Social Cognition Flashcards
Social psychology definition
The science of how human thought, feeling and behaviour is influenced by and have influence on other people
Thought
Internal language & symbols, often conscious
Cognition
Automatic, unaware of it
Social cognition
Approach that focuses on how cognition is affected by social contexts and how cognition affects our social behaviour
Impression formation - Asch’s (1946) configural model
· Intelligent · Skilful · Industrious · Warm or Cold · Determined · Practical · Cautious
- We use personality traits to describe people, form impressions
> > Asch (1946) Conducted a study where pp’s had to read the list on the left, including personality traits e.g.
> > One group either saw the list including the word warm and the other group read the list which included the word cold
> > Participants were then asked to rate the target person on a list of bipolar evaluative dimensions:
- Generous/ungenerous
- Happy/unhappy
- Reliable/unreliable
- Wise/unwise
Impression formation
> > Spend a large amount of time thinking and talking about other people
We make impressions of other people and use this to decide what we think about other people and how we act towards them
Asch (1964) findings
> > Those who saw the word warm made much nicer impressions of the hypothetical person - more likely to rate them more favourably
This model suggests that the terms warm/cold are central traits, thus these traits influence the meaning of other traits
Replication of Asch – Kelley (1950)
· ‘People who know him consider him to be a rather cold (or warm) person, industrious, critical, practical and determined’
- REPLICATION of Asch’s study
- Introduced a guest lecture to students with the following statement:
- ‘People who know him consider him to be a rather cold (or warm) person, industrious, critical, practical and determined’
- Half of pp’s recevied the word warm and another half heard cold
- After the lecture they were ask to rate the lecturer on a number of dimensions
Replication of Asch – Kelley (1950) findings
>> Those who received a cold trait rated the lecture as these traits: - Unsociable - Self-centred - Unpopular - Ruthless - Formal >> Students were more likely to rate negatively when the word ‘cold’ was used - Less likely to ask questions as well
Biases in forming impressions: Primacy and recency effects
- Primacy and recency effects highlight that the order in which things are presented too us is important and can have an effect
» Primacy effects – traits were more favourable when the positive traits were described first
» Recency effects – there was more concentration on the last traits when you don’t pay attention to the first ones
Biases in forming impressions: Primacy and recency effects - Asch (1946)
·
- Asch (1946)
» Used 6 traits to describe a hypothetical person
» He changed the order of the traits presented
» Positive words used first followed by negative, then this was reversed for other participants
· Intelligent
· Industrious
· Impulsive
· Critical
· Stubborn
· Envious
Recency effect - when the later information has more impact than the earlier information
Biases in forming impressions: Positivity and negativity - (Sears, 1983)
Generally we assume the best of others and therefore form positive impressions of people
Biases in forming impressions: Positivity and negativity - (Fiske, 1980)
However, if there is any negative information about someone -> this attracts our attention and we are biased towards negativity (Fiske, 1980)
- Likely to form a negative impression
Biases in forming impressions: Positivity and negativity - (Hamilton & Zanna, 1974)
Once this negative impression is formed, it is much more difficult to change, more resistant to change (Hamilton & Zanna, 1974) - even if positive information comes to light
» This is because the negative information tends to be more unusual and distinctive so it draws more attention
Why?
- Negative bias tends to be more unusual & distinctive – attracts attention - more likely to remeber this (Skowronski & Carlston, 1989)
- Evolutionary explanation - negative information indirectly signifies potential danger
- Detection of potential danger has survival value – evolutionary, detection value
Biases in forming impressions: Physical appearance
> > Research suggests that physical appearance sways our impressions of others
Helps us form impressions
Appearance is the first information we see - therefore very influential, primacy effects
Biases our impression formation
(Zebrowitz, & Collins, 1997) - Appearance-based impressions
- Appearance-based impressions can be surprisingly accurate! (Zebrowitz, & Collins, 1997)
- Observers’ ratings of people based purely on pictures of their offices and bedrooms demonstrated accuracy (Gosling, Ko, Mannarelli & Morris, 2002)
Impression formation bias - Physical attractiveness - (Dion et al., 1972)
- One of the earliest/most immediate appearance based judgments we make, is whether we find someone physically attractive
» Research has found that physically attractive people are – warm, good, interesting, socially skilled (Dion et al., 1972) - Research suggests this can influence workplace/ someones chance of getting a job > more attractive people are more likely to get a job
Impression formation bias - Physical attractiveness - (Knapp, 1978)
Professional men who are taller than 1.88m - receive 10% higher starting salary than men under this height
(Heilman, & Stopeck, 1985)
- Attractive male executives -> were considered more able than the less attractive male executives
HOWEVER - Attractive female executives -> were considered less able that the less attractive executives > Participants suspected that the attractive female executives were promoted because of their appearance
(Heilman, & Stopeck, 1985)
Biases in forming impressions: Stereotypes
> > Impressions we make of others are strongly influenced by certain stereotypes (shared assumptions) based on their group memberships e.g. ethnicity, sex, class
Stereotypes are - Widely shared and simplified images of a social group and its members
One of the salient characteristics of a person we meet is their category membership - this tends to engage in stereotype consistent information
Biases in forming impressions: Difficulty incorporating stereotype-inconsistent information (Haire, & Grunes, 1950)
> > Participants struggle to incorporate stereotype-inconsistent information (Haire, & Grunes, 1950)
People had NO difficulty writing a paragraph about a working man when they received stereotype consistent information
BUT »_space; When having to write a paragraph about a person - and include a piece of inconsistent information (Word ‘intelligent’ that opposes a stereotype) they struggled to write the paragraph on a working man, when they had to include this information
Stereotypes - Gilbert & Hixon (1991) - Activation Phase
> > Investigated the effects of cognitive business on the activation and application of cognitive stereotypes
- Activation Phase
Participants performed a word fragmentation completion task - whilst being exposed to either Caucasian or Asian assistant who was turning over 19 cards
Cards included words that could be spelt out as stereotypical information or inconsistent stereotypical information
> > 14 neutral and 5 target words: e.g. S_Y, S_ORT, RI_E, POLI_E – (consistent or inconsistent information) e.g. (SHY not SPY)
DV: Number of stereotypically completed word fragments
Whilst completing the fragmentation task, half of the participants are cognitively busy (rehearse 8-digit number), other half were not
Stereotypes - Gilbert & Hixon (1991) - Application Phase
> > Did the same thing, a number reversal and a visual search task to be cognitively busy
Had to watch a video of the assistant describing a typical day in her life - half pp’s saw either caucasian / asian
- Half of the participants were again cognitively busy (visual search task)
DV: At the end they had to rate the assistant on stereotypical Asian traits (e.g., timid, intelligent, calm, etc.)
Stereotypes - Gilbert & Hixon (1991) - findings
> > Participants who were not busy during the first phase, but who were busy in the late phase made more stereotypical ratings of the asian assistant
> > Business of the application phase increased the subjects tendency to view the Asian assistant in a stereotypical term, but only if it the corresponding stereotypes had been activated previously in the first phase
Cognitive algebra - Impression formation is based on evaluation
> > Asked about your impression of someone you just met, e.g. friendly, entertaining, nice… this shows that impression formation is is based on evaluation and not description
> > Cognitive algebra is an approach to the study of impression formation that focuses on how we assign different positive and negative valence to attributes and how we combine these positives and negatives into a general evaluation of a person/event
- Impression formation is a matter of evaluation, not description
- Three principal models: summation, averaging, weighted averaging
Cognitive algebra - Summation
> > Summation refers to a process where the overall impression is simply the cumulative sum of each piece of information
It is a method of forming positive or negative impressions by adding all the positive and negative attributes of a person to come to a sum which if it is high is positive and low - negative impression
Therefore if someone wanted to make a particularly impressive/positive impression they would present all their positive attributes and conceal any potentially negative ones