social approach Flashcards
Milgram - background
Legitimate authority figures
=> someone we obey because we have been socialised to and we know there’ll be consequences if we don’t
Milgram - background
Agency theory
=> We shift between two states and bhv differently in different contexts
AUTONOMOUS state => act independently with free will
AGENTIC state => enter a state of obedience where we believe the authority figure will take responsibility
Milgram - background
“germans are different hypothesis”
- nazi germany could be explaind by the idea that germans are more obedient than other cultures
Milgram wanted to test this hypothesis
Milgram aim
- investigate what level of obedience would be shown when told to administer electric shocks to another person by an authority figure
milgram - sample
40 males
20 - 50 years old
new haven area (USA)
Milgram - sampling method
volunteer
paid $4.50
Milgram - research method
controlled observation
no clear IV or DV
in a controlled lab at Yale Uni
Milgram - procedure in a nutshell
- ‘assigned’ roles of teacher or learner (ppt always got teacher)
- ppts see Mr Wallace strapped into shock generator and ppts given 45v shock
- spelling test, if Mr W got it wrong ppts shocked him
- 15 V increments
- Jack williams gave standardised prods
- end when 450V given or refused
- Debreif
Milgram - findings
100% gave up to 300V shock (labeled very dangerous)
65% OBEYED & shocked up to 450V
- ppts showed nervousness and tension
- sweated, trembled
Milgram - conclusions
- no such thing as an obedient type of person
- everyone enters agentic state and obeys
- germans are NOT different
Milgram - explanations for obedience
- Prestigious Yale Uni - important place
2. Jack Williams dressed in white lab coat and was stern - seemed like a legitimate authority figure.
Bocchiaro - background
what is a whistleblower
someone who reports unethical bhv to a higher authority figure
Bocchiaro - background
what did Bocc believe there was little understanding of in M’s study
- nature of dis/obedience and whistleblowing to unjust authority
- individual chara’s of those who disobey
- responses to authority in men and women
Bocchiaro - aim
=> investigate rates of obedience, disobedience and whistleblowing when request was ethically wrong
Bocchiaro - research method
lab / scenario study
8 pilot tests used to make cover story credible
=> lab at VU Uni in Amsterdam
Bocchiaro - sample
149 undergrad students
96 women, 53 men
gained course credit or €7
Bocchiaro - procedure in a nutshell
- greeted by stern dutch experimenter (formally dressed)
- asked ppts to recommend 3 friends to take part in extremely harmful study into sensory deprivation
- given 3 mins alone to decide to dis/obey/WB
- 7 mins to do what decided
- given 2 personality tests => HEXACO & SVO
- debriefed & sign consent form