towards a new political economy of religion Flashcards
Economic considerations have
grown in importance in the post-Cold War era.
iscal problems in minor economies can shake the foundations of
major international state systems.
There’s been a growing economization (marketization and commodification) of
religion
which theory supports the economization observation of religion
rational choice theory
creasing globalization of religious conflict relates to the new
global political economy
thesis
Taking into account macro-level changes in political economy is key to understanding current debates in the sociology of religion.
Marion Maddox and Nicolas de Bremond d’Ars are engaged in
unveiling the relationship between religion and economy.
what does Maddox draw from weber
capitalist ethic
what does bremonnd d’ars draw from weber
relationship between religious ethics and economy.
Maddox and de Bremond d’Ars on Religion and Economy align with what paradign
secularization
Maddox studied
Australian megachurches, redefined as ‘growth churches’.
maddox uses Ninian Smart’s seven dimensions of religion:
ritual, doctrine, myths, emotions, ethics, social life, and the material.
Maddox claims growth churches are ____ ____ which
‘capitalism’s cathedrals’, which ‘reproduce, naturalize, enlarge, enchant and, to some degree, civilize it.’
Maddox sees growth churches as similar to
global franchising businesses.
De Bremond d’Ars studied the
French ecumenical, mostly Catholic, movement Les Entrepreneurs et Dirigeants Chrétiens (Christian Entrepreneurs and Managers).
E. Nicolas de Bremond d’Ars analyzes how managers and lay Catholics in the movement aim to… what is the dillemia
overcome the ethical dilemmas of being religious businessmen.
Their dilemma is the contradiction between the Catholic value system and the managers’ role being bound to practical reasoning and instrumental rationality
The dual distribution of salvation goods between laymen (piety, charity) and priests (sacraments) creates
tensions in the lay fraternity. ○ The movement is structured around practical reasoning and business logic.
E. Nicolas de Bremond d’Ars use of Georg simmel
○ He explains its development using Georg Simmel’s concept of ‘religious sentiment’, which resides among non-religious businessmen in a fluid or diffuse kind of piety.
– This makes use of existing social forms of religion (fraternity), leading to an organizational amalgamation of Catholicism and capitalism
The September 2011 issue of Social Compass (58(3)) distinguishes four categories of scholarship on religion and economy:
- The damaging features of consumer culture on religion
- Consequences of Consumer Capitalism on the Religious Landscape
- growth religions
- religion welfare and neoliberal policy-making
○ 1. Damaging Features of Consumer Culture on Religion:
§ Consumerism is seen as shallow and hedonistic.
§ People lose their sense of tradition.
§ This approach has an inbuilt nostalgia.
Consequences of Consumer Capitalism on the Religious Landscape:
§ There is organizational decline of mainstream churches.
§ New religious and spiritual marketplaces flourish.
§ This resonates with contemporary theorizing on religious diversity.
Incorporates secularization and rational choice theory of religion.
Growth Religions:
§ Focuses on Pentecostalism and other thriving movements, including Hindu and Muslim movements.
§ These are seen as the winners of social transformations rooted in urbanization, globalization, and the loosening grip of Tradition.
§ Their theologies are often conservative and may contain elements of prosperity theology.
○ 4. Religion, Welfare and Neoliberal Policy-Making:
§ Faith-based movements and traditional Churches have gained strength in welfare provision.
§ Religions are seen as providers of social capital.
§ Linked to changes in welfare state policies from neoliberal economic and administrative trends.
§ This structuralist and institutionalist view focuses on political economy as the driver of social change.
Maddox’s Presentation: Fits the third category of focusing on growth religions
The explicit link between growth churches and consumer capitalism is emphasized.