Union and Its Territories Flashcards
Significance of Article 1
India i.e Bharat is a Union of States
This signifies that the country is named India and Bharat.
It states the political structure i.e Union of States
Union of States has been preferred to Federation of States as the Indian Federation is not the result of an agreement among states. They have no right to secede. The federation is a union because the union is indestructable.
Art 2
Admission or establishment of new states that are not part of the Union i.e External Readjustment
Art 3.
Formation or changes in existing states i.e Internal Readjustment.
Significance of 7th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1956
Lead to the creation of Zonal Councils to advise on matters of common interest. They have statutory origin. Total 5
North Easter Zonal Council is created by a different statute in 1971 (North East Council Act 1972
Process of Invoking Art 3
- Introduced in the Parliament with prior recommendation of the Prez
- Prez has to refer the same to the state legislature concerned for expressing its views within a specified period.
- Prez is not bound by the views of the state legislature and may either accept or reject.
Art 4
Laws made under Art 2 and 3 are not to be considered amendments
How did Hyderabad, Junagarh and Kashmir became a part of India?
- Hyderabad = Operation POLO police action
- Junagarh = Referendum
- Kashmir = Instrument of Accession.
Dhar and JVP Commission (1948)
Reorganisation of States on the basis of administrative convenience rather than linguistic.
Rejected language as the basis of reorganisation
Note: JN + SVP + Pattabhi Sitaramayya
Fasal Ali Commission 1953
Language as the basis of reorganisation
It rejected the theory of One Language one State
UT of Deli was redesignated as National Capital Territory in which amendment
69Th Constitutional Amendment Act 1991
Merits of reorganising states on linguistic lines?
Secular Mode
Better learning outcome
Unity in diversity
Broad based participation
Efficient Administration
Demerits of reorganising states on linguistic lines?
Regionalism
Sub Nationalism
Economic and Financial Stress
More recognition of languages
List of new state demands?
Uttar Pradesh : Bundelkand
Maharashtra : Vidharba
Bihar : Mithilanchal
West Bengal : Gorkhaland
Assam : Bodoland
Delhi as a State
Arguments for and against Delhi as a separate state?
- 69th Constitutional Amendment 1991 = Formation of legislative council
- Currently 2 crore people = need representation
- UN Report = most populous city by 2028
- Resolve issues of frequent tussle between govt the lg
Against :
1. Not national compulsion = politically inspired
2. National Capital = Interest of entire country
3. Institutions of national importance
4.
SC judgement that gives clarity on the role of LG in Delhi?
Govt of NCT of Delhi Vs Union of India Case 2018 :
1. LG does not have any independent decision making powers
2. Bound by the aid and advice of COM except for matters of police, public order and land.