SU 3 - Proficiency & Due Professional Care Flashcards
The level of proficiency needed to perform the internal audit activity.
Skills
The knowledge, skills, and other competencies required of internal auditors to effectively carry out their professional responsibilities.
Proficiency
The collective knowledge, skills, abilities, and personal attributes that can lead to exceptional performance.
Competencies
Comprehending the objectives and scope of the engagement, as well as the competencies that will be required to execute the audit work and any policies and procedures specific to the internal audit activity and the organization.
Due professional care
The body of information necessary to perform the internal audit activity.
Knowledge
The means by which members of a profession maintain, improve, and broaden the knowledge, skills, and competence required in their professional lives.
Continues professional development
The systematic measurement of characteristics such as education and experience that results in recognition of an individual as one who meets the suggested knowledge and other minimum requirements for a position or a profession.
Certification
One of the most important staffing responsibilities a chief audit executive (CAE) may handle alone or share with human resources is the development of retention strategies. Which would be the most appropriate and effective retention strategy among those listed?
a) Develop a single career path for all internal auditors, with the same deadlines for reaching each stage, from new auditor to staff auditor to auditor-in-charge and audit manager.
b) Develop, with each internal auditor, a schedule of training opportunities based upon the goals of the auditor and the objectives of the internal audit activity.
c) Provide internal auditors with bonuses based upon cost savings they achieve for the organization through their audit recommendations.
d) Ensure that each annual and post-audit review for auditors is predominantly positive.
b) Develop, with each internal auditor, a schedule of training opportunities based upon the goals of the auditor and the objectives of the internal audit activity.
Rationale
Training should generally challenge an auditor to acquire new competencies that fit with his or her goals and the objectives of the audit activity. This is implied in Implementation Guide 1230, which gives suggested activities to enjoin the CAE to attend to the professional development needs of the staff, including achievement of appropriate certifications. One-size-fits-all approaches to retention are likely to be inappropriate for some talented individuals, and not all internal auditors will have the same desire to advance through all career path stages. Compensation based upon cost savings rather than more-inclusive measures of performance may tempt internal auditors to adopt too narrow a focus in their audit practice. The CAE should include any relevant positive evaluations in a review, but not all reviews can appropriately be predominantly positive.
A chief audit executive (CAE) for a manufacturing company with 21 international facilities has developed a rotational audit plan to conduct seven assurance audits per year over a three-year cycle to provide adequate audit coverage for these facilities. Do the CAE’s actions demonstrate appropriate due professional care?
a) Yes, the CAE has the appropriate audit resources to provide such coverage.
b) Yes, the CAE has a solid rationale for selecting the timing of the audits.
c) No, performing rotational audits without regard to the risks or importance of the department is not in line with due professional care.
d) No, the CAE must obtain approval from the audit committee for the rotational audit plan.
c) No, performing rotational audits without regard to the risks or importance of the department is not in line with due professional care.
Rationale
An example of not exercising appropriate due professional care is performing rotational internal audits of each department in an organization without regard to the risks or importance of the department.
When assessing an internal auditor’s critical thinking skills, what should be the CAE’s primary consideration?
a) Whether the auditor made appropriate connections between the organization’s strategies and its external environment.
b) Whether the auditor reached sound conclusions based on disciplined thinking that is clear, rational, objective, open-minded, and informed by evidence.
c) Whether the auditor’s written, oral, and non-verbal communications were impactful.
d) Whether the auditor successfully helped management improve governance, risk management, and compliance.
b) Whether the auditor reached sound conclusions based on disciplined thinking that is clear, rational, objective, open-minded, and informed by evidence.
Rationale
Critical thinking competency is required to reach sound conclusions based on disciplined thinking that is clear, rational, objective, open-minded, and informed by evidence. Improvement and innovation competencies are required to help management improve governance, risk management, and compliance. Communication competency is required for impactful written, oral, and non-verbal communications. Business acumen competency is required to make appropriate connections between the organization’s strategies and its external environments.
A large manufacturing company with declining profits has placed a spending freeze on all external training. The audit department has 12 auditors at various levels of proficiency. What would be the best next step the chief audit executive (CAE) should take to provide staff training?
a) Have the auditors look for free training on the Internet, and allow them to take the training on company time.
b) Mandate that the individual auditors train each other in their off hours.
c) Take no action, since the resources are not available.
d) Discuss the matter with human resources, executive management, and/or the audit committee to identify possible alternatives.
d) Discuss the matter with human resources, executive management, and/or the audit committee to identify possible alternatives.
Rationale
Implementation Guide 1230, “Continuing Professional Development,” states, “The individual internal auditor is responsible for conforming to Standard 1230. This includes continuing their education to enhance and maintain their proficiency. Internal auditors need to stay informed about improvements and current developments in internal audit standards, procedures, and techniques, including The IIA’s International Professional Practices Framework (IPPF) guidance.”
Which would best be performed by an internal auditor with continuing professional education in accounting?
a) Looking for processing efficiencies for transactions placed in suspense accounts.
b) Determining the reasonableness of segregation of duties.
c) Assessing lease provisions.
d) Providing advice on accounting transactions.
a) Looking for processing efficiencies for transactions placed in suspense accounts.
Rationale
As internal audit functions strive to move up the maturity ladder, they must acquire or develop internal auditors with more advanced specialist accounting knowledge to leverage their skills to go beyond basic accounting; an example is looking for processing efficiencies for transactions placed in suspense accounts. Assessing lease provisions, determining the reasonableness of segregation of duties, and providing advice on accounting practices are examples of skills requiring the baseline knowledge of basic accounting principles expected of all internal auditors.
The most important reason for the chief audit executive to ensure that the internal audit department has adequate and sufficient resources is to
a) ensure that the function is adequately protected from outsourcing.
b) establish credibility with the audit committee and management.
c) demonstrate sufficient capability to meet the audit plan requirements.
d) fulfill the need for effective succession planning.
c) demonstrate sufficient capability to meet the audit plan requirements.
Rationale
Standard 2030 requires that internal audit resources be appropriate, sufficient, and effectively deployed to achieve the approved plan. As noted in interpretation of the standard, “Appropriate refers to the mix of knowledge, skills, and other competencies needed to perform the plan. Sufficient refers to the quantity of resources needed to accomplish the plan. Resources are effectively deployed when they are used in a way that optimizes the achievement of the approved plan.”
How should the IIA Global Internal Audit Competency Framework be used if it is to form a foundation that is equally useful to practitioners, line managers, HR professionals, trainers, and others?
a) Referred to properly as the ISO certification standard that it is
b) Considered as an industry-specific best practice
c) Treated in policy as a mandatory requirement
d) Considered as a guide
d) Considered as a guide
Rationale
Given the diversity of professional practice globally, there are practical difficulties in devising a framework that can be regarded as both fully comprehensive and universally applicable. As such, this framework should be used as a guide.
Internal auditors must be alert to the significant risks that might affect objectives, operations, or resources. What is the best first step an auditor would take to achieve this?
a) Read prior internal and external audit reports in order to gain an understanding of the risks associated with the operation.
b) Perform the necessary research on the nature of the operations to gain an understanding of the risks.
c) Perform necessary interviews with operating management to gain an understanding of the operations.
d) Review the organization’s policies and procedures on the audit.
b) Perform the necessary research on the nature of the operations to gain an understanding of the risks.
Rationale
Performing the necessary research on the nature of the operations to gain an understanding of the significant risks that might affect objectives, operations, or resources would enable the internal auditor to put the other choices into context prior to doing them, which is consistent with Performance Standard 2200, “Engagement Planning,” and the “Engagement Planning: Establishing Objectives and Scope” Practice Guide.
Which of the following would an internal auditor need to know first to be in line with due professional care principles for consulting engagements?
a) The organizational objectives for the consulting engagement
b) When to perform an engagement without supervision
c) The IIA’s Standards
d) How to provide objective comments about the proposed process or activity
c) The IIA’s Standards
Rationale
A working knowledge of The IIA’s Standards is needed before any consulting or assurance activity should be started.
Which of statements is true regarding due professional care?
a) Internal auditors are expected to be reasonably prudent.
b) Internal auditors are expected to provide qualified assurance that irregularities exist.
c) Internal auditors are expected to be infallible.
d) Internal auditors are expected to provide absolute assurance that noncompliance exists.
a) Internal auditors are expected to be reasonably prudent.
Rationale
Internal auditors must apply the care and skill expected of a reasonably prudent and competent internal auditor. Due professional care does not imply infallibility. Internal auditors are not expected to give absolute or qualified assurance that noncompliance or irregularities do not exist.
Which statement best describes the internal auditor’s responsibilities for fraud?
a) Internal auditors are required to evaluate the risk of fraud when performing financial engagements, and are expected to have specialized fraud training.
b) Internal auditors are required to evaluate the risk of fraud as a standard practice and are expected to have specialized fraud training.
c) Internal auditors are required to evaluate the risk of fraud as a standard practice and are not expected to have specialized fraud training.
d) Internal auditors are required to evaluate the risk of fraud when performing financial engagements, and are not expected to have the specialized fraud training.
c) Internal auditors are required to evaluate the risk of fraud as a standard practice and are not expected to have specialized fraud training.
Rationale
Internal auditors are expected to have sufficient knowledge to evaluate the risk of fraud and the manner in which it is managed in the organization, but are not expected to have the expertise of a person whose primary responsibility is detecting and investigating fraud. This applies to all types of engagements, not just financial engagements. Because fraud expertise is not expected, there is no expectation for all internal auditors to have continuing professional education in fraud.