Unit 3 AOS 1: Key Knowledge Flashcards
Aims of States
- To achieve its national interests (national security, economic prosperity, regional relationships, international standing)
- To maintain its sovereignty
Roles of States
To meet the needs of citizens and provide:
- Security
- Freedom
- Order
- Justice
- Welfare
Fragile states: do not provide for their citizens
Power of States
- Its sovereignty (its authority over its borders free from external interference)
- Can be military, economic, political, diplomatic, cultural
Aims of the UN
- Maintain international peace and security
- To recognise, promote and uphold the fundamental human rights of all people
- To develop friendly relations among nations on principles of equal rights and self determination
- Help facilitate international cooperation in the spheres of social, economic and cultural development
Roles of the UN
- Maintaining peace through mediation and arbitration of disputes (ICJ), deployment of peacekeeping forces, authorizing military action or sanctions (UNSC)
- Provide funding, personnel and resources to address global issues like poverty (WFP), education, human rights, cultural and social development and protection (UNESCO), refugees (UNHCR), etc
- Facilitating dialogue and open, transparent discussion between states on issues of mutual concern (UNGA)
Powers of the UN
- United Nations Security Council (UNSC) can issue binding resolutions on member states
- Establishing peacekeeping operations, deploy peacekeepers to conflict zones
- Enacting GA resolutions to provide consensus on global issues
- Article 42 of the Charter permits “any action… as may be necessary to restore international peace or security
Limitations to powers of the UN
- Veto power of the P5 members of the UNSC
- Relies on member states for soldiers and funding
- GA resolutions are non-binding
- UN must respect the sovereignty of member-states, and relies on them to enforce sanctions and ratify treaties
- ICJ rulings can be refunded
Aims of the IMF
- Reduce global poverty
- Promote economic growth
- Ensure the stability of the international monetary system (system of exchange rates and international payments that enables countries to transact with each other)
- To provide resources to member states experiencing balance of payment difficulties
Roles of the IMF
- Capacity development: providing assistance, policy advice and training
- Conditional lending to member states who are struggling with balance-of-payment difficulties
- Overseeing economic development through economic surveillance
Powers of the IMF
- Can provide states hit by crises with financial support to create breathing room as they implement adjustment policies to restore economic stability and growth
- Can provide precautionary financing advice to help prevent economic crisis
- Conditional nature of loans
Limitations to power of IMF
- Voting power in the IMF corresponds to the amount of money a state contributes (results in disparate levels of influence within the organisation)
- Role in surveillance can only be effective if states are willing to implement its suggestions
- The IMF have a ‘one size fits all’ approach to economic policy (fails to take into account different types of economies)
Aims of the ICC
- To hold those responsible for the worst atrocities (eg. genocide, war crimes, crimes against humanity) accountable for their crimes
- Assist national judiciaries in investigating and prosecuting the worst perpetrators
- Help promote international peace and security by deterring future would-be perpetrator
Roles of the ICC
- Investigates and prosecutes those responsible for grave offenses such as genocide and war crimes
- Provides justice for victims of the worst atrocities by providing rehabilitation and court-ordered reparations (through the Trust Fund for Victims – 80,000 current beneficiaries)
- Offers assistance to countries with underdeveloped judicial institutions
- To act as a court of last resort that can bring to account those charged with atrocity crimes
- To deter would be criminals from committing atrocity crimes and offer rehabilitation to those found guilt
Powers of the ICC
- Can exercise its jurisdiction within the bounds of the 123 states that have ratified the Rome Statue
- ICC can enforce a case from a non-member state if the individual is referred to them from the UNSC
Limitations to power of ICC
- Many states have not ratified the Rome Statute (including Russia, China and the US) – and a UNSC referral is unlikely
- The ICC relies on their member states to carry out arrests, and states cannot follow ICC commands.
- Only when national courts are unable or unwilling to properly deal with war crimes can the ICC step in to take over (complementarity)
- The court is not retroactive so it can only hear cases on matters that occurred after the Rome treaty entered into force
- If states renounce their participation in the Rome statute, the capacity to challenge sovereignty is limited
Criticisms:
- Established in 2002, during its 20-year tenure the court has only been able to achieve a mere 10 convictions and has heard 30 cases in total
- During its first twelve years, had only investigated and tried alleged war criminals from the African continent. By 2014, two warlords from Congo were the first convictions ever made by the ICC at the cost of over $1 billion