The Rise of the New Right Flashcards
White, working class pro-war riots as evidence of the ‘silent majority’
-
Economic conservatism
- libertarianism
- Minimal federal intervention
- Free market
EVIDENCE
- Friedrich Hayek, The Road to Serfdom: ‘Economic control is not merely control of a sector of human life which can be separated from the rest. It is the control of the means of all our ends.
- Milton Friedman
Social conservatism
- Rejected interventionist gvt. - so rejected civil rights
- Wanted minimal welfare state
- Would not accept concessions to Communists, seemed a show of weakness of American values
EVIDENCE:
- Russell Kirk, 1953 ‘Political problems, at bottom, are religious and moral problems…Custom, convention, and old prescription are checks…upon man’s anarchic impulse.’
PRIMARY SOURCE: Barry Goldwater, ‘The Conscience of a Conservative’ (1960)
Conservative ‘revival?’ - evidence of conservatism early in the 60s
- ‘I find that America is a fundamentally conservative nation. The preponderant judgment of the American people, especially of the young people, is that the radical, or Liberal approach has not worked and is not working. They yearn for a return to Conservative principles.’
‘The laws of god…have no dateline.
- Barry Goldwater
—> sold 3 million copies by 1964
I+K on the New Left
‘Blessed with hindsight, we can better appreciate the significance of the ’60s Right. Conservatives began building a mass movement earlier than did the New Left. And they sustained morale and kept expanding their numbers for years after young radicals had splintered in various directions.’
What did the political landscape of America look like in 1945?
- liberal
- Expanded federal bureacracy after the war - implications: economic planning and welfare?
- ## Military reduction after the war
Were conservative ideals at odds with one-another?
Why did consiervatives avoid division?
- Libertarianism says that there needs to be constant innovation (in the market) but social conservatism says innovation can damage society
- Orange County, California: ‘culturally conservative’ but lived well due to military and aerospace industry federal funding in the area.
—> overcame these divisions, united by a fear of communism, religious decline, and by hatred of “creeping socialism”
C.f Frank Mayer
What was ‘creeping socialism’?
- ‘State regulatory agencies, strong labour unions, progressive income taxes, and civil rights laws all wrested control from employers, property owners, and local authorities.
Religious decline in the United States as a factor in the conservative revival
- 50% of Americans regular church goers
BUT
- declining religious participation in schools
- new stress on cultural tolerance meant dilution of conservative Christian values?
- fear of ‘Godless Communism’
EVIDENCE
- Engel vs. Vitale (1962) rules that no school could make children pray
George Wallace in response to Engel vs Vitale ruling (1962)
‘I don’t care what they say in Washington, we are going to keep right on praying and reading the Bible in the schools of Alabama’
Examples of conservative publications (3)
- The Freeman
- Human Events
- National Review
The National Review
- Founded in 1955 by William F. Buckley, Jr.
- anti communist
- Christian conservative
- Defence of free market
Aimed, according to I+K, to form a ‘fusionist’ right
Anti-left
Primary Source: Extract from the National Review on the Civil Rights Movement
- ‘the white community is so entitled because, for the time being, it is the advanced race.’
PRIMARY SOURCE: Extract from the National Review on libertarianism and non-interventionist government
- ‘We are…depriving private citizens of the protection of their property; of enjoining, under threat of federal armed power, the police power from preserving order in our communities.’ - Frank Meyer, 1963
John Birch Society (JBS)
- Founded by Robert Welch in 1958
- Feared ‘gigantic conspiracy to enslave mankind’ (Welch)
Activism
- Letter writing
- Billboards
- Alarmist literature
100 000 members by 1963
5% of public had sympathy for their radical stance
Wide appeal
EVIDENCE:
- Though many rejected JBS’s wilder ideas, Orange County, California, 38 chapters: professionals like doctors and dentists, congressman, housewives - not just crackpots
How did the New Right establish itself at universities?
ISI/YAF
Intercollegiate Society of Individualists
- In 1950s, ‘experimented with tactics the New Left would later make commonplace’
- Demonstrations, published in newspapers
EVIDENCE
- Protests in favour of House of Un-American Ideals Committee (that Left refused to like)
Young Americans for Freedom
- Established 1961, quickly gained 25 000 members
- ‘Sharon Statement’ written by young conservative M. Stanton Evans
- Journal, The New Guard
How did conservative student activism differ from the New Left?
- ‘…campus conservatives [worked at] the lectern and the party caucus rather than into the streets’
Religion and the New Right
- New right feared dilution/erosion of Christian principles
- Strong conservative scene at Catholic colleges such as Fordham
How did the Goldwater campaign 1964 affect the New Right?
‘The first effort that united all continents of the New Right was the campaign to elect Barry Goldwater president in 1964. The Campaign, conducted with crusading fervor, did more than anything else to make American conservatism a mass-phenomenon.
- March on July 4th drew 9000, including, so remembers one organiser, ‘college rebels looking for a cause’
- nationwide direct mail campaign for funding saw Goldwater receive more money than any other presidential candidate
‘transformed the New Right from a small, largely intellectual phenomenon into a huge grassroots force.’
5 states who traditionally voted democrat went republican
- Future leaders like Patrick Buchanan involved: ‘We were there on St. Crispin’s Day’ - Henry V, Act IV, III, 3202
Barry Goldwater’s conservative ideas
- ’ Extremism in the defence of liberty is no vice’
- Make social security voluntary
- sell off federally owned Tennessee Valley Authority
- Opposed nuclear test ban treaty
- Opposed civil rights legislation, that might force you to hire ‘incompetent’ workers
‘In your heart, you know he’s right’
Conservatism on the Sunbelt
- Advances after the 1964 Goldwater campaign
Reagan
- Had been liberal democrat, but hate for government regulation and communism moved him to right
- Campaigned for Goldwater in ‘64
- stress on ‘law and order’ worked well against Watts Riots, California Student’s Movement
- 1964, California voters overwhelmingly reject Rumford Act that would have made housing discrimination illegal. When supreme court tried to overturn that decision Regan capitalised by arguing individual liberties were being threatened
Distanced himself from radicals: ‘any members of the (John Birch) Society who support me will be buying my philosophy. I won’t be buying theirs.’
—> Reagan won by 1million votes against popular, liberal (though pro war) governor of eight years in California