Social Influence Flashcards
What are the three types of conformity:
Compliance
Identification
Internalisation
Define compliance:
Going along with others to gain their approval.
Define identification:
Going along with others in order to fit in with a group.
Define internalisation:
Going along with others due to an acceptance in their beliefs.
What are the two explanations of conformity?
Normative social influence
Informative social influence
Define normative social influence:
Going along with something because you want to gain approval and be liked.
What is informative social influence:
Going along with something because we believe the opinion of the majority.
In Asch’s experiment, the participant gave the wrong answer on ___% of critical trials.
37%
In Asch’s experiment, ___% of participants never conformed at all.
25%
In Asch’s experiment, ___% of participants conformed at least once.
75%
What are the three variation in Asch’s experiment?
- Group size
- Task difficulty
- Unanimity
In Asch’s experiment, explain the variation of group size:
- Increased the group size by adding more confederates
- Conformity increased with group size, with the rate of conformity remaining the same with 3+ confederates
- If the number of confederates was too large, the participants became suspicious.
In Asch’s experiment, explain the variation of unanimity:
- Found that if one confederate gave the correct answer, conformity dropped from 37% to 5%.
In Asch’s experiment, explain the variable of task difficulty:
The more difficult the task is the higher the rate of conformity. This is because participants assume the majority to be correct.
Name the four limitations of Asch’s experiment:
- Historical validity
- Artificial task and environment
- Limited application of findings (cross-cultural replications)
- Ethical issues
In Asch’s experiment explain the limitation of historical validity.
- Experiment lack historical validity
- Conducted in the 1950’s when the era was very conformist
- Perrin and Spencer repeated the experiment in the 1980’s and found that only 1/396 conformed
- Shows that experiment lacks historical validity as findings vary depending on how conformist the era is.
In Asch’s experiment explain the limitation of artificial situation and task:
- Lacks external validity as experiment was conducted in a lab = so results are generalised to that environment and will not necessarily be replicated in a real-life environment
-Experiment may have shown demand characteristics = so results are invalid
In Asch’s experiment explain the limitation of limited application of findings:
- Meta- analysis shows us that results cannot be applied to all cultures.
- They are unable to be cross-culturally replicated = collectivist cultures (e.g. japan) have higher rates of conformity compared to individualist cultures (e.g. USA)
- Gender differences - women were not included in the study = differences in conformity rates
In Asch’s experiment explain the limitation of ethical issues:
- Participants were decieved as they believed the confederates wee genuine people.
In Zimbardo’s experiment, what were the findings?
- At the start the guards were gentle and weary with the prisoners.
- Prisoners began to rebel, causing the guards to react harshly
- Guards constantly harassed the prisoners, administering rules and punishment
-After the rebellion stopped, prisoners became depressed and anxious - 2 prisoners left, 1 went on a hunger strike
- Both prisoners and guards identified with their social role at the end of the experiment
Name the two strengths in Zimbardos experiment:
- Control
- Experimental realism
In Zimbardo’s experiment, explain the strength of control:
- The experiment was highly controlled e.g. participants were randomly assigned their roles
In Zimbardo’s experiment explain the strength of experimental realism:
- Externally valid as it occurred in a highly realistic environment
- 90% of the conversations were about prison life
Name the three limitations in Zimbardo’s experiment:
- Personality factors
- Lack of research support
- Ethical issues
In Zimbardo’s experiment explain the limitation of personality factors:
- Zimbardo didn’t take personality into account with his findings
- 1/3 of the guards acted aggressive, 1/3 of the guards acted fairly, 1/3 of the guards acted nicely