Unit 2 Flashcards
(70 cards)
An argument
A paper, grounded on logical, structured evidence, that attempts to convince the reader to accept an opinion, take some action, or do both. It doesn’t always involve conflict, but simply support a previous established decision or course of action
An argument represents
An opportunity to think things through, to gradually, and often tentatively, come to some conclusion, and then in stages begin to draft your position
An arguments foundation
solid logical support, and in addition many writers use emotion and ethical appeals
Rational Appeal
In society you are expected to reach your conclusion on the basis of good reasons and appropriate evidence. Reasons are the key points or general ideas you’ll use to defend your conclusions
Appealing in an agrument
Present your reasons and evidence in such a way that if your readers are reasonable they will likely agree with you.
Evidence Categories
-established truths
-opinions of authorities
-primary source information
-statistical findings
-personal experiences
Strong arguments combine several kinds of evidence
What are established truths
Facts that no one can seriously dispute
Examples of established truths
-Historical facts
-Scientific Facts
-Geographical Facts
Provide strong backup for argumentative postitions
Opinions of Authorities
An authority is a recognized expert in some field
Authoritative Opinions
The only kind to use, play a powerful role in winning readers over to your side.Always list their credentials and cite source information. Beware of authorities that are using biased opinions
Primary Source Information
Documents or material produced by individuals directly involved with the issue you are dealing with
Statistical Findings
Are data that shows how much, how many, and how often that will add support to your argument
- Comes from books, magazines, newspapers, handbooks, encyclopedias, and reports
- Are often misused and distrusted
- Recent data is better than old data
Personal Experience
An experience that can deliver an argumentative message more forcefully than any other kind of evidence. It does not replace other kinds of evidence because if the paper doesn’t have other support the reader will reject is as trivial
Evaluation of Evidence
After gathering evidence,certain standards govern the evaluation and use of the evidence. Your should not reach a conclusion on flimsy evidence
How to reach a reasonable conclusion and defend a position
- How credible are the sources of the information ? How reliable is the evidence?
- How much confirming evidence is there?
- How much contradictory evidence is there?
- How well established is the evidence?
- How well does the evidence actually support of fit the claim?
- What does the evidence actually allow you to conclude?
Reading Strategies
An argument consists of a conclusion you want to support, your reasons for that conclusion, and evidence that supports your reasons
3 Rational Appeal strategies
- Induction
- Deduction
- Analogy
What is a Induction
An argument when a general claim is supported by specific evidence, whether its direct observations, statistical data, or scientific studies.
Induction
- Most conclusions are supported inductively.
- To prove something this way you must check every bit of evidence
- The greater the number of observation and the larger the population surveyed, the stronger the conclusion is supported
Types of organization for Induction
- may post some directions
- Suggest the consequence of the position
- raise a general question, evaluate evidence, then come to a conclusion
Induction: besides presenting evidence what two other important things do you need to do?
- Demonstrate the credibility of your evidence
2. Try to show how the evidence fits the conclution
What is Deduction
A process of argumentation that demonstrates how a specific conclusion follows logically from some initial premise about which people might agree
Options to organizing deduction
- Start with the position you want to prove
- Start with a question that will be answered with the argument
- Start with a synopsis of the argument
About deduction
- Give your statement and lead the audience throw the paper.
- Use examples, stories, and facts