Social Influence Flashcards
What are ethics?
The moral considerations that researchers have to make in the course of their research
What guidelines do psychologists work from?
The British Psychological Society guidelines
Ethics are used to ensure research doesn’t cause what type of harm?
- Psychologically
- Emotionally
- Physically
What are ethical guidelines?
Requirements set out by the BPS to be used by researchers to ensure their research is deemed as ethical
What are ethical issues?
The consequences of research that occur if research doesn’t meet ethical guidelines
What are the 8 ethical guidelines for the use of human research?
Brief
Consent
Confidentiality
Deception
Debrief
Protection of Participants
Privacy
Withdrawal
How do you remember the 8 guidelines?
BCCDDPPW
What does the ethical guideline ‘Brief’ mean?
When you let them know what’s going to happen
What does the ethical guideline ‘Consent’ mean?
An under 16 needs a parent/guardian
consent (gatekeepers)
What does the ethical guideline ‘Confidentiality’ mean?
Everything is said in private and their identity isn’t disclosed
What does the ethical guideline ‘Deception’ mean?
Not telling the truth - the participant is mislead
What does the ethical guideline ‘Debrief’ mean?
Discussing the results and possible deception
What does the ethical guideline ‘Protection of participants’ mean?
Participants leave the way they came - protect them during research
What does the ethical guideline ‘Privacy’ mean?
Participants shouldn’t be observed in their private life
What does the ethical guideline ‘Withdrawal’ mean?
Participants are allowed to leave research at any stage and their research is to be destroyed
What is social influence?
SI is the way that a person or group can affect the attitudes and behaviour of another individual or group
What are the 3 types of Social Influence?
Conformity
Obedience
Independent behaviour
What is conformity?
The tendency to change what we do (our behaviour) or think and say (attitudes) in response to the influence of others
What is the main aim of conformity?
That our behaviour meets with what the majority do
What are some examples of conformity?
Music taste
Fashion trends
Friendship groups
School rules
Laws
Who put forward the 3 types of society?
Kelman in 1958
Why were 3 types of society created by Kelman?
He argued that there were a variety of reasons as to why an individual will conform or not
So, conformity will change the social situation an individual is in
What are the 3 types of society Kelman suggested?
Compliance
Identification
Internalisation
Why do we conform?
To fit in with norms and society
No other choice
Expectation
Desire to fit in with others
Survival
To be deemed as normal
Become part of a group
To be included
What are the consequences of not conforming?
Punished physically/socially/emotionally
Unwanted attention
You get deemed a troublemaker
You get deemed as unruly
You get stereotyped unfairly
What are some real-life examples of compliance?
A school rule
Peer group likes and dislikes
What are some real-life examples of indentification?
Similar clothes as peers
Use of social media apps
Gender-specific behaviour
What are some real-life examples of internalisation?
Converting to a different religion
Adopting a new religion
Radicalisation
What is majority influence?
Where a larger group influences a minority to change their behaviour or attitude so that it fits with the majority and their ideal
What is the key research experiment for majority influence?
The Line Experiment
Who created the Line Experiment?
Asch (1950s)
What are the positives of the line experiment?
+ Lab experiment - variables are strictly controlled, meaning that replication of the experiment is easy
+ Large sample size - 123 pp
+ Supports NSI - pp reported that they conformed to fit in with the group, so it supports the idea of NI, which states that people conform to fit in when privately disagreeing with the majority
What are the negatives of the line experiment?
- Controlled condition - artificial environment
- Task lacks realism
- Ethical Issues = deception and psychological harm
- Gender bias - only used males
- Lacks universality - used white American undergraduate students
What are the three main variables that impacted conformity the most in Asch’s experiment?
Group size - the bigger the group size, the more confidence
The unanimity of majority- higher conformity when all the confederates gave the wrong answer
Task difficulty- the harder the task, the more conformity
How did group size affect Asch’s experiment?
- An individual is more likely to conform when in a larger group
- Evidence: There was low conformity with the group size of confederates were less than 3 - any more than 3 and the conformity rose by 30%
- Must be at least 3 to exert an influence, but an overwhelming majority is not needed in all instances to bring about
conformity
How did unanimity of majority affect Asch’s experiment?
- An individual is more likely to conform when the group is
unanimous i.e. all give the same answer, as opposed to them all giving
different answers - Evidence: When joined by another participant or disaffected confederate
who gave the correct answer, conformity fell from 32% to 5.5%. If different answers are given, it falls from 32% to 9%. - Link: Unanimity is vital in establishing a consistent majority view, which is
particularly important by providing normative social influence through
preventing any conflicting views arising.
How did task difficulty affect Asch’s experiment?
- An individual is more likely to conform when the task is difficult
- Evidence: Asch altered the (comparison) lines making them more similar in length. So, since it was harder to judge the
correct answer, conformity increased. - Evidence: When the task is difficult, we are more uncertain of our answer
so we look to others for confirmation. - Link: This suggests that informational social influence is a major mechanism for conformity when the situation is ambiguous and the individual does not have enough of their knowledge or information to
make an informed decision independently, and so has to look towards others.
What are the factors that affect levels of conformity?
Gender
Age
Social class
Situation
Difficulty level
Size of majority
Historical time era
Place/culture
Visual presence