Unit 3 AOS 1: Global Actors Flashcards
What are International Organisations (IGOs)?
- they are global actors
- facilitate universal action
- independent from states
- e.g UN, ICC, WTO, IMF
What do IGOs do?
- Establish and facilitate relations between states
- Enable discussions that follow established processes and protocols
- Maintain a legal standing on the world stage
- Foster a capacity of action
- Challenge state sovereignty: through global governance
- IGOs have certain rights and obligations to its members
What do IGOs look like?
- Made up of member states - by joining they grant authority to the IGO and agree to follow protocols - this is what the USA has issues with…..
- Physical buildings
- Schedules of meetings
- Conferences
- Plenary bodies
Can IGOs can states limit their power?
YES - They can treat them as resources rather than solutions. If powerful states see no advantages in the agreements decided upon by the IGO, the IGO can be rendered powerless
BUT - IGOs are still powerful since the states act differently towards IGOs actions than they would with individual states
What is the International Monetray Fund?
The International Monetary Fund is a major financial agency of the United Nations, and an international financial institution, headquartered in Washington, D.C., consisting of 190 countries.
What are some facts about the IMF?
- IGO
- Created to ensure the stability of the international monetary system
- Founded as part of the Bretton Woods agreement
- Major global actor - provides framework for global economic cooperation
- Monitors exchange rates
- Washington DC headquarters
- Works alongside the World Bank ( who give loans for capital projects)
- North Korea,Liechtenstein, Andorra, Cuba, Monaco - all not members of IMF
- Kosovo is also part of the IMF (but not the UN - partially recognised state - it is confusing)
- Last member to join Nauru in 2016
- Promotes international money cooperation
What are the aims of the IMF?
- Promote international monetary cooperation
- Exchange rate stability
- Facilitate the balanced growth and expansion of international trade
- Establish a multilateral system of payments
- Make resources available to members experiencing payment difficulties
What does IMF actually do?
- Keeps track of the global economy and the economy of its member states. They look out for risks to economic stability and advises on needed policy adjustments eg. Vietnam
- Provides loans (short-medium term) - funded by member contributions. This can help them stabilize their currencies, continue to pay for import etc. Eg. Ireland
- Works with governments to modernise economic policies and organisations and train people - in turn this helps strengthen economies, promote growth and create jobs eg. Columbia
What is the quotas of the IMF?
- They are based broadly on the relative size of the member in relation to the world economy
- Each member’s quota determines its maximum financial commitment to the IMF
- It also determines its voting power
- It impacts its access to IMF financing should it need it
What is the voting like in the IMF?
- Important decisions require a special majority - 85% of votes
- USA holds 17% of voting rights which means they can VETO at the IMF and is the only single state able to do so
What are the three main functions of the IMF?
- Surveillance
- Technical Assistance
- Lending
How does the IMF get/exercise power?
- Via loans - IMF makes those who need loans make reforms. If they don’t make reforms, they withhold the funds. These reforms challenge a state’s sovereignty.
WHAT IS THE PROBLEM WITH THESE?????
- States can only use funds for the purposes of which they were lent
- Interest is applied to loans (0% to low income states)
- IMF has great economic power - direct threat to economic sovereignty of states
- The power of the IMF resides in its ability to dictate economic policy agendas to the member states that seek assistance from the IMF. Known as the ‘lender of last resort’, the IMF is an option that most states would prefer to avoid using.
- ‘Conditional loans’: limits on public spending, pressure for the privatisation of state-owned assets, the expedited implementation of trade liberalisation measures (cutting tariffs and/or subsidies), lowering budget deficits, increased taxation and greater oversight of the operation of government departments.
What are criticism of the IMF?
- Conditions placed on loans are too intrusive and compromise economic and political sovereignty of states
- Policies are passed down to states without any consideration to the fact that states have distinctive characteristics “blanket approach” - for some states, these conditions are difficult to carry out or are counter-productive resulting in more problems like food shortages. It should not be “one size fits all approach”
- Lack of sequencing of policies, imposed all at once eg. privatisation of utilities happens quickly without proper planning - often leads to unemployment - vicious cycle
- Lack of public scrutiny, lack of connection to real ground day to day in affected countries
What is the International Criminal Court?
- Based on a multilateral treaty (Rome Statute)
- Unlike the others we have studied, this IGO is young - took effect 2002
- Cannot look retrospectively - limitation here
- Cooperates with the UN but is independent from them
- Court of last resort : doesn’t replace national jurisdictions
- Compliments state judicial systems
- Only investigates and prosecutes when state is unable or unwilling
- Applies discretion in choosing cases: cannot handle all breeches of Int. law - Limitation??
- Tries PEOPLE
- ICC has jurisdiction in the territory of state parties and in other states if crimes are committed by nationals of state parties.
How does the ICC make arrests happen?
ICC needs cooperation from states. These states are the ones that make arrests, transfer people to the detention centre in The Hague, freeze suspects assets and enforce sentences as all of these things come under their jurisdiction.
What are the aims of the ICC?
- Ensure the worst perpetrators are held accountable for their crimes
- Serve as a court of last resort - they can investigate, prosecute and punish : perpetrators of genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes
- Assist national judiciaries in investigating and prosecuting the worst perpetrators. This allows the states to be the first to investigate and prosecute
- Help promote international peace and security - acting as a deterrent for would be perpetrators
What strategies are used in the ICC to achieve these aims?
- Have states sign on/ratify to follow its rules
- Relies on cooperation from states to arrest
- Investigates cases
- Uses the international community to pressure other states to cooperate
What is the role of the ICC?
- Deter would be criminals
- Offer rehabilitation to those who are found guilty
- Give a voice and justice to victims (can participate in proceedings and request reparations - $$$)
- To provide legal representation
- Offers measures of witness protection
- Educating the world
- Upholding international law
- Enforcing retribution
- Moral authority
- Defining international justice
What are the three bodies of the ICC?
- Assembly of state parties : state party reps, makes decisions on various issues, elects judges, prosecutors and deputy prosecutors
- The Court - 4 organs: Presidency (overall admin), Judicial divisions (18 judges, 3 divisions), Office of the Prosecutor (independent - conducts the investigations and brings cases before the court), Registry (admin, protection, outreach, maintains court records)
- Trust fund for victims: reparations for victims and families of victims of crimes within the jurisdiction of the court
What are the issues of the ICC?
- One of the roadblocks to the ICC potentially achieving its aims is that there is no mechanism for enforcement. - As a result, the ICC needs to rely on states for this - to pressure those who are non-compliant.
- They hope international pressure and rep. damage will be enough to make compliancy happen but this is not the case.
- State dissatisfaction - Burundi, Gambia, South Africa have all wanted out at one time or another