the interactionist approach Flashcards
interaction
interaction between biology and the environment
original diathesis-stress model for SZ
meehl (1962) - vulnerability and stress trigger necessary for development of SZ
-schizogene
-environmental (schizophrenic mother)
-those without schizogene won’t develop SZ (both must be present)
modern diathesis-stress model
-no single SZ gene (polygenic)
-vulnerability can be environmental and genetic
-read et al (2001) early traumatic events can alter the developing brain (more vulnerable to later stress)
modern understanding of stress
Houston et al (2008) says many factors can risk triggering SZ
-biggest factor is THC-rich cannabis (increase by 7x - interfere with dopamine)
evaluation
living in urban areas can double the risk compared to rural
-unknown why (stress or people with diathesis for SZ more likely to move to the city)
treatment
-antipsychotic often used with CBT (acknowledging role of biology and environment)
-combining treatment more common in Uk than USA (healthcare systems)
-even if cause of SZ is biological, CBT can relive psychological symptoms
supporting evidence for vulnerability and triggers
point - Tienari (2004) followed 19,000 Finnish adopted children (high vulnerability) and compared to controls (low vulnerability)
evidence - children with high vulnerability more likely to develop SZ (suggests its genetic)
-also in a household with low empathy and critical
explain - supports diathesis model (genetic only led to SZ with environment)
supporting evidence for interaction between environment and biology
point - Tarrier (2004) randomly allocated 315 patients into 3 groups
evidence - group 1 (medication + CBT), group 2 (medication + counselling), group 3 (controls - only medication)
explain - patients treated with drugs and CBT had lower symptoms than those only taking drugs (SZ is biological + environmental)
simplistic model
point - original model is too simplistic
evidence - SZ is aetiologically heterogeneous
-SZ is polygenic (108 genes)
-Houston (2008) environmental factors can trigger SZ (cannabis, family dysfunction, trauma)
explain - theory been through multiple revisions (supports latest version of there being multiple triggers + causes)