The Bar--Criminal Law and Criminal Procedure Flashcards
When can an omission be a voluntary act?
You need 3 things: 1. legal duty to act by-- Statute Contract Status Relationship Voluntary assumption of care Creation of the Peril
- knowledge of facts that give rise to duty
- ability to help
Specific Intent
Desire/Intent to achieve a specific result
What are the (11) specific intent crimes
assault 1st degree premeditated murder larceny embezzlement false pretenses robbery forgery burglary solicitation conspiracy attempt
AMBLESCARFF–
Which defenses are available ONLY to specific intent crimes?
Voluntary Intoxication
Mistake of Fact
Malice (and the Malice Crimes)
Acting intentionally or with reckless disregard of an obvious or known risk.
(Murder, Arson)
General Attempt (and the General Attempt Crimes)
The defendant is generally aware of the factors constituting the crime, but need not intend a specific result)
Battery, Forcible Rape, False Imprisonment, Kidnapping
Strict Liability
No mental state needed
Crimes against public welfare, Statutory Rape
MPC Mental States
Purpose, Knowledge, Recklessness, Negligence, SL
Purpose (MPC mens rea)
with conscious desire to achieve a particular result
Knowledge (MPC mens rea)
aware of what he is doing—when D is aware that it is practically certain that his conduct will cause the result
Recklessness (MPC mens rea)
aware of substantial and unjustifiable risk but consciously disregards that risk
Negligence
D should have been aware of substantial and unjustifiable risk
Accelerating Cause
Where one action accelerates the result, that counts as an actual cause even tho but for that action the same result would have occured
Concurrence Principle
D must have the required mental state at the same time in which he engages in the culpable act (see exceptions–larceny)
Battery–elements
the unlawful application of force to another resulting in either bodily injury or offensive touching (general intent)
Assault
attempted battery; or
the intentional creation other than by mere words of a reasonable apprehension in the mind of the victim of imminent bodily harm (specific intent)
Murder (and 4 ways to satisfy mens rea)
the unlawful killing of another person with malice aforethought–
mental state satisfied in 4 ways:
Malice Aforethought–with intent to kill or cause serious bodily harm;
depraved heart (extreme reckless indifference to human life)
felony murder–during commission of inherently dangerous felony.
deadly weapon rule
intentional use of deadly weapon crates an inference of intent to kill
transferred intent rule
intent fulfilled–when D intends to harm one victim but accidentally harms a different one (applies to murder, battery, and arson) (cannot apply to attempts)
First v. Second Degree Murder
First: any intentional killing committed with premeditation and deliberation (cool collected)
Second: all other, plus depraved heart murder
Felony Murder and its common limitations
any killing caused during commission or attempt to commit a felony
1- D must have committed felony 2-felony is inherently dangerous 3. merger rule 4-killing took place during felony or immediate flight there from 4. foreseeable 5. victim was not a co-felon
Proximate Cause Theory of Vicarious Liability for Felony Murder
Co-felons are guilty of felony murder even where killing caused by third party
Agency theory of vicarious liability for felony murder
co-felons guilty of felony murder only where killing is committed a co-felon
Voluntary Manslaughter
A killing that would otherwise be murder, committed in the heat of passion upon adequate provocation
(needs—obj and subj provication, no time to cool off, no actual cooling off)
Involuntary Manslaughter
A killing committed during commission of crime to which felony murder doctrine does not apply OR unintentional killing committed with criminal negligence or recklessness
False Imprisonment-criminal
the unlawful confinement of a person w/o their consent (general intent)
Kidnapping
False imprisonment that involves moving or concealing the victim in a secret place (general intent)
Forcible rape
sexual intercourse w/o consent accomplished by force, threat of force, or when victim is unconscious (general intent)
Stat Rape
sexual intercourse with someone under age of consent (SL–but MPC reasonable mistake of age defence)
Larceny
A trespassatory taking and carrying away the person property of another with the intent to permanently retain the property.
(erroneous takings rule–a taking under claim of right is never larceny even if D is erroneous in belief that it is his)
Embezzlement
conversion of the personal property of another by a person already in a lawful possession of that property with the intent to defraud (specific intent to defraud)
False Pretences
obtaining title (not just custody) to the personally property of another by a false statement made knowingly with the intent to defraud
just custody–larceny by trick
Larceny by Trick
where defendant obtains custody (not title) as a result of a false statement
title? false pretences
Robbery
a larceny from someone’s person or presence by force or threat of immediate injury
specific intent to steal
Forgery
making or altering a writing so that it is false (specific intent to defraud)
Burglary
Breaking and entering the dwelling o another at night with intent to commit a felony inside
Arson
malicious burning of the dwelling of another
scorching is not enough but charring is
Jurisdiction
crime may be prosecuted in any state where an act that was party of the crime took place; or the result took place
Burden of Proof
In criminal cases–P must prove Every element BRD—so you CANNOT instruct the jury to presume that the required mental state exists if D committed act
When can an omission by the basis for criminal liability?
- Legal Duty to Act—(6 ways)
- Knowledge of Facts giving rise to the duty
- Ability to help
What 6 duties give rise to affirmative need to act such that omission could give rise to criminal liability?
- by statute (tax returns, professionals etc)
- by contract (baby sitter, doctor)
- by status relationship between D and V
- *** Parent/Child, Spouse/Spouse
- By voluntary assumption of care (D starts rescuing)
- by creation of the peril
Possession of Contraband
Possession= control for a period of time long enough to have opportunity to terminate possession
(need not be in actual possession–constructive is OK)
with knowledge of the possession and character of item
Receipt of Stolen Propery
Act: Receiving possession and control of stolen personal property. (if it was stolen and recovered from police in sting, it is not stolen for the purposes of this crime)
mens rea: Knowing that property has been obtained criminally by another party and with intent to permantnetly deprive the owner’s interest in property
Accomplice
The person who helps principal is an accomplice:
Act: aids or encourages principal
Mens rea: intent to assist the principal and with the intent that the underlying crime be committed.
** if the principal’s crime requires a mental state of recklessness or criminal (gross negligence) most jurisdictions hold an accomplice liable for intentional conduct that aids the principal and manifests the required recklessness or negligence.
**mere presence at scene is not enough. mere knowledge of crime is not enough.
Scope of accomplice liability?
Accomplice is liable for all crimes he aided or encouraged, and all foreseeable crimes committed along with aided crime.
Withdrawal of an Accomplice
for an encourager: repudiating the encouragement before crime is committed
aider: neutralize or prevent (notify authorities)
Corporate Liability
Corp agent engages in criminal conduct, corp and agent may be held liable where agent acted on behalf of corp and w/in scope of his office
when corp is liable for regulation offense–agents can be liable where they stand in responsible relation to situation causing danger