The Media Flashcards
What did Vir, Hall and Foye find about representations of nationality?
The BBC was seen to have a more Southern English bias, and more interest in its English viewers than the wider nations. Also, those living in the highlands feel under-represented in the media.
What did Mulhern say about representations of nationality?
Critical of the media portrayal of the Irish and says that the Irish are stereotyped in 2 ways: homesick and drinking bad Guinness, or too successful to be homesick. E.g. Mrs Brown.
What did Graham say about representations of Nationality?
The media can sometimes force other nationalities into programmes, leading to tokenism. Also, the portrayals of the Welsh as ‘thick’ e.g. in Gavin and Stacy.
What did Van Dijk find about traditional representations of ethnicity?
Ethnic groups are presented in 5 ways: criminals, abnormal, a threat, dependant, unimportant.
What did Nahdi find about traditional representations of ethnicity?
Portrayals of Muslims were particularly negative, often presented as strange or different.
What did Ligali find about changing representations of ethnicity?
The media has been accused of being institutionally racist due to less reporting incidences of murders of ethnic minority groups.
What did Husband and Hartman find about traditional representations of ethnicity?
Media sees ‘foreigners’ (especially black people) as inferior.
What did the Children Now -Fair Play study say about the traditional representations of ethnicity?
ethnic minorities are stereotyped in video games - 86% of heroes are white and 8/10 sport characters are black.
What did Malik find about changing representations of ethnicity?
Broadcasters are guilty of tokenism and stereotyping in the media. This is an issue as a result of a lack of Black and Asian people in positions of power within the media, e.g. channel 4. However, did note that ethnic minorities are increasingly more included.
What did Barker find about changing representations of ethnicity?
Eastenders can be seen to be changing the way ethnic minorities are presented in its storylines. There are now a range of asian and black characters that represent the demographic of London much better. However, soap operas have been criticised for stereotyping.
What did Hall find about changing representations of ethnicity?
‘The Whites of their eyes’. There has been a key shift from overt racism to inferential racism, which is where unconsciously the media refers to presumptions of certain ethnic groups, which allows stereotypes to be based on this.
What did Moghissi find about changing representations of ethnicity?
Muslims are huddled together in the media. Since 9/11 a moral panic has been created around Islam.
What did Billington find about traditional views of masculinity and femininity?
Men and women are presented very stereotypically in the media. Women are presented as subordinate, submissive and passive whereas men are presented as dominant, aggressive and heroes.
What did Milestone and Meyer find about traditional views of masculinity and femininity?
Dominant notions of essential gender differences and ideological representation of masculinities and femininities continue to perpetuate inequalities within the media.
What did Gauntlett find about traditional and changing views of masculinity and femininity?
Dominant notions of essential gender differences and ideological representation of masculinities and femininities continue to perpetuate inequalities within the media. In contemporary films, men often have a more sensitive and thoughtful side and women are presented as ‘tougher’. Additionally, found that magazines aimed at young women emphasised that women should be able to do their own thing and be themselves. Female pop stars, such as Lady GaGa, promoted financial and emotional independence through their lyrics. Also, in Friends, male and female representations have become more equal. However, this equality in the media has plateaued.
What did Easthorpe find about traditional and changing views of masculinity and femininity?
Many forms of media transmit the idea that masculinity is based on strength, aggression, competition and violence is biologically determined and therefore a natural goal for boys to achieve. 1980s saw a changing representation of masculinity, where men were presented as emotionally vulnerable, in touch with their emotions, treating women as equals, care about their appearance and active fatherhood is an experience worth having.
What did Tunstall say about traditional views of femininity
The media generally ignores the fact that women go out to work, instead focussing on their domestic, sexual and marital activities.
What did Tuchman examine about
argued the narrow range of roles for women lead to their ‘symbolic annihilation’ in the media. This refers to the idea where the media omit, trivialise or condemn certain groups that are not socially valued.
What did Ferguson find about traditional views of femininity?
‘Cult of femininity’ presented in women’s magazines.
What did Glascock find about traditional views of femininity?
Studies the idea that when portrayed as violent, men are more often portrayed as physically aggressive, whereas females more verbally aggressive. Found that these difference were also prominent behind the camera, where males predominate and was found related to on-camera demographics.
What did Westwood find about changing views of femininity?
Refers to ‘transgressive female roles’, women are presented in a way that means they are breaking hegemonic social and moral constraints/gender roles. This can be seen to empower women. They are being presented as norm breaking e.g. drinking and being sexually promiscuous.
What did Gill find about changing views of femininity?
The depiction of women has changed from women as passive objects of the male gaze, to women being more active, independent and sexually powerful.
What did Nairn find about traditional and changing representations of the upper class?
The media representation of the monarchy, they have been represented as a family that are ‘like us but not like us’ and the narrative of their lives is presented as a soap opera. Also states that the representation of the family reinforces a sense of national identity. Media representations of the upper class have been traditionally positive, but this has changed over years. For example, Prince Charles was meeting with politicians which journalists found inappropriate as the Royal Family are meant to be neutral.
What did Saunders say about traditional representation of the middle class?
Conspicuous consumption, the middle class are targeted by corporate companies.
What did Mertens and D’Haenes say about traditional representation of the middle class?
The digital divide, the middle class use technology for career development and knowledge, whereas the working class use it for entertainment.
What did Leech say about traditional representation of the middle class?
The middle class are presented as the ‘ideal’ lifestyle in the media and advertising developed the idea of the ‘cereal packet family’ to describe the image that is sold to us as desirable.
What did Reiner say about changing representations of the upper class?
Recent media representations of wealthy people are being used to show examples of hard work, success and meritocracy. The media states that their successes are celebrated by the media and audiences are encouraged to identify with a culture of consumption and materialism. (think about what Neo-Marxists would say).
What did Giddens say about changing representations of the upper class?
There are three types of upper class: traditional upper class, entrepreneurial super rich and jet-set pop aristocracy.
What did Newman say about traditional representations of the working class?
In the media, the working class are stereotyped and labelled in an unflattering and pitying light. News stories tend to label the working class as being a problem in society, creating moral panics.
What did Devereux say about traditional representations of the working class?
Portrayals of the working class are divided into two categories: positive = seen as happy and a deserving poor, negative = welfare benefits.
What did Jones say about traditional representations of the working class?
‘Chavs: The Demonization of the Working Class’. ‘Chavtainment’ when the media negatively portrays the working class.
What did Dodd and Dodd say about changing representations of the working class?
Examined Eastenders and suggested that the show presents a traditional notion of working class communities, but that this does not reflect a modern day working class culture. However, the show has introduced realism when approaching severe issues such as rape and drug abuse.
What did Price say about changing representations of the underclass?
Developed the concept of ‘poverty porn’ to describe shows like Benefits Street. This refers to the idea of the media exploiting the participants and their lifestyles in order to shock and entertain audiences. Carried out discourse analysis and found that Benefit Street does have narratives that present people as decent and compassionate captured by an unfair society.
What did Baumberg et al find about traditional representations of the underclass?
Found common language used to describe benefits as ‘undeserving’: fraud and dishonesty, dependency, lack of effort, outsider status. Also found a disproportionate focus on benefit fraud.
What did Golding and Middleton say about the underclass?
Examined the notion of moral panics surrounding the underclass - carried out content analysis and discovered that welfare issues were not discussed unless they were linked to other social issues, such as crime, fraud or sex.
What did Hall find about traditional representations of the working class?
Whatever the intended meaning of certain forms of media is, they will be interpreted differently based on how people use their own values and views to decode it.
What did Heintz-Knowles say about traditional representations of childhood?
The media tends to portray stereotypical views of children:
Children are motivated by peer relationships and romance
Entertainment hardly shows children grappling with important issues
Anti-social behaviour
Minority ethnic groups are under-represented
Girls are twice as likely than boys to show affection
Boys are more likely to use physical aggression
What did Heinzt-Knowles say about changing representations of childhood?
TV dramas now show a more realistic portrayal of issues from a child’s point of view e.g. Tracy Beaker.
What did Postman say about changing representations of childhood?
The idea of childhood has begun to disappear as children interact more with the media. He argues that children are sexualised in the media and it creates a world where adults and children share the same sports, music, language and literature. The internet contributes to this and causes children and youths to be exposed to adult content.
What did Griffin say about traditional representations of youth?
The media portray youths negatively and portray them as a social problem in three ways:
Dysfunctional, deviant and suffering a deficit.
What did Wayne say about traditional representations of youth?
82% of 286 stories focussed on young people as either perpetrators or victims of crime. Wayne argues that the media ignores stories about how young people are affected by problems in housing, education, health, unemployment, parental abuse and politics.
What did the Women in Journalism study find about traditional representations of youth?
‘Hoodies or Altar Boys’. Found:
Negative language used to describe them e.g. thugs
More stories about teens and crime than any other topic
Few stories about teen boys in good light
Reality Tv was seen to portray them more fairly
Teenagers were wary of other teenagers.
What did Kelly say about traditional representations of youth?
3 major types of representation: dangerous, need of protection and immature.