Characteristics
- Allow for effective + timely interventions
- Should be used whenever they are adequate to hold young ppl
- Must be considered as an option by police before decision to lay charges
- Are presumed to be adequate to hold 1st time non-violent offenders accountable
- May be used even if they have been used w/ the youth before
- May be used even if the youth has previously been found guilty of a crime
Extrajudicial Measures - EXAMPLES
- Taking no further action
- Warnings
- Cautions
- Referrals to community agencies w/ the consent of the youth
Extrajudicial Allowings
Most formal type of extrajudicial measures
EXAMPLES:
- Restitution
- Compensation
- Counseling
- Treatment
- Community service work
- Mediation
Youth Sentences - Intent
- Hold young ppl accountable for their actions
- Utilize just sanctions that ensure meaningful consequences
- Promote the youth’s rehabilitation + reintergration
Restorative Justice
Those who are involved in the crime – victims, victims’ families, youth who offend, the community – are encouraged to reconcile, restore, + repair relationships + situations.
Non-Custodial Options
- Fine
- Community service
- Probation
- Attendance order for specific program
Non-Custodial Orders are forbidden unless young person has:
- Committed a violent offence OR
- Committed a serious offence OR
- Failed to comply w/ non-custodial order OR
- Committed a serious offence + there are other aggravating factors