The prime minister and cabinet - 3.3 Prime Minister and Executive - UK Government Flashcards
The Factors governing the prime minister’s selection of ministers
Ability & experience of individuals Establishing PMs authority Rewarding loyalty & conciliating rivals Maintaining a balance between party factions Diversity
Example of prime minister being limited in power to appoint, reshuffle and dismiss ministers
2010 coalition 5 cabinet ministers were the responsibility of Lib Dems
Ability & experience of individuals (factor governing the PMs selection of ministers)
Will always be ‘natural’ backbenchers (i.e. not suitable for government (being a minister)) due to talent or political view - could be too extreme
General ability is more important than knowledge of particular policy as departments are staffed by civil servants.
In case of leadership contest PM will usually include defeated rivals in government in recognition of their standing
Example of PM appointing defeated rivals from a leadership contest into government
John Major 1990 kept Douglas Hurd in Foreign office and offered Hesseltine choice of senior posts
Establishing a PMs authority (factor governing the PMs selection of ministers)
Incoming PM will want to stamp their authority on government
Example of PM stamping own authority on government
2016 Theresa May distanced herself from Cameron’s administration by sacking Osborne & 9 other senior ministers
Rewarding loyalty & conciliating rivals (factor governing the PMs selection of ministers)
Politically wise to occupy potentially troublesome MPs with senior posts
Example of prime minister rewarding loyalty by appointments
2001 Blair appointed committed supporters of New Labour - David Blunkett & Alan Milburn
Example of prime minister conciliating rivals with minister positions
Blair appointing Brown as chancellor
Maintaining a balance between party factions (factor governing the control PM has on minister selection)
In order to maintain party unity - need different ideological views
Example of PM appointing ministers with different ideological views
Theresa May had to include Brexiteers e.g. Boris Johnson & Liam Fox as well as Remainers such as Philip Hammond and Amber Rudd
Meeting expectations of diversity (factor governing the control of PM’s selection of ministers)
PMs must be careful to include women and ethnic minorities
Example of PM not including women - causing controversy
John Major 1990 cabinet included no women
Example of greater representation of ethnic-minority groups in recent years
Sajid Javid (Asian) has served under May and Cameron
Presidential government
An executive dominated by on individual. E.g. President in US
Presidential government UK
Cabinet is formally responsible for policy-making but argued that cabinet is not strongly dominated by Prime Minister. Increase in presidential government - leadership becoming much more personalised and PMs are more distant from & less dependent on traditional institutions